VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Turret]

Ian and Han? That would be so hot, maybe I haven't been paying attention, but is there any hint of that in the dialogue?

Well, an introspective Ian and a not/low anger Hana definitely have warming relations over the run of the game. With both Ian and Hana admitting in a roundabout way that they find each other hot.
It is a currently not very likely relationship, but it is not zero chance. It could be an option on a path where Edwin is pursuing another girl instead of Hana.

 

[Discrepancy]

Ian and Hana? That would be so hot, maybe I haven't been paying attention, but is there any hint of that in the dialogue?

My bad haha, I meant Edwin, Mina and Hana, maybe it's my mind playing tricks but yeah that would be hot too but doubtful?

 

[Discrepancy]

Given that we know that we will have to choose our special LI one day, our hero already had a situation with a throuple gone bad, it is pretty much clear that any kind of throuple ending(!) will be in a bad ending.

As for the threesome Feli/Mina/MC I consider it "wrong" in the meaning that for it to happen, you loose big chances for both Felicia AND Mina romances. It is a nice threesome but nothing more, hence fuckboy stuff and you loose more in the process than you win.

A threesome Hana/Mina/MC will most probably come and be hot, but still "wrong" on the relationship end of the equation. To even get to the initiate stage of it, we see jealousy rearing it´s head. Yes, a nice fun threesome or two, but a throuple MC/Hana/Mina will never last.

So a throuple ending by design will only happen on a bad corrupted ending, because of the characters involved. e.g. Hana has nothing against having some fun and has an understanding as far as the club in involved. But beyond that, she wants an exclusive relationship. So some threesomes, esp. fun ones yes, but not longterm stuff.

I agree with you I just don't like the word "wrong" or "bad" you use to describe it.
Like if Edwin is fuck buddies with Mina, Hana, and Felicia (don't think you can have that status though) there's nothing wrong or bad in my opinion for the consenting parties to have a threesome.
If you using it in a gaming sense, yeah is probably bad to do a threesome and lose love points or whatever in a possible love relationship with someone.
IMO Edwin pursuing a love relationship with someone at this time is extremely selfish on his part, I think with Hana is more or less ok because she knows what he's up to, but still it's a bit weird for me. In the future who knows, it dependes where the story will take us

 

[ffive]

Am I the only one who thought this was the shortest update ever that seemed to take forever to come out?

Didn't really feel short to me. It could be due to knowing beforehand it'd end right as the Exhibition begins; the amount of content was pretty much within my expectations for that time period, and relative to similar segments earlier in the game.

 

[PervyParadox]

Sure, I think it's possible, I just think it's unlikely, yeah past experience for Edwin like I said before, and yes Dolfe point and yours are true that MMF is different to MFF, but it's still relevant, a throuple relationship is complicated and both Mina and Hana (especially Mina during the concert) showed signs of jealousy before, so realistically even if it happens in game I doubt a Edwin, Hana and Mina serious throuple relationship would last (sorry don't want to rain on your parade, but that's my opinion).
Edit for correction: For a threesome with Edwin, Mina and Hana I'm sure it will happen, more than once even and I can't wait
Mina is also interested on a MMF threesome and I'm here for it, hope it's with Jacob

Mina showing sign of jealousy is balanced by the kiss scene. She literally admits that she doesn't know if she was more jealous of Edwin or Hana. Wouldn't be the best way to resolve said jealousy to date both of them at the same time ?

I don't think with the way the story has been written and with what happened in the past that this will end in a throuple specially if a previous instance already failed, there may be threesomes but I think at some point they will make you pick one or get dumped.

On the contrary I think the very existence of a previous instance means that there is a chance of getting a throuple in the end. For my arguments about that, refer to my previous message. A previously failed attempt set a precedent, and pave the way to a second attempt, but with different circumstances and characters to prevent the failure this time.

Given that we know that we will have to choose our special LI one day, our hero already had a situation with a throuple gone bad, it is pretty much clear that any kind of throuple ending(!) will be in a bad ending.

A threesome Hana/Mina/MC will most probably come and be hot, but still "wrong" on the relationship end of the equation. To even get to the initiate stage of it, we see jealousy rearing it´s head. Yes, a nice fun threesome or two, but a throuple MC/Hana/Mina will never last.

Refer to my answer above. I still don't understand why a throuple ending would be a bad one. You seem to think that the concept of a throuple means being a jerk or completely corrupted, which I don't understand. Again, the possibility of a Mina/Hana/Edwin throuple would most likely depends on variables and choices with Mina and Hana. I don't see why it should be a bad ending.

As for jealousy, it could be part of the process. There is jealousy now, but Mina offered a solution to this jealousy. If the three of them are together, then there's no reason to be jealous anymore as long as they all learn to share their time equally. Also there's a great way for it to last: by ending the game. We're probably not gonna follow up for decades after the story. Just give the players a throuple ending, and then the end. Let the player choose if it lasts or not, who cares, the game will be over anyway. I'll make it last a century, don't worry about that.

So a throuple ending by design will only happen on a bad corrupted ending, because of the characters involved. e.g. Hana has nothing against having some fun and has an understanding as far as the club in involved. But beyond that, she wants an exclusive relationship. So some threesomes, esp. fun ones yes, but not longterm stuff.

Hana didn't want to fuck Edwin at the beginning of the game either. Characters evolve, relationships evolve. Hana might accept an "exclusive" throuple, where she doesn't want Mina and Edwin fucking other people. It is consistant with all the characters. Mina is attracted to both, Hana is attracted to both, Edwin is attracted to both. They all like each other (given the right choices of course), so why not long-term stuff ? Because you guys decided a throuple can't ever work for some reason ? Well, I think it's possible, and even likely.

And I will die on that hill, damn it.

 

[shroomify]

That's especially funny when any family members in the game use the same last name.

I use Max Headroom most the time. Ha