I would, again, caution about making generalizations about stuff like this. Weed makes most people chill and relaxed, but I knew a guy it made (even more) violent and aggressive (than he already was. I absolutely hated that dude, but that's a different story for a different day.) I also know someone with ADHD who often took coke to chill him out. It's rare, but it happens. In fact, that's exactly how amphetamines are prescribed: it makes normal people hyperactive, but it's prescribed to hyperactive people specifically to help them chill out. This obviously doesn't really address your (valid, imo) criticisms with the effect of molly on the characters, but I just wanted to point out that some drugs DO have different, and sometimes opposite, effects on individuals. Ecstasy can definitely be one of those drugs.
Sure, but I think you are nitpicking on my point, and I concede that there are different uses, but what amphetamines do is exactly the same thing as with everyone else, with the difference that ADHD people usually already have (memory help me out here) dopamine issues and amphetamines help them with that, as they do with everyone else.
K is used for helping with depression symptoms, but doesn't work with everyone in the long term for example, it is all matter of brain chemicals.
If we want to move out of pure brain chemicals I had different experiences with ecstacy myself, mostly when I mixed it with alcohol, in fact I still have a pretty vivid and VERY unpleasant memory about a specific day from more than 20 years ago.
So I agree with you on that, and I am glad you agree with my point on ex.
For the rest, I agree, constructive criticism is helpful, and I'm glad you're supporting him financially. I haven't really paid attention to exactly who is giving what criticism with what tone, so this isn't directed at you by any means... but let's just say a lot of the criticism here isn't exactly constructive, and very little of it is empathetic. Some of it is downright preposterous. I find much of them to be childish and entitled, as it tends to be in many of the f95zone comment sections. Especially for non-vanilla games. ESPECIALLY for NTR games. It's why I very rarely participate in discussions here, but I was so excited about this game and sad that it's over (for now) that I couldn't help myself from commenting. That said, I truly hope the author doesn't read this board.
I agree with you, some comments, especially about Lacey are not...great (death wishes etc).
I actually made a post I sort of regretted and subsequentely deleted, since I thought I was being overtly harsh, I obviously didn't change my mind over the topics I presented.
I think the dev actually reads the board, but this is just my speculation since many topics brought here then find a way in the story, and I hope he can understand that a post full of unsubstanciated hatred for a character might just be an emotional reaction from a reader and not an attack on him personally.
Me? I try to post helpful stuff (and too MANY quotes from the material), and I hope it is received as such.
Anyway, I'm not here to think much about whether he used a crutch or not, or the inner workings of his development process, or to pick apart or analyze the thing. For me, this story is an emotional journey I am happy to take with the author, and I simply wanted to express how spectacular I think the whole project is and how grateful I am that it exists. I just downloaded it for a quick fap, and here I am days later, unable to get it out of my head. The entirety of my free time between work, social obligations, and sleep has been dedicated to this game. I've never been this emotionally invested in a VN before. I think it's something truly special.
You see, we think very alike, but with everything or anyone that you would be affectionate to, you would want them to shine as brightly as they can.
And then my analyzing mind kicks in, and I analyze things that I like, I do not analyze things I do not care about.
Same as you, L&J is the only novel I actually enjoy, and I am also on the journey, it still doesn't stop me to want to see greater heights (tbh some were already achieved).
I still think you're making effects of drugs more objective than they are. I am a VERY anxious person with a diagnosed panic disorder, and the entire reason I got into speed was because it got me out of my head and made me feel invincible. Despite physically agitating me, it took away my anxiety almost completely because it stopped me from second-guessing everything I say and do. On speed, I just... said and did them without thinking. This sounds completely opposite of your experience, which is fine, but it goes directly against the description you are defining as objective.
I think you may be a bit off-base with your belief in the objectivity of these drugs. Or, to put it a different way, the physical ways these drugs affect people are the same - those are chemical and mechanical facts - but the way those physical effects manifest in behavior, thought, feelings, mood, etc. can vary significantly.
Glad to hear you're defending Lacey though! She deserves it.
I addressed what you mention at the top.
And I clarified my thoughts about what I tried to convey which is exactly what you mention.
For example if in universe we say that ex lowers inhibitions etc, it is still very silly that the lowered inhibitions are only relative to everyone else but MC.
But you agreed with this point, so lets leave it at that.
Lacey is my favourite character, she needs to be held accountable, but people need to fucking read the material and try to understand her.
In act 2 I wrote a LOT about her growth and how she was trying her damn best and still fell flat (think KW she made a mess out of it by choosing the wrong topics, trusting the wrong people and setting the wrong rules).
Her trauma does not excuse every shitty thing that she does, she does need to face the music.
But the TOTAL lack of empathy is quite surreal.
In fact my high criticism of Lacey in this act is that she was sadly forced in the drama, while there were already many many hooks to create the drama and have the same fights over and over (
professors, the still unattented topic of the dick naming/toothbrushes/damian/porn/internet videos).
I'll leave you with a silly thought, MC and Lacey are looking for "firsts" (and things to share between them, Lacey dialogue in act 1) it was the first plane trip for their anniversary, I cannot see her simply sitting with the girls and mostly ignoring MC.
If I read Lacey even in act 1, she would be snuggled to him with a fucking smile beamed on her face (the drama can still be injected or be present, I am not advocating for a fairytale).
This is why I am trying to bring to attention to the author and to anyone else that love this novel these flaws, forced drama is easier to write, but really deforms the characters that have already been written.
I'm not disagreeing with you. But since the question came up, I'm wondering what behaviors are considered common for those two drugs (understanding that some variance is expected)...
And for those who might not get what I'm saying: do these drugs tend to release "the real you" as alcohol does (lowering inhibitions) or would they actually induce something else?
I think Ficken gave a very good answer there, his english is definitely better than mine.
I only have to disagree on the mind altering part, and this is where a lot of the subjectiveness comes in, shrooms were way more mind altering for me (there are various kinds).
Ex does not make you bring out your real self, actually I do not think even alcohol brings your real self out.
Inhibitions are definitely a part of you.
I only took ex at clubs and raves, and I would dance a lot without stopping and touch a lot, heck the dancing would be mostly rubbing and touching each other.
I always have a hard time to explain, but for me ex was a VERY tactile experience, I would hug and kiss a lot, I loved the feeling of even running my own hands on my body, can I describe it as tingling? (I apologize for my piss poor english).
I felt extremely happy, very close to people, the colors were "bright" and "vivid".
If you are interesed, since I have a tendency to ramble on, I can also talk about the bad part of it.