Zara Scarlet

Engaged Member
Apr 3, 2022
2,531
3,392
I'm a bit torn when it comes to Ivy. If we're talking about negative influence, it's pretty clear on Holly's route, where Lena letting Ivy take the lead ends up hurting Holly. With Ian, though, it's less obvious. It often comes across as playful teasing or flirtation that Ian is free to resist or shut down. As for Lena, despite Ivy’s chaotic nature, she does seem to genuinely care about her best friend, even if she doesn’t always handle things the right way.


I wonder if there are routes where Ivy can be calmed down or become more "reasonable." I doubt Jeremy is a good match for her, even though he does seem to have a real soft spot for her. Then again, both of them tend to play around in relationships. I’m not sure if there will be future options for either Ian or Lena to actually get Ivy into something more stable that would have a positive impact on her.


So in the end, she’s definitely chaotic, but not really "evil." And she doesn’t quite come off as a true antagonist, even if she sometimes does things that are highly questionable.
When you say she's hurting Holly, that's a matter of opinion, depending on what kind of person you want Holly to be. If you want her to be sweet and relatively pure, well then I agree with you. But if you want her to be more outgoing, sexier and a lot more confident, then I don't agree with you at all. Under Ivy's influence, Holly seems reasonably happy. She's probably not going to write fantasy novels anymore, but she's certainly getting plenty of experience to move into erotic fiction. She's seems to have gotten over her crush on Ian, and is now obviously able to stand up to her parents and not have them dictate what she can or cannot do. Maybe Ivy is making her sluttier, but that could work for her, if she does cross over into erotic fiction. Particularly, if she starts copying Ivy and Lena, by posting sexy pics on Peoplegram, and develops a much larger social media following.

Jeremy is definitely not the right person for Ivy, because he just isn't ambitious enough. Ivy wants to be successful, and I don't see her settling for anyone else who isn't. Yeah, she'll probably hook up with him eventually, but she's hardly the kind of girl who's going to be overly impressed by Jeremy's big cock, which is pretty much the only thing he has going for him. But she's not going to settle down with anyone, anytime soon. If she did, it would have to be an open relationship. I can't see her settling for any situation, where she couldn't continue to play the field.

And I don't think anyone can really change Ivy, except Ivy herself. The only person who as any real influence over her, is Lena. Because she obviously loves Lena, or at least as close to loving someone as Ivy can get. But it's fairly clear that Lena doesn't want to change her, and accepts Ivy for who she is, even though sometimes that can be quite frustrating.
 
May 15, 2018
298
637
When you say she's hurting Holly, that's a matter of opinion, depending on what kind of person you want Holly to be. If you want her to be sweet and relatively pure, well then I agree with you. But if you want her to be more outgoing, sexier and a lot more confident, then I don't agree with you at all. Under Ivy's influence, Holly seems reasonably happy. She's probably not going to write fantasy novels anymore, but she's certainly getting plenty of experience to move into erotic fiction. She's seems to have gotten over her crush on Ian, and is now obviously able to stand up to her parents and not have them dictate what she can or cannot do. Maybe Ivy is making her sluttier, but that could work for her, if she does cross over into erotic fiction. Particularly, if she starts copying Ivy and Lena, by posting sexy pics on Peoplegram, and develops a much larger social media following.

Jeremy is definitely not the right person for Ivy, because he just isn't ambitious enough. Ivy wants to be successful, and I don't see her settling for anyone else who isn't. Yeah, she'll probably hook up with him eventually, but she's hardly the kind of girl who's going to be overly impressed by Jeremy's big cock, which is pretty much the only thing he has going for him. But she's not going to settle down with anyone, anytime soon. If she did, it would have to be an open relationship. I can't see her settling for any situation, where she couldn't continue to play the field.

And I don't think anyone can really change Ivy, except Ivy herself. The only person who as any real influence over her, is Lena. Because she obviously loves Lena, or at least as close to loving someone as Ivy can get. But it's fairly clear that Lena doesn't want to change her, and accepts Ivy for who she is, even though sometimes that can be quite frustrating.

I wasn’t really talking about Holly as much as I was focusing on Ivy and whether she should be seen as a more negative character in terms of influence and actions, possibly even one of the main antagonists. I was responding to someone who had placed Ivy in that category.

As for Holly, I’m fine with either of her routes. I don’t only go for the “pure” character paths in the game. That said, I think it’s worth discussing. While Ivy might help Holly open up sexually and even enjoy herself in the process, I’m not sure that such abrupt and radical methods are really good for her.

Holly is very innocent and impressionable. You can clearly see how easily she gets pulled into everything, with very little resistance. Sure, you could argue that she’s getting something out of it and even seems happy on that route, but I still think she’s at risk of facing real disappointments, negative experiences, and relationships that aren’t always healthy.

Unlike Holly, Ivy seems to have enough distance, experience and self-control to stay emotionally detached from those kinds of relationships. I’m less confident that Holly has that same ability. I’m also not entirely sure things will turn out well for her in the end. It all depends on what Eva Kiss has planned.

Will Holly become a sexually liberated, confident woman ? Or will she end up trapped in a cycle of throwaway relationships where she’s treated like an object, with little control over what’s happening, and ultimately hurt ? A lot could still happen. But for now, based on how this is being portrayed in the game, it doesn’t feel especially positive either.

And just to be clear, I’m not saying this from a moralizing or puritanical point of view. That’s not where I’m coming from, and it’s not part of my values.


I also have doubts about the Jeremy-Ivy relationship and what Eva Kiss might have planned for this route. At first glance, it seems unlikely that they’d have a serious relationship since they’re both players and more casual types. However, it does feel like there’s something going on, as they seem to have been circling each other for a while.

Ivy teases Jeremy a lot but doesn’t seem to give in to his advances. As far as we know, they haven’t slept together yet. Jeremy seems pretty fixated on Ivy, while she hesitates to take things further and asks Lena for advice. Jeremy himself looks a bit awkward and even asks Lena to put in a good word for him with Ivy to get a chance.

There’s definitely some tension between them at least. As for whether they’re really meant for each other, honestly, I have no idea. Maybe not. Ivy seems to prefer ambitious men who know what they want. Jeremy can come off as a bit immature and awkward in relationships, seeming like he just wants to have fun and doesn’t really own up to his mistakes.

That said, we don’t know much about Jeremy beyond the surface. His character feels pretty superficial so far. Maybe he can grow, whatever direction this goes. And whether Ivy and Jeremy could make a "balanced" couple ? I have no clue there either.


Regarding your last point, I wonder if Ivy will change, if she’s even capable of it, and whether that would be a good thing. Does Eva Kiss have different routes and possible developments planned for her, or will she just keep the same role and kind of influence she already has ? Honestly, I have no idea.

That said, I don’t really see her settling into an exclusive relationship or becoming "pure" or more tame sexually. I don’t think there will be any real romance with this character, even with Ian. I imagine only the “chad Ian” might interest her for a while, but it probably wouldn’t be a stable or permanent relationship.

For now, Ivy remains a fairly minor character. Given how far along we are in the game, I find it hard to imagine any radical or complete change in her personality. It remains to be seen what Eva Kiss has in store for her.
 
Last edited:

Geigi

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
2,496
5,673
There's certainly a point by which Holly becomes more outgoing, sexier and confident. Then she starts doing gloryholes.
The former is Ian's doing and the latter is Ivy's doing. You can guess which is positive and which is negative. Ivy's traits are manipulative/cunning, those two combined are not virtues. Just because she's Lena's friend, it doesn't mean she's being good to everyone else.
 
Last edited:

Maccabbee

Well-Known Member
Mar 26, 2024
1,335
2,227
The former is Ian's doing and the latter is Ivy's doing. You can guess which is positive and which is negative. Ivy's traits are manipulative/cunning, those two combined are not virtues. Just because she's Lena's friend, it doesn't mean she's being good to everyone else.
To be fair, I don't think she sees what she's doing as "bad," she just is having fun, but she definitely doesn't care or understand what is best for others (or herself, for that matter).
 
May 15, 2018
298
637
To be fair, I don't think she sees what she's doing as "bad," she just is having fun, but she definitely doesn't care or understand what is best for others (or herself, for that matter).
To me Ivy’s basically a Chaotic Neutral type D&D style. She’s not out to hurt anyone she just does what she thinks is fun even if it’s a bit reckless. She doesn’t really think about the consequences for other people and she couldn’t care less about rules or social expectations. She just follows her impulses.
 

BlandChili

Engaged Member
Dec 15, 2020
2,474
5,783
Is romance with the slutty Holly possible?
Unclear. It seems unlikely for Lena, since slut Holly specifically ends any doubts in that regard. With Ian she uses some of the same needy language their first time having sex, but so far neither she nor Ian seem to be pondering an actual relationship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ffive
May 15, 2018
298
637
When I launch the latest version it crashes before it gets to the main menu? Any idea on how to fix?


Strange, I haven’t had any issues on my end. Did you launch the game with an outdated mod by any chance ? It might help if you include the crash log in your post, so others can better understand what’s going on. You could also try doing a clean reinstall of the game without any mods or third-party content.

Also, try deleting your local save files in the game folder, along with any persistent data and saves in your AppData directory (AppData/Roaming/RenPy, delete the folders named "persistent" and "RedString-1574621830").
 
4.60 star(s) 360 Votes