Great, lets smear the shit some more.
Anyways, do you all differentiate between ntr being mentally stimulating/gripping and being really hot? Like I realized I can enjoy some pretty slop ntr out there, but its just since its really "sexy".
1) Be it the art, the voice acting etc, while the story itself isnt that great - these make for great replayability of just few scenes. Just load up a save for a quick wank (for example netorare princess for me - shit story, really hot animation). Now while the story isnt that great, the ntr is still there, so it cannot really be replaced by good art without the tag for me. Its like daily bread and butter.
2) Then you have games that are absolutely gripping with their story/writing (clipick games for example for me). You play the game and your heart is pounding, you get absolutely absorbed by the story and you really feel the ntr - these can have mediocre art, but they absolutely hit. The thing I realized is that while these games are masterpieces in my mind, I cant really replay them too much. I need to be "in" the story, but when just replaying a scene? Its really not that hot. And you never get that "first time" feeling when you played them.
I guess my conclusion is, that weirdly for replaying bits and pieces, the slop ends up trumping the masterpieces for me. Which is kinda sad, but emotional investment cannot be flicked on and off in a snap and I dont have 5 hours to just get in the "feel" of a good story game. Not to mention you cant catch that first time feeling again anyway.