MAGO-DAG

Forum Fanatic
Sep 1, 2023
5,351
21,001
Harems are dumb. The hole to pole ratio is too damn high.
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
Not all harem games are that dumpies, but I understand your opinion especially because of the obsessive harem fans, the same goes for NTR fans...
but some harem games are made pretty well, the problem with harem genres is that most developers don't know how to do it and suddenly make the same boring plot with 5-10 girls and meaningless fucking!

Harem games also need clear plans and plots with a little difficulty, tension and competition between girls because of jealousy, and then slowly they come to terms with it and not just like that "show a bigdick with one click and all the girls are yours"
 
  • Like
Reactions: prpa

prpa

Member
Nov 29, 2016
203
516
Not all harem games are that dumpies, but I understand your opinion especially because of the obsessive harem fans, the same goes for NTR fans...
but some harem games are made pretty well, the problem with harem genres is that most developers don't know how to do it and suddenly make the same boring plot with 5-10 girls and meaningless fucking!

Harem games also need clear plans and plots with a little difficulty, tension and competition between girls because of jealousy, and then slowly they come to terms with it and not just like that "show a bigdick with one click and all the girls are yours"
I'm not the biggest fan of Harem games, but I liked a few in which the Harem is on the smaller side. Like you said, it's really hard to make them even "semi-realistic", maybe in a fantasy or medieval game. That's why I prefer throuple relationships to pure Harems; while not the norm, at least they can be found in the real world, and it's easier to make them appear natural.


As for obsessive Harem fans, and I'm talking as someone who dislikes NTR, nothing makes me laugh more than when they complain about LIs already in the Harem interacting among themselves. They perceive sex between girls (with or without the MC present) as cheating and constantly complain about the MC being NTR'd. :KEK:
 
Last edited:

bonerland

Active Member
Dec 28, 2017
731
1,093
I'm not the biggest fan of Harem games, but I liked a few in which the Harem is on the smaller side. Like you said, it's really hard to make them even "semi-realistic", maybe in a fantasy or medieval game. That's why I prefer throuple relationships to pure Harems; while not the norm, at least they can be found in the real world, and it's easier to make them appear natural.


As for obsessive Harem fans, nothing makes me laugh more than when they complain about LI interacting among themselves. They perceive sex between girls (with or without MC present) as cheating and constantly complain about MC being NTR'd. :KEK:
That’s just gals being pals.
 
  • Yay, update!
  • Hey there
Reactions: Simpgor and prpa

Wilhelms

Newbie
May 6, 2025
64
34
Harems are dumb. The hole to pole ratio is too damn high.
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
Actually your game isn't the epitome of reality either, if we present this story as true to someone, they would be calling it Bulshit in the world we live in. It's the fact that this is just fiction that makes it little bit interesting and worth giving a damn.
And fiction is always a little dumb for it to be interesting enough to catch some attention.

And btw the hole to poll ratio even in your game is absurd. So by saying this you killed your own argument already.

Edit: And your MC is either bipolar or badly written because in the whole game he can't seem to stop whining about how what he is doing is very bad but then suddenly when the opportunity arises he turns out to be a sadistic maniac.
 
Last edited:

MAGO-DAG

Forum Fanatic
Sep 1, 2023
5,351
21,001
I'm not the biggest fan of Harem games, but I liked a few in which the Harem is on the smaller side. Like you said, it's really hard to make them even "semi-realistic", maybe in a fantasy or medieval game. That's why I prefer throuple relationships to pure Harems; while not the norm, at least they can be found in the real world, and it's easier to make them appear natural.


As for obsessive Harem fans, and I'm talking as someone who dislikes NTR, nothing makes me laugh more than when they complain about LIs already in the Harem interacting among themselves. They perceive sex between girls (with or without the MC present) as cheating and constantly complain about the MC being NTR'd. :KEK:
I am also 100% not a fan of harems, I usually try to avoid things like harem/ntr discussion... I am mostly a fan of things like half corruption harem with a little vanilla mixed in.
It all depends on taste and variety.

Would say I am mostly a fan of Netori, but unfortunately such genres are underrated, sometimes I want to play a game where Mc with an antagonist nature corrupts other people's girls or wives... but I'm me, that's my taste lol :HideThePain: :Kappa:
 
  • Yay, update!
Reactions: prpa

lustforsex

Newbie
Sep 18, 2023
90
334
Actually your game isn't the epitome of reality either, if we present this story as true to someone, they would be calling it Bulshit in the world we live in. It's the fact that this is just fiction that makes it little bit interesting and worth giving a damn.
And fiction is always a little dumb for it to be interesting enough to catch some attention.

And btw the hole to poll ratio even in your game is absurd. So by saying this you killed your own argument already.

Edit: And your MC is either bipolar or badly written because in the whole game he can't seem to stop whining about how what he is doing is very bad but than suddenly when the opportunity arises he turns out to be a sadistic maniac.
1747629284112.gif
 

Ozymandias037

Member
Sep 25, 2023
140
450
Actually your game isn't the epitome of reality either, if we present this story as true to someone, they would be calling it Bulshit in the world we live in. It's the fact that this is just fiction that makes it little bit interesting and worth giving a damn.
And fiction is always a little dumb for it to be interesting enough to catch some attention.

And btw the hole to poll ratio even in your game is absurd. So by saying this you killed your own argument already.

Edit: And your MC is either bipolar or badly written because in the whole game he can't seem to stop whining about how what he is doing is very bad but then suddenly when the opportunity arises he turns out to be a sadistic maniac.
I'm impressed. It's rare to see someone be so wrong, so confidently.



(okay it isn't really I just wish it was)
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,635
10,145
Anyone else find the the body skin freckles on Sophia hot asf in that diary pic? I hope there is some on her booty too. She needs all the help she can get to round out that cake.:sneaky:
That's Cassandra - without Joe Shelby, this time - with Kristoff Jostad Jameson, the military contractor.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,635
10,145
Anyway...

guys, I can't see any harem tag over there next to the game title, so... the question is: why talking about it?

If you have been reading this VN in these years you should have realised since a lot of time that this story and harem are like oil and water: they just don't mix.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Discrepancy

Dactess

Member
Sep 9, 2021
133
161
They perceive sex between girls (with or without the MC present) as cheating and constantly complain about the MC being NTR'd. :KEK:
Yeah NTR to me is just stealing, cheating, jealousy. But I do see some people lose it when they see 2 Li's look at each other or there is a male friend in a game lol. I mean if there is a Lesbian character straight trying to steal a LI from the mc and making moves then yeah that's NTR but that's usually not the case.

I haven't really seen anything in Pale Carnations that would suggest that to me though. I mean the hoes ain't loyal but they are hoes.

Although, I did slightly agree with Edwin during the threesome when he had that thought about Mina screaming Felicia's name... but there was an easy fix to that. And well Veronica makes me insecure so I gotta keep Mina away from her, but Hana is fine.


Anyway...

guys, I can't see any harem tag over there next to the game title, so... the question is: why talking about it?
Someone responded to a post I made and they said a harem wouldn't work in this game. Which I'd like to point out that I in no way brought a harem ending up, I was just talking about a lesbian push for Mina.

I said I agree with them and that I think harems only work in fantastical settings.

And well, the flames spread. At least I think.
 
4.80 star(s) 532 Votes