well, I'm not sure why so many people believe Taina deserves some kind of punishment. What is the basis? Sorry, but I'm about to white knight 0_0.
SPOILERS: Read at yo own risk
Taina:
Warned Tsug about the first attack
-with the intention to protect Megan and her d00d.
--expecting them to step down peacefully.
Helped MEGAN escape
-with the expectation that she doesn't come back,
--and didn't expect Megan to also free Tsug, but she did.
Intended to usurp the usurpers immediately after the attack
-had the chance to kill him in the bedroom on day 1, but didn't.
-helped him get Vica.
-Rescued him from the mutants.
-Voluntarily admitted that she planned to kill him instead of lying.
For Taina to deserve punishment means that what she did is somehow immoral or terrible in comparison to, let's say MC.
MC:
Made a deal to have Pino marry Danka
-took Danka, forced Bahuton to accept, and made up some bs about being a mutant as an excuse(optional, but how many players actually let Pino have her???)
Took Cat from Adam
-while Adam is a reasonable d00d that didn't even abuse her, nor did he wrong MC.
forced Cuman to submit to his will.
-when Cuman respected him by not buying the previous lord's concubines.
-was following the law and loyalty to his "friend".
Wants to take over the city, which basically means betraying Patricia(not optional, he literally said he will bend the city to his will)
-when Patricia accepted him and treated him fairly
Promised Vica that he'd make her queen.
-He also told Jerry that wastelanders are honest, so if he lying to his "housemate", that's even worse.
Took Anabelle away from Nelson just because she asked for it when it wasn't his business
-not sure if he was going to use her as a bargaining chip or what.
When comparing MC to Taina, she doesn't even come close to deserving anything.
And then there's the "optional" getting slaves from raids. I will not count that part since it's kind of necessary for gameplay purposes.