Im not saying people can't have their opinions. nor do they have to like the game, but a lot of the complaints are from people expecting the MC to jump on his daughters and visa versa within 10 minutes. I respect your right to not enjoy the game, and my comments were not directed at people with legitimate complaints about story elements. more at the people who are annoyed that he hasnt bedded and knocked up every woman he met within 10 frames of meeting them and saying the game sucks as a result.
Also of course their will be moments that require you to exercise a little suspension of disbelief. but a few of your points are not insane as you might think imo, allow me to elaborate. Read on if you are interested in my opinion. Wont be offended if you dont
1- virgin mother, in 1950 that was impossible in 2021 its a routine medical procedure. not that unbelievable at all
2- Waitress, sure a bit of a stretch but if that is hardly outside the realm of possibility. Being hit on while on a date is not all that crazy, psychologically speaking, it puts some people at ease to see you on a date. its the same phenomenon that married people deal with, they appear "safe" and stable and good "mate" material since another person found you worthy of their trust etc, and while I doubt most would jump you in the bathroom, its not crazy to get hit on while on a date. Its an actual phenomenon that has been studied. Some people even wear fake rings for that very reason. Im also sure at least a few people reading this have gotten back their customer copy of the dinner check with a phone number penciled in under the thank you note from the waitress
3- The cop is being written out of the story from what I understand, Ill give you that, it was very forced and jarring.
4- the mother, its been 18+ years, grief makes you do weird things and prolonged grief even stranger, its not impossible to believe that she feels some kind of connection to the MC, she has spent 18 years with all that anger and grief bottled up before boiling over when she tries to kill him and when the MC isnt the total monster she imagined him to be all those years it probably throws her whole world on its head and he is the last "connection" she has to her dead son. Its hard to determine how the mind would cope with that. Im not saying its a healthy emotion for her to have but its hardly going to spoil the game or have me label it as "yeah right!"
5- Triplets, allow me to be a statistics nerd for a moment. in 2019 there were a confirmed 3136 triplet births in the US alone. that year it was about 88 triplet births in the US per 100k births. On average 1 in 10k natural pregnancies (without any fertility drugs etc) result in triplets (odds go way up with fertility aids), about 380,000 births per day around the world means a potential of around 38 triplet births a day worldwide. 13,870 a year (roughly). So while its very rare, and those are just rough numbers, its not as rare as people think.
anyway I digress, I enjoy a good debate so I got a bit off track but then again not really since these were issues brought up as story speed bumps.