May 14, 2020
24
52
The sandbox seems pointless since almost nothing is optional except for the futa content, thank god.
My remaining options are to "have fun with Amy" (didn't I just say no?) or buy magic crystals (playing with incest and I'm not going to upload pics of my sister or any LI to creeps like me to fap to, so money is an issue).
Can't proceed with Katie without advancing other storylines, which I don't want to do. I liked Katie because she seemed the least slutty, but she's quickly turning me off with all the sudden topless scenes, dirty talk and the very ominous and foreboding drawer of sex toys. She also was fine with the MC being with other girls, which in my playthrough he hadn't, barring the forced ones with Serena.

I get it, this wasn't made for me, that's fine but the option not to have relations with characters would be nice. Not everyone can fap to an orgie, call it a purity fetish. I would be satisfied with just the optional removal of some dialogues, no need to write extra lines ore anything. Like if Claire hadn't mentioned enjoying Amy's appendage or if Serena and the MC hadn't discussed the exhibitionism, I would still be interested in these characters. Or if you could just remain friends with them, and not have the sex scenes be a requirement for progression, I don't want to know where the "handjob" wager with Amy goes, as the last dialogue with her said "we're friends", I don't know about you, but me and my friends don't jerk each other off.
 

GrammerCop

Well-Known Member
Donor
Mar 15, 2020
1,731
1,705
Maybe it was mentioned before but i stumbled over a prpblem with the phone for a pool invite.
It seems the phone wont apper if your progress with claire isnt far enough.
The hint told me i should try to invite amy but i had no phone icon but after speking with claire and getting
the same hint for her the phone appeard.
For Claire, you may need to purchase some equipment.
For Amy, try the pool at different times of the day.
 

PTGames

Developer of Lunar's Chosen
Donor
Respected User
Game Developer
Sep 17, 2018
2,185
3,638
(playing with incest and I'm not going to upload pics of my sister or any LI to creeps like me to fap to, so money is an issue).

She also was fine with the MC being with other girls, which in my playthrough he hadn't, barring the forced ones with Serena.

I get it, this wasn't made for me, that's fine

I would be satisfied with just the optional removal of some dialogues, no need to write extra lines ore anything.
Complaining about playing with an unofficial mod turning the game into something else is a weird complaint, just don't play with the mod?

Again, complaining about only playing part of the game and the rest not making sense because of that is strange.

So you want me to change the game entirely so it is made for you? Otherwise I'm unsure why if you recognise the game isn't for you, you're here complaining about it.

Even without having to write extra, making things optional while keeping things coherent is a lot of work.

Sorry if that seems snappy, I'm just confused as to why you would bring up those particular points when they all seem self defeating. Except that last one, that's fair, but again would be a lot of work. I'm sorry the game isn't to your liking, but it's not going to be for everyone. I'd rather focus on keeping what I'm doing going for those that enjoy it, than water things down to appeal to a larger audience and losing quality in the process.
 
May 14, 2020
24
52
Complaining about playing with an unofficial mod turning the game into something else is a weird complaint, just don't play with the mod?

Again, complaining about only playing part of the game and the rest not making sense because of that is strange.

So you want me to change the game entirely so it is made for you? Otherwise I'm unsure why if you recognise the game isn't for you, you're here complaining about it.

Even without having to write extra, making things optional while keeping things coherent is a lot of work.

Sorry if that seems snappy, I'm just confused as to why you would bring up those particular points when they all seem self defeating. Except that last one, that's fair, but again would be a lot of work. I'm sorry the game isn't to your liking, but it's not going to be for everyone. I'd rather focus on keeping what I'm doing going for those that enjoy it, than water things down to appeal to a larger audience and losing quality in the process.
Mod is irrelevant, the issue stands. I wouldn't do it to an LI. My girls tits are for me, not for sale for a dollar a week.

Not all of it interests me, clearly. But that was more of a continuity issue, the scene played like actions had been performed when they hadn't.

I have an opinion, but I'm fine with it being ignored because I accept that I'm not the only one around. I don't see why I can't voice that opinion nonetheless.

Not in the case of just editing some lines of dialogue. These weren't vital pieces of story, just some small flavors that could have easily not been there. What is gained by me hearing that Futa-Amy boinked Claire? Could just not have had that.

My main issue is that all of these kinks are forced when they needn't necessarily be. If you are going for the audience who likes Sluts, Futa, Exhibitionism, Lesbianism and whatever the uploading of your girlfriends nudes to a porn site is, that's great!
More power to you for following through with your goal! But on the off chance that you don't want to alienate those that don't enjoy this specific fetish combo, I thought I'd speak up. My tastes are vanilla, I understand that, but you can have vanilla and pistachio at your ice cream shop without selling your artistic soul.
Just because something appeals to more people doesn't mean it's less than something that appeals to fewer. Quality is not based on how niche something is.

You can be snappy, you spent countless hours on this, it's a part of you. I respect that.
Realize that most criticism comes from a place where I'm getting into the characters and the game when things take a turn that kills the appeal for me, I liked everything I'm not complaining about, so take heart in that. The writing is good, the characters are interesting and the renders are very nice.

I can't spank my monkey to your game, but I love you anyway. Thanks for the response!
 
Last edited:

PTGames

Developer of Lunar's Chosen
Donor
Respected User
Game Developer
Sep 17, 2018
2,185
3,638
Mod is irrelevant, the issue stands. I wouldn't do it to an LI. My girls tits are for me, not for sale for a dollar a week.

Not all of it interests me, clearly. But that was more of a continuity issue, the scene played like actions had been performed when they hadn't.

I have an opinion, but I'm fine with it being ignored because I accept that I'm not the only one around. I don't see why I can't voice that opinion nonetheless.

Not in the case of just editing some lines of dialogue. These weren't vital pieces of story, just some small flavors that could have easily not been there. What is gained by me hearing that Futa-Amy boinked Claire? Could just not have had that.

My main issue is that all of these kinks are forced when they needn't necessarily be. If you are going for the audience who likes Sluts, Futa, Exhibitionism, Lesbianism and whatever the uploading of your girlfriends nudes to a porn site is, that's great!
More power to you for following through with your goal! But on the off chance that you don't want to alienate those that don't enjoy this specific fetish combo, I thought I'd speak up. My tastes are vanilla, I understand that, but you can have vanilla and pistachio at your ice cream shop without selling your artistic soul.
Just because something appeals to more people doesn't mean it's less than something that appeals to fewer. Quality is not based on how niche something is.

You can be snappy, you spent countless hours on this, it's a part of you. I respect that.
Realize that most criticism comes from a place where I'm getting into the characters and the game when things take a turn that kills the appeal for me, I liked everything I'm not complaining about, so take heart in that. The writing is good, the characters are interesting and the renders are very nice.

I can't spank my monkey to your game, but I love you anyway. Thanks for the response!
I wasn't snappy about receiving criticism, I was just confused by those particular points. Although this follow up explanation clears up a couple of them.

The reason not much is avoidable is because it's part of who those characters are. The idea of the game isn't individual characters, but the group as a whole. So having some parts being optional would dilute the relationships between characters. For example, the part about Claire boinking Amy shows they have a very close house mate/friend relationship, which will play into later scenes.

Uploading the pictures is 100% required, there are points that require all the images to be uploaded (such as unlocking the photostudio) which couldn't be done if people were just picking and choosing certain ones to upload. It's also the only way to earn money in the game, so it can't be optional or that creates money balancing issues. While I understand not everyone would be happy about sharing their girls images online irl, I'm surprised that's an issue in a game, especially where other than you uploading it, you never run into anyone that's actually seen them (that's one thing that won't ever be in the game as that crosses a line for a lot of people).

While I would love to be able to do something extremely modular, that's just not how this game works. It's designed around all the characters being involved, with each of them having their own unique traits. I'm certainly not ignoring your opinion, unfortunately there just isn't much I can do to appease it as your main issues are the main concepts of the game.

But I do apologise for the tone of my previous post, you just caught me on a particularly grumpy day, so I'm sorry for that :)
 
May 14, 2020
24
52
I wasn't snappy about receiving criticism, I was just confused by those particular points. Although this follow up explanation clears up a couple of them.

The reason not much is avoidable is because it's part of who those characters are. The idea of the game isn't individual characters, but the group as a whole. So having some parts being optional would dilute the relationships between characters. For example, the part about Claire boinking Amy shows they have a very close house mate/friend relationship, which will play into later scenes.

Uploading the pictures is 100% required, there are points that require all the images to be uploaded (such as unlocking the photostudio) which couldn't be done if people were just picking and choosing certain ones to upload. It's also the only way to earn money in the game, so it can't be optional or that creates money balancing issues. While I understand not everyone would be happy about sharing their girls images online irl, I'm surprised that's an issue in a game, especially where other than you uploading it, you never run into anyone that's actually seen them (that's one thing that won't ever be in the game as that crosses a line for a lot of people).

While I would love to be able to do something extremely modular, that's just not how this game works. It's designed around all the characters being involved, with each of them having their own unique traits. I'm certainly not ignoring your opinion, unfortunately there just isn't much I can do to appease it as your main issues are the main concepts of the game.

But I do apologise for the tone of my previous post, you just caught me on a particularly grumpy day, so I'm sorry for that :)
I can respect that, fair enough.
Does the nature of Claire and Amy's relationship have to be sexual in order to show that they're close, though? Couldn't she have been supportive without jumping on the magical dick? To me it doesn't show that they had a close relationship, it tells me that Claire will jump on a dick far too gladly. This was after I selected "disable futa content", too.

The MC becomes sleazy by persuading these girls to participate in his photoshoots, uploading these pictures to pornsites and taking all the profit from it.
I don't like uploading any pictures of anyone, not just some characters, my issue is that it's a morally gross act that you don't need for the story but force upon the player. You could have just have the MC take legit pictures rather than lewd ones and achieve the same result without having the girls' nudes published online specifically for the purpose of wank material.

That's fair, I've got no issues with that at all. Respect.


No apology necessary. Thanks for the response, much love!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valeck

PTGames

Developer of Lunar's Chosen
Donor
Respected User
Game Developer
Sep 17, 2018
2,185
3,638
I can respect that, fair enough.
Does the nature of Claire and Amy's relationship have to be sexual in order to show that they're close, though? Couldn't she have been supportive without jumping on the magical dick? To me it doesn't show that they had a close relationship, it tells me that Claire will jump on a dick far too gladly. This was after I selected "disable futa content", too.

The MC becomes sleazy by persuading these girls to participate in his photoshoots, uploading these pictures to pornsites and taking all the profit from it.
I don't like uploading any pictures of anyone, not just some characters, my issue is that it's a morally gross act that you don't need for the story but force upon the player. You could have just have the MC take legit pictures rather than lewd ones and achieve the same result without having the girls' nudes published online specifically for the purpose of wank material.
For later stories, yes :p Although if you still got the image of them fucking being displayed on the non futa route, that's not meant to happen. If you were just told about it, that is intentional on that route.

As for the pictures, uploading them would be sleezy if 1. He wasn't making a career out of photography and as everyone knows, sex sells and 2. All the women consent. I even made sure to put it into the conversation in some of the shoots that he reminds them they'll be going online and they all are ok with it. At which point, it becomes their choice, not the MC's which shouldn't really offend anyone unless they're against women choosing they're happy with their body being viewed publicly.

Also this is a porn game, it'd be a bit strange going the conservative route to specifically avoid additional nudity :p
 

spellbreaker

Member
Aug 24, 2017
415
1,313
Soon ;)

Or you can pledge on Patreon and get it right now :p
What are the plans for Meg right now? Is she going to remain dickless for now and then in the future have the player chose if she should get her appendage back? Also will the relationship be something like with Amy where she changes who tops and bottoms from time to time?
 
Last edited:

BobKillgin

New Member
Apr 25, 2020
6
0
What are the plans for Meg right now? Is she going to remain dickless for now and then in the future have the player chose if she should get her appendage back? Also will the relationship be something like with Amy where she changes who tops and bottoms from time to time?
Who is Meg?
 

lemonfreak

The Freakiest of Lemons
Oct 24, 2018
5,397
10,080
I can asked dev really deletel version Android?:(
Dev had nothing to do with it, the port is made by a third party. Apparently, last time it was updated the wrong link was so that was removed. Wait a day or 2 and someone should update it, in the meantime you could always make a request in the here
 

Abhai

Devoted Member
Sep 12, 2018
8,895
36,795
Lunars Chosen [v0.10 Patreon] [PTGames] (838 MB rar pc source)
336 MB rar unofficial win compressed (slightly reduced image/video/audio quality):
done by Cruncher v0.4.1(BAS@f95zone)
 
Last edited:
3.90 star(s) 87 Votes