VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[strangelandQQ]

Where did the theory that Victoria was doing porn before Edwin was born even come from?
This isn't the first time I've seen similar comments and posts (was catching up on a thread from the release date of a new chapter).
The prologue came out in 2020, we can assume the action takes place in the present day. In game time, it's been 2 months or so. Some flashbacks with Victoria are dated 2009-2010, based on camera time.
There's a birthday scene in the game for Edwin, he turned 22. He is supposed to be 11-12 years old at the time of filming these particular scenes.
Unless he wasn't born 12 years old

 

[Thor875]

Where did the theory that Victoria was doing porn before Edwin was born even come from?
This isn't the first time I've seen similar comments and posts (was catching up on a thread from the release date of a new chapter).
The prologue came out in 2020, we can assume the action takes place in the present day. In game time, it's been 2 months or so. Some flashbacks with Victoria are dated 2009-2010, based on camera time.
There's a birthday scene in the game for Edwin, he turned 22. He is supposed to be 11-12 years old at the time of filming these particular scenes.
Unless he wasn't born 12 years old

Why can we assume that the action takes place in the present? It is a fictional story.

 

[ffive]

Why can we assume that the action takes place in the present? It is a fictional story.

Edwin gets a usb stick from Kat with recording of previous exhibition. The video is dated 2017. Given the exhibitions as well as the club have only existed for a few years, it is reasonable to guesstimate the game to take place in 2018 or so. Maybe a year later. This aligns with Victoria doing her first porn in 2009 when Edwin was in mid school and had his "episode".

 

[TD1900]

I'm pretty sure there's a lock screen on someone's phone that has the year as 2020.
If not, I guess you can use this comment as confirmation.

 

[Fuzzy Nuts J]

Edwin gets a usb stick from Kat with recording of previous exhibition. The video is dated 2017. Given the exhibitions as well as the club have only existed for a few years, it is reasonable to guesstimate the game to take place in 2018 or so. Maybe a year later. This aligns with Victoria doing her first porn in 2009 when Edwin was in mid school and had his "episode".

as the Development started in 2019 I think a safe guess would be 'present' is 2019

 

[Thor875]

Edwin gets a usb stick from Kat with recording of previous exhibition. The video is dated 2017. Given the exhibitions as well as the club have only existed for a few years, it is reasonable to guesstimate the game to take place in 2018 or so. Maybe a year later. This aligns with Victoria doing her first porn in 2009 when Edwin was in mid school and had his "episode".

Thanks

Edwin gets a usb stick from Kat with recording of previous exhibition. The video is dated 2017. Given the exhibitions as well as the club have only existed for a few years, it is reasonable to guesstimate the game to take place in 2018 or so. Maybe a year later. This aligns with Victoria doing her first porn in 2009 when Edwin was in mid school and had his "episode".

Thanks, that's logical if you assume that the first flashbacks show her first 4 movies. That's probably the most likely.
In a previous threat someone wrote to me about this assumption, it could be possible that the flashbacks are all from Donovan and we don't even know her first movies. From that point of view, I didn't find it illogical. It is possible that her story of the first 4 movies was told in these movies.
Sparse but also illogical?

 

[masiex]

is there a way for me to edit my save so I can get fullest deal with Rose?

 

[sunaboz]

(...) Chuck made it clear that the former resident wasn't going to return. (...)

That doesn't mean much because it's Chuck's house so even if Darius would return Chuck wouldn't let him stay there. Either way he's either dead or a guinea pig for Abel who for all we know might even have (Darius') keys for the apartment.

(...) Maybe Chuck is Mr. Nice Guy in general and helped Victoria financially since she ended up quitting her porn career? (...)

He's definitely not, at least not to whores. Victoria made it rather clear that she's not too content about Edwin's reconnection with Chuck but not explicit enough for Edwin to know what's really behind her words.

(...)
And what about Grace's line about “the messages Chuck left for people who insulted him”? What if the reason Chuck was teaching a class at the school wasn't because of Ian, but because of this "message" thing intended for Victoria? (...)

That line bothered me too and your theory makes total sense, although I don't think it's the case. While Chuck is a total pervert his main passion has always been science (he admitted to both, i.e. that he's a total pervert and that physics is his real passion). I wouldn't be surprised if after meeting Victoria (who has humongous breasts) being the pervert that he is he would talk about her to August and Donny saying how awesome it would be if she would star in a movie and Donny would say "but she did star" :].

Either way, Chuck could mess with Victoria and put pressure on her in a thousand different ways, there would be no reason for him to teach Edwin for that. And his affection towards him seems genuine, plus as you've said, him saying to Kat to not mess with Edwin as far as porn acting is concerned suggests that he doesn't want Victoria to get hurt (if only because that would hurt Edwin).

 

[Ottoeight]

Unfortunately, we do not have any information on when which films were shot. The only clue are the camera shots between 2009 and 2010. It is possible that after she ran away from home (for whatever reason), perhaps to become an actress (given her interest in movies), she suffered the fate of many others and had to shoot porn. The first 4 movies. Then she met Edwin's father and stopped. When he died the in-laws wanted nothing to do with either of us. Quite unusual not to want to see your grandson. Without any support, she then signed on with Donovan? Too far-fetched or illogical?

I think you forgot that in those early amateur gonzo flicks she is introduced as a MILF, and she definitely is old as in the flashback where Edwin's dad is dead and she cries because of Edwin's behaviour. She started her porn career after her husband died.

I think we might want to stop speculating on details that the story might never reveal:

sometimes Edwin himself wonders why she did what she did and maybe we will never have an answer as well. Do we (we players) really need an answer? dunno.

 

[rukoblud]

how to access a full gallery? can anyone share full save?

 

[Cyberjacky]

Does this game has no incest (I see no tag)? I've started the game and see mc has mom

 

[mirc]

mc has mom

Yes, I know, it's quite shocking, right?

 

[Turret]

Does this game has no incest (I see no tag)? I've started the game and see mc has mom

If we thread oldtimers would get a Euro for every time the questions "Is there incest?", "How do we get full gallery/full save?"are asked, we´d be filthy rich!
I get that thread newbies have these questions, but if you read just a couple pages before asking you´d see that is no incest in the game and will not be. Also that there is a gallery unlocker you can use and full save is a pipe dream, since there are different paths to take. You will never gat all content in one playthrough.

 

[Idontplay]

Does this game has no incest (I see no tag)? I've started the game and see mc has mom

Thank to God no.

If we thread oldtimers would get a Euro for every time the questions "Is there incest?", "How do we get full gallery/full save?"are asked, we´d be filthy rich!

How about: «Is there ntr?»

 

[Beduin123]

She has closed the chapter on Elias. She doesn't care. What should he do but divorce her? Does anyone here really believe that she wouldn't find a new man with money if she wanted to? She obviously thinks that her knowledge (she doesn't give the slightest hint of what it's all about) coupled with the network and connections that the club would bring her as a member, could help her save the school.

It doesn't address my question at all. As earlier discussion proved, nobody here has a slightest idea about what that "knowledge" could be and how it could bring her the desired financial independence. Let's wait and see what the Devs have in their sleeve.

And regarding the art school, as somebody wrote here recently, forget about it. It is dead by now anyway.

Thank to God no.

That's your take on it. I wouldn't mind. Victoria is hot and Edwin is very kinky But I realize that it's unlikely with this game being on Patreon or wherever it is. Though on the more serious not that may not fit the story.

 

[stormhawk]

next update should focus more on victoria

 

[Thor875]

I think you forgot that in those early amateur gonzo flicks she is introduced as a MILF, and she definitely is old as in the flashback where Edwin's dad is dead and she cries because of Edwin's behaviour. She started her porn career after her husband died.

I think we might want to stop speculating on details that the story might never reveal:

sometimes Edwin himself wonders why she did what she did and maybe we will never have an answer as well. Do we (we players) really need an answer? dunno.

Thank you. If she was introduced as a MILF, I really overlooked it. I'm just very worried about Vicky. I still have this bad feeling, hence the speculation. To calm myself down. I've just started again from the beginning and have a question about her Online dating. Which option is better? I will support her and would like her to have a boyfriend/husband. But isn't there a very high risk that someone will recognize her there, because of her porn career? Speculation that we will probably never know, I'm well aware of. Or excuses.

 

[Ottoeight]

Thank you. If she was introduced as a MILF, I really missed it. I'm just very worried about Vicky. I still have this bad feeling, hence the speculation. To calm myself down. I've just started again from the beginning and have a question about her Online dating. Which option is better? I will support her and would like her to have a boyfriend/husband. But isn't there a very high risk that someone will recognize her there, because of her porn career? Speculation that we will probably never know, I'm well aware of. Or excuses.

My advice for everybody is: play the latest update, then play the whole game from scratch - this will help you remember things and connect some dots in the light of the latest update.

We have quite a few months ahead, after all.

 

[Leinad_Sevla]

Is there a way to just download the latest update?

 

[DD-MegaDoDo]

great update. I do have one complaint however.

The game prevents my Mac from sleeping – aside from unnecessary strain to the battery, it opens the door to me being discovered asleep with my laptop open to an anime character buttfucking another while drowning her in the bathtub.

Luckily this scene had no choices, otherwise I'd have some explaining to do this morning.