- Sep 14, 2021
- 42
- 46
1. Ever heard of a game called Kincaid, The last Barbarian, Sinistar, The forest of Blue Skin or Hounds of the Meteor? Yeah, I bet those games were made by big AAA companies, right? Nope, just one or and handful of people, just like the ones from SOD. So this excuse is nullified.1: It's a game made by probably 5 or less people. Most H companies don't have the funding, manpower, or experience of non porn games. Inb4 somebody lists off a single non porn game made by a single dev over several years like it's the same thing or a fair comparison. That's an exception, not a rule (And also lacking in porn).
2: Any time a new major element to the game (Porn) is added, the devs have to divide up attention to that new system that would normally be spent elsewhere (Combat, story, etc).
3: Good games require all the systems involved to be balanced well. Too much or too little story, gameplay, porn, can turn people off. Porn adds another thing that needs be balanced with all the other systems.
Those things are why porn games will generally never feel the same as non porn games gameplay wise. Take like an hour of average gameplay in a game. In an open world game, you'll maybe spend 30 minutes running around, 10 minutes fighting, 20 minutes misc stuff (Dialogue, fucking with your inventory, crafting, etc). When you add porn as a major competent, you need to cut a lot of that stuff to make room for it. The combat basically can't be removed for it to still be considered an open world rpg. So you end up cutting down the running around or misc stuff. Both can take away the depth of the game.
An open world game is also one of the more forgiving game types because cutting down on the running around type of stuff is fairly easy (Smaller game world). Most game types don't have that luxury, so the story or even sometimes the gameplay suffers. Because the story is generally the easiest time wise for devs, H games tend to suffer in the gameplay department quite a bit. A small cut to gameplay would be a major cut to story. The story doesn't need years of work and constant bug testing after all.
Does all this mean porn games have to have shit gameplay? Of course not. Does it mean on average that porn games will have less depth in story and combat/gameplay? Of course it does. Game devs do not have unlimited funds or time to make games. Nobody can create their perfect idea of a game, sacrifices always have to be made.
SoD has its own issues (I've listed a ton in my own posts here), but expecting the gameplay to be like a professional non H game is stupid. If you're not okay with some things being sacrificed for porn, don't play hentai games. The rare unicorn H games that have awesome gameplay, story, and everything would be even better without the porn. It's like how VNs typically have better story and usually more H CGs than an action H game because they cut the gameplay (Or why Slice of Life anime have more time to flesh out their characters than an action anime). The remaining stuff gets a boost.
2. That is nonsense. When you make the game, you plan it all out and not stuff things willy-nilly in it in the last second.
3. Again, that is nonsense, because fine tuning is the last thing you do, but then 90% of the game is done.
Sorry, but that sounds like you want to excuse all the things that went wrong in this game, because you like the game. All those points are no reason not to make a good game, especially if you get MONEY MONTHLY via Parteon. Like I said, there are devs, who work on H games on their own and those games look better than this one. Kincaid, The last Barabrian, Sinistar. Those are games are made by one or more and before you say "But some of them are 2D" that doesn't matter. They chose their platform and promised a good game. If they can't handle it, it is their problem, not ours. Don't comes with excuses when you can do it better or set your goals too high when you can't reach them. This game has not only flawed, it is worse than the first one and I would take the earlier engine any time over the ugly Unreal Engine.
EDIT: Just saw that the engine from the earlier game was the Unreal Engine as well. This makes it even worse, because their graphic quality when down the hill!
If you like the game, more power to you, but don't expect that people will shred it if they don't like it.
Last edited: