shiama

Newbie
Feb 23, 2018
18
12
I didn't even say Milf City is a bad game. It's a good game and im waiting for next update. IN MY OPINION, Milf City is overrated and not good as BADIK. Thats all. That doesn't make me troll, does it?
No, the "kid" and trying to push it in people's faces and starting this discussion about which is the best in the first place, THAT makes you a troll. Stop trying to hide, at least own up to what you are.
 

Q Who

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 16, 2017
1,718
1,794
I didn't even say Milf City is a bad game. It's a good game and im waiting for next update. IN MY OPINION, Milf City is overrated and not good as BADIK. Thats all. That doesn't make me troll, does it?
He probably meant me. Don't worry about it. I sure didn't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MeetYourMaker

Seagal

Active Member
Oct 10, 2017
548
2,234
You just don't say why it is better. To say it is a better porn game without any reason as to why. is simply pointless. Your reply is not I like Milfy for these content reasons. Your reply is merely this. I like Milfy City better because I like it better. Not much of an argument in support but typical.
What other reason do I need? Are you trying to argue just to argue? I did give a reason, and I even said I liked that other game also. I said I like nukige better than your average eroge visual novel. It's not my fault if you don't know the terms or the sub genres.

You realize your comment is the one that's entirely pointless right? Whatever reason you or I could give for liking either game in terms of story, content, etc, is entirely subjective or opinion. You could give literally any reason you want for liking either game more or less and it would be fine. You're trying to argue just to argue, and that's typical from a troll.

Not going to respond to you again. I've said my peace, and the conversation is no longer productive. It never was in fact.
 

Q Who

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 16, 2017
1,718
1,794
What other reason do I need? Are you trying to argue just to argue? I did give a reason, and I even said I liked that other game also. I said I like nukige better than your average eroge visual novel. It's not my fault if you don't know the terms or the sub genres.

You realize your comment is the one that's entirely pointless right? Whatever reason you or I could give for liking either game in terms of story, content, etc, is entirely subjective or opinion. You could give literally any reason you want for liking either game more or less and it would be fine. You're trying to argue just to argue, and that's typical from a troll.

Not going to respond to you again. I've said my peace, and the conversation is no longer productive. It never was in fact.
There is just as much sex in BAD as there is in Milfy. By your metric BAD is also a nukige. Fuck every game here almost is nukige. People should just admit that the idea of fucking mommy is what they find appealing.

BTW you said you were not responding B4. My subsequent post to you as a comment. I never asked you to clarify anything, I asked the other poster why he felt that way.
 

Viressa

Well-Known Member
May 24, 2018
1,522
3,210
I played a little of DIK. None of the characters hit any of my fetish buttons (and they're not particularly difficult buttons to hit: Big titty moms, big titty teachers, big titty older sisters, submissive personalities, bdsm). Milfy City has Celia and Linda, who while not perfect (they could both be much thiccer for my taste) I like both of them a lot. DIK's girls are all skinny barbie dolls with completely vanilla routes.

And the story... well, it's a consistent problem for me that I completely fail to connect with male characters on an emotional level. I don't care about your male MC, I don't care about his struggles, I don't care about his tragic backstory with his dead mom or whatever. If we must have a male MC, the best kind for me is a protagonist who's more or less an empty shell, with no real characterization or motivations, for me to inhabit and use to interact with the women characters. It's also much easier for me to slip into male characters on the younger/nerdier side as opposed to 20-something gymrat jock types. So the MC from Milfy City is more or less optimal, though I'd like a female protagonist even better.

DIK's protagonist absolutely does not want to be an empty shell, the writer wants him to be a fully fleshed out character, and I respect that. But it's a major obstacle to enjoying the game for me. And considering that there's nothing in this game worth pushing through that for... I dropped it before the first episode was over.


This is all personal taste, of course. My needs and priorities will be very different from anyone else's. Neither game is objectively superior here.
 

Q Who

Well-Known Member
Donor
May 16, 2017
1,718
1,794
I played a little of DIK. None of the characters hit any of my fetish buttons (and they're not particularly difficult buttons to hit: Big titty moms, big titty teachers, big titty older sisters, submissive personalities, bdsm). Milfy City has Celia and Linda, who while not perfect (they could both be much thiccer for my taste) I like both of them a lot. DIK's girls are all skinny barbie dolls with completely vanilla routes.

And the story... well, it's a consistent problem for me that I completely fail to connect with male characters on an emotional level. I don't care about your male MC, I don't care about his struggles, I don't care about his tragic backstory with his dead mom or whatever. If we must have a male MC, the best kind for me is a protagonist who's more or less an empty shell, with no real characterization or motivations, for me to inhabit and use to interact with the women characters. It's also much easier for me to slip into male characters on the younger/nerdier side as opposed to 20-something gymrat jock types. So the MC from Milfy City is more or less optimal, though I'd like a female protagonist even better.

DIK's protagonist absolutely does not want to be an empty shell, the writer wants him to be a fully fleshed out character, and I respect that. But it's a major obstacle to enjoying the game for me. And considering that there's nothing in this game worth pushing through that for... I dropped it before the first episode was over.


This is all personal taste, of course. My needs and priorities will be very different from anyone else's. Neither game is objectively superior here.
I do not dwell on the MC much at all myself either. I just find the dialog and situations much more believable. I am good so long as the girls are not loli looking. I find the girls quite similiar in all respects. I also find consentual sex more appealing than blackmail and rape. This is Icstors patter. He has a photo to blackmail his aunt into sex in incest story. The aunt who is bitchy like Celia. In milfy he has her job as blackmail for sex. I don't get your point of view though.
 

ijako3

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2017
1,016
2,519
I mean, Milfy City is the best porn game with really chill atmosphere and laid back story scenarios - BaDiK goes for a more serious environment, both appeal when certain mood is on.
BaDiK i will play once fully, just like acting lessons and then forget about it, Milfy City i can revisit and have some fun with it when it comes to overall gampleay.

As for renders and all this technical stuff Milfy City is still beyond BaDiK for me. :rolleyes:

And by the way what is it with BaDiK fans and their alt accounts or trying to push their favorite game everywhere they can? ;)
 

fried

Almost
Donor
Respected User
Former Staff
Nov 11, 2017
2,313
6,112
Uh, it's really a dumb conversation begun mostly due to trolling, but it's OK to like both games and prefer one over the other.

I personally find BAD interesting, in that its "attitude" pathing reminds me of Dr. Amana's (i.e., a game I happen to support) path choices with related consequences of choosing each path/attitude. I like that Dr. Pinkcake tries to offer more than one facet of personality for some characters (especially the MC, because they inherently get to act as different personalities by virtue of paths chosen). While I find many of the renders technically very good, sometimes they are just too polished or 2D in lighting quality for me. It's certainly a game I would recommend for people to try, as well as the predecessor "Acting Lessons," but not due to any competition with Milfy City.

Milfy City is an entirely different game in terms of how the play works, its intent and how rewards can occur. I feel it's one of the best for the type of open travel style - with lots of clues/triggers you need to search out - because it's both fun to look for clues and it offers top-notch graphics (for a Daz-based game) + strong personalities for the type of readily accessible action it's intended to offer. Although it doesn't represent my favorite type of adult gameplay (which I've stated before), I still appreciate it for what it is and the level of quality it offers in the adult game genre.
 

derof

Member
Jul 29, 2017
311
182
The only thing Milfy City got better is perhaps the technical quality of the renders (although his knowledge of anatomy is weird) and even this isn't by much.

Everything else from the character's development, music/sounds, and a actual story with branching choices Being a DIK does a whole LOT better.
Does that game has a incest too ?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Ahjgfg
3.70 star(s) 458 Votes