You guys are entitled to your opinion, but I don't think much of your opinion though, or hold really any value in anything you say because you're known trolls and haters of this game. Which is clearly evident from your nonstop posting in this thread. I'll entertain you with a response here one last time though.
And just an FYI - most people refer to a Visual Novel as a game, so if Milfy City isn't a game then neither is that other title.
Milfy City has better renders, posing, and animation. That really isn't for debate here either. Not to take away from that other creator, because I enjoy the game and even support him, but he's not as good as ICSTOR when it comes to those things. There's a few creators that are in that top tier with ICSTOR. The unnamed games creator is just a notch below them. Wish I could say more and give examples, but I know I shouldn't do that, and the mods scare me around here.
If you notice what I said in my post also, I said Milfy City is a better porn game, and I believe it is. If you want something with more of a story focus than maybe you'll enjoy that other title more. It's why I say Milfy City is a nukige, and that other game is a eroge with high sexual content. There's a different approach when it comes to story focus between the two. Look up the terms in you need to.
It just happens that I enjoy nukige a lot more than your average eroge visual novel. So that's why I say Milfy City in my opinion is a better game, but I won't call anyone crazy or anything for liking that other game more, because it's a great game.