VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Alfius]

From watching her on screen to watching her live on stage. She definitely has a big role in the future updates. Her hesitation in the beginning about Uncle Chuck and her being in just a towel in front of Ian and being very friendly with him. Ian having already banged his maid who has been taking care of him from childhood would surely have Mc mom in his sights. The developers can play it safe without having incest to avoid patreon censor. Mc gets to bang Rosalind who reminds him of his mother. I think Kathleen/Chuck/Ian would bring her into the club.

MC is already thinking about his mom when banging Rose, but not in a good way. (More like shamefully)

Ian might bang MCs mom as revenge for Mina. And it might involve the club.

I do think there is a 50/50 possibility we might see sexual action with the MC's mom (I hope not), but I don't see it happening as incest.

 

[Maverick369]

The only thing I can see making edwin lose his shit is if they put his mother into bondage and then gangbang her with the mother being a willing participant that is enjoying it.

 

[Maverick369]

The club may have been aware of Edwins dark side as a teenager because mother told them she needed the money to get his treatment and the plan all along was to get Edwin involved. The mother may also still be under contract to do something in future and participating in a carnation club event is part of that. Or maybe she was already a participant that won in the past and they will have a champion vs champion event. Who knows either way in order for Edwin to go darker he needs to lose his mom as a moral compass

 

[deadh30775n]

How many chapters have the dev intended for this game?

 

[Maverick369]

five plus epilouges. But this game is being done like half life 2 did in terms of episode 1 then episode two. There on average has been 3 to 4 updates for each chapter. They are just finishing chapter 3 with update 4 to include the second event. I understand that it is going to take two more years for the game to be completed.

 

[Cigzag]

Finally finished the update. And as everyone has been saying Mina's part was great. Was really fun making her cum her brains out. I wonder how affection vs. bully will turn out. Going by her fantasies bullying her might be more appropriate but then she also listed her playing the domme part so it'll be interesting to explore her fantasies either way.

But what struck me the most wasn't actually the sex scene. It was the transition to the bath tub. Regular Mina with her twin tails has that cutesy look and she's certainly pleasant on the eyes. But holy shit! Her with her hair down, no make-up and her green eyes .... She's beautiful! Just absolutely gorgeous. I just sat there for a few seconds. How can you do this? I usually have somewhat of an aversion of characters/people that put up that (fake) cutesy front but man once you pull the curtains apart was I blown away.


Anyway, taking a step back I bet everyone went down and dirty with Mina but I do wonder. If you keep your respectful distance to her and cover for Ian at all times to keep their relationship score as high as possible. Can you keep the two together?

Edit: Holy shit calling Mina at the end of the and she's already back at it again with a big ass magic wand. What did we wake in that girl?

Agreed. Mina is absolutely stunning and I always knew there was a naughty little minx behind that cutesy facade of hers. And yes, I think the "bully" choice outcomes were far better with Mina and really amped up the hotness of the scene, I actually don't know why it's called a bully choice though because it was hot and Mina was super in to it, it was just dominant if anything.

Hana used to be my favorite girl initially but these last couple of updates Mina has definitely stolen the show. They are all good and extremely well written however. This is the best VN out at the moment, there's no competition.

 

[MilesEdgeworth]

Sounds like the mom as a sexual being is wishful thinking for some people. Theres no indication that mom will have anything to do with the club or edwin and to have her all of a sudden do that would come out of nowhere. Why would she even get involved in that from a narrative point?

 

[Alfius]

Sounds like the mom as a sexual being is wishful thinking for some people. Theres no indication that mom will have anything to do with the club or edwin and to have her all of a sudden do that would come out of nowhere. Why would she even get involved in that from a narrative point?

100% This.

Of course things can always happen. Especially with Ian that always had a crush on her, but so far there has been no indication that anything will happen with her.

 

[Maverick369]

I’m just speculating on what the final thing will be that causes Edwin to lose his shit allowing for his complete turn to the dark side. After all it was the death of a Anakins mom that started that path.

 

[kurosx]

After all it was the death of a Anakins mom that started that path.

So, in the next game Edwin will be the Dark Helmet of a porn empire?

 

[Maverick369]

LOL you never know. He did say that he worked better with video than a camera. Remember that Kathlean did say that the medium used needs to match the artist at the end of the last update when he delivered the photos.

 

[Lindien]

Can we expect an update download eventually? , would be cool as the game's starting to become heavy and on the limit of mega free download...just asking no big deal.

 

[Maverick369]

His updates usually take 10 to 16 weeks to do or roughly 4 a year. meaning there is probably another 10 updates needed to complete the game

 

[Lindien]

I mean as i see it on the front page theres no ways to download just the updates, i have to download the entire game each time there's an update?

 

[ename144]

I’m just speculating on what the final thing will be that causes Edwin to lose his shit allowing for his complete turn to the dark side. After all it was the death of a Anakins mom that started that path.

I think the death of Victoria is more likely to be the instigating event for the MC than her joining the Club, but even that's a bit on the unlikely side (and I sincerely hope we won't see it).

I think the MC's point of no return is probably going to be something that happens at the Club. We know Kathleen has a scheme in the works AND is working overtime to convince the MC to embrace the dark side. It seems simple enough for the MC to face escalating opportunities to enjoy the suffering of those around him until we finally hit some sort of breaking point where the MC either flinches and commits to helping others (leading to conflict with Kat) or jumps headlong off the slippery slope (with Kat as an eager ally).

 

[desmosome]

Quick question to the devs. What will happen if two or all 3 girls have the same score for the shoot points?

 

[Turret]

Quick question to the devs. What will happen if two or all 3 girls have the same score for the shoot points?

While I am not one of the Devs, there is a passage during the talk with Kath when he brings the photos in. You can tell which Carnation you liked the most during the shoot. Your choice and one of Kath will seemingly push the voting towards one girl.

 

[desmosome]

While I am not one of the Devs, there is a passage during the talk with Kath when he brings the photos in. You can tell which Carnation you liked the most during the shoot. Your choice and one of Kath will seemingly push the voting towards one girl.

That choice gives +1 shoot points for whoever you pick. I'm wondering what happens if after that choice, you have the same points for all 3.

 

[Turret]

That choice gives +1 shoot points for whoever you pick. I'm wondering what happens if after that choice, you have the same points for all 3.

Maybe that point acts like a tiebreaker or since we have to remember Kath with her sadism, she might introduce a "tiebreak" game.

 

[Maverick369]

Im just curious how lewd and debauched exhibition 2 is going to be. I suspect whips, chains and stocks are going to eventually make it into the game as well as possible gangbang.