As a new-ish AVN dev, I am always exploring other AVNs. In our community of AVN players, we have a wide assortment of fetishes and ideas for what the perfect adult visual novel should be. For me, I really didn't think Pale Carnations would be my thing. Boy, was I wrong.
Let me just start by saying that I am the type of player that prefers a wholesome story where the MC is at least trying to be a gentleman. I'm not into a lot of the crazy fetishes that are out there these days. Pale Carnations is one of the most well-written visual novels I have played. It constantly pokes at your moral compass and dares you to peek into that world. And even if you're not into the stuff happening in that world, you want to press on. You'll be faced with decisions where you're absolutely torn between them.
When those decisions come, don't be afraid to choose and explore the story because this writer knows what he is doing. Every story must have those bitter moments making the sweeter ones even sweeter. If you're like me, you will definitely reach decisions where nothing you would choose is among the choices. Do not let this deter you. Choose something you might not normally choose and let the story play out.
Each character is so well written that I found myself caring deeply for some, disgusted with others, and lusting after several. They are believable. Mina is so damn cute... but she's your best friend's girlfriend. Do you go after her? Is it NTR? Hell I don't know. I personally find all the NTR debating a waste of time and prefer to just experience the story the way the writer has written it. So yep, I'm going after Mina. (Sorry friend). It is just a fantasy story after all. Here, you can step into the shoes of a person who chooses to do things you might not normally do.
Graphics are very top notch. Animations are fluid (literally) with camera movements and great angles. The scenes are very erotic and the timing is flawless. Sex scenes are worked through, not just instantly in your face. I love that. These girls are all stunningly beautiful, very well designed, very sexy.
Choices matter. From what I have experienced, every choice has some affect on what you're going to experience. There are tons of lewd scenes already. Yep, some situations are intense. And may even piss you off. If they do piss you off, thank the writer because he did a freaking awesome job with this. Pale Carnations is one of those unusual gems. A dark secret, a guilty pleasure. I love it and can't wait to see where this ride takes me next. Job well done Mutt & Jeff.