If only the MC, or his friend Jack, or the asshole who touched her without her consent, or even the asshole's friend wasn't one, but in this case, I think most women would rather become lesbians than a slimy old fart's wives or baby mamas.
The old idiot made a bet with Jack on who's gonna fuck her first... don't think that sounds like he has a lot of fucks to gives for her except the literal ones he implied he already gave her, so no, he don't care about her well-being at all. He's just a wannabe pirate going back to the sea once he's done fucking and probably impregnating her, if he lives long enough to see her get pregnant and give birth to their kids, and being an old pirate at least in his 60s doesn't make him too much of a stable relationship either.
In the NTR route, she says his was the biggest dick she's had, so relax, she don't look older than 22 and she definitely ain't
that innocent either, but we can pretend she's as innocent as she pretends to be and she only refuses to fuck the MC, cuz it's only inappropriate when he wants to fuck her.
I know, but it's the same thing in almost the same context. MC's GF got fucked by a random fucker thinking it was him doing it, despite how unlikely to believe and ridiculous that scene was, and Jane acts like the old, ugly bastard's GF after he saves her, so there could've been an option for the MC to fuck her too after Hank got too drunk or too tired and her too horny to fall asleep or something less rapey than that scene was, just like that other ugly bastard fucked his GF, since they both were strangers and, you know, favorable circumstances to take advantage of.