Evangelion-01

Devoted Member
Apr 12, 2018
10,564
7,091
Mediocre compared to what? triple A games? If you would compare his games to other porn games than you would see that his stuff isn't that mediocre. Icstor's games are finished games, could they be expanded and be better? sure! But for the time those games came out, I think Icstor did a great job. The only other games I could even compare and they might be better in some aspects are: SS, TSL, and DoD.

His games are always so full of content, and the experience through the games is always smooth, never encountered a bug or something that really pissed me of. like a shit ton of no-content/buggy/grindy games.

And about this update, when he said he was at 65% before break. That was only Caroline's content, but now he added Celia's and some Neighbor content as well. I am not gonna say that i am not a little bit disappointed with the time it takes, but i can at least appreciate the work that goes beyond the scenes... and so far Icstor has not even disappointed me once (In terms of content and stability).
I can see where you are coming from... but if you say that ICStor's games are great you certainly haven't searched or played really quality games thus far.
Milfy City is probably his first game that I would label great... unless he fucks things up with a rushed ending.

NamberFo4 I can say everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and I am not saying his previous games were bad... but medicore hits it quiet well for me.
The picture quality and the fact that we are not following the standard Blackmail/white knight routine with all characters so far makes it a different quality.
 
Last edited:

d4L

Newbie
May 4, 2017
15
65
I can see where you are coming from... but if you say that ICStor's games are great you certainly haven't searched or played really quality games thus far.
Milfy City is probably his first game that I would label great... unless he fucks things up with a rushed ending.

NamberFo4 I can say everyone is entitled to their own opinion, and I am not saying his previous games were bad... but medicore hits it quiet well for me.
The picture quality and the fact that we are not following the standard Blackmail/white knight routine with all characters so far makes it a different quality.
I completely agree with you on the Blackmail/white knight routine, he sure did a lot of it. but i think it's also because it was just beginning of the whole incest 3dcg games, and it worked quite well for him (in terms of popularity). I do think that his old story plots weren't the greatest, but at least the characters reactions to stuff was a a bit different within games (not by much, besides Milfy City).
But when it comes to content, nice renders, stability and consistency I think that Icstor has everyone beat, at least in the 3dcg incest category.

BTW, i played almost every incest game on this site, so believe me when i say i tried 95% of them
 
  • Like
Reactions: JesusIsDead

Volta

Well-Known Member
Apr 27, 2017
1,015
1,155
I completely agree with you on the Blackmail/white knight routine, he sure did a lot of it. but i think it's also because it was just beginning of the whole incest 3dcg games, and it worked quite well for him (in terms of popularity). I do think that his old story plots weren't the greatest, but at least the characters reactions to stuff was a a bit different within games (not by much, besides Milfy City).
But when it comes to content, nice renders, stability and consistency I think that Icstor has everyone beat, at least in the 3dcg incest category.

BTW, i played almost every incest game on this site, so believe me when i say i tried 95% of them
I'd argue that Timestamps and the Visit are good contenders, especially Timestamps for renders and animations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SubtleHustle

Evangelion-01

Devoted Member
Apr 12, 2018
10,564
7,091
I completely agree with you on the Blackmail/white knight routine, he sure did a lot of it. but i think it's also because it was just beginning of the whole incest 3dcg games, and it worked quite well for him (in terms of popularity). I do think that his old story plots weren't the greatest, but at least the characters reactions to stuff was a a bit different within games (not by much, besides Milfy City).
But when it comes to content, nice renders, stability and consistency I think that Icstor has everyone beat, at least in the 3dcg incest category.

BTW, i played almost every incest game on this site, so believe me when i say i tried 95% of them
Well sure if you limit yourself to the Incest only games there isn't that much variety... but there also quiet a number of games that simply contain some IC on the side while the mayority of the game is on corruption, hypnotism and others... and some aren't even on this site. Milfy City can compare to the games on mind... but his other games don't.
 

d4L

Newbie
May 4, 2017
15
65
Well sure if you limit yourself to the Incest only games there isn't that much variety... but there also quiet a number of games that simply contain some IC on the side while the mayority of the game is on corruption, hypnotism and others... and some aren't even on this site. Milfy City can compare to the games on mind... but his other games don't.
Well, i personally almost only play incest games, there is only a few other games that i'm interested in.
And hypnotism is kind of boring to me, well depends how it's done. but most times it's done in a very shallow way, and then the reactions from the characters just feel like robots, which i don't like very much.
And I would honestly love to hear about games that aren't on this site, cause I didn't find many out there.
 

desmosome

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 5, 2018
6,182
14,227
He should get some credit for being in the vanguard of western 3D incest genre. Honestly, he rode that wave to great heights but he also probably contributed quite a bit to the success of that genre. None of his old games hold up under scrutiny though. He has always been good at picking models and making quality renders/animations, but the writing and gameplay were atrocious. Milfy City is on another level compared to his old games because he got a writer on the team. Even so, this game is pretty average these days. It's your average vanilla incest game just without the head scratching nonsense plot like his old games.
 

boxedjack

Member
Apr 23, 2017
446
1,220
And about this update, when he said he was at 65% before break. That was only Caroline's content, but now he added Celia's and some Neighbor content as well.
Celia was always planned for 0.6. If I remember correctly, she wasn't even included in the character poll because she was a given even before Icstor started working on 0.6 since she hasn't received an update since 0.1.

That's one of the reasons some here doubt the 65%. For reference, they now both have about the same amount of content.
Was Celia originally only supposed to get half as much content as Caroline? That would put the development status with all renders and without any animations done at 97.5%.
Was Celia originally only supposed to get a third of the content that Caroline got? That would put the development status with the renders and without any animations done at 86.67%.

Consider the last two updates had about 1 animation for every 13 renders. How many renders are in one animation? I'd guess more than 13. If it is indeed more than 13 then that would mean the animations are more than half the work, at least in terms of rendering time. Posing is another issue.
 

PPanGames

Developer of Forbidden Passion and TlooB
Game Developer
May 8, 2019
311
2,716
Monday is the day you guys. I can't wait. Seems like I don't have to work too because Monday became a weekend day :^)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Hajtand
3.80 star(s) 415 Votes