Are we playing the same game?
My ending when he does not want her to have sex with Robert
That was a +20 in their relationship (Maybe it was a bug, but their reaction seemed to corroborate the fact)
You can not discount a review because it said that they are married instead of engaged (to be married in 2 weeks)
Of course you are free to post any review and score you want, but to me it seems like you don't enjoy the genre (Also not my kinks) and made up in your own mind how everything is going to go and based on your own dislikes and assumptions to where the story is going, rated the game poorly. Fair enough, it's your right to do.
Don't however assume that most other positives are faked or dishonest reviews. I for one, even though I enjoy games where I play as a decent alpha male, actually enjoyed the game a lot so far.
The reality is that you do get a lot of people that has very little going for him in the looks department as well as in the sex department (Like our dear MC in this game). For me it's a refreshing game about a relationship between a 4 guy dating a 10 girl. They actually have a good relationship up to now in the game and I actually appreciated it.
Sure this game can go to shit in the next couple of updates and go full on NTR/humiliation/cuckold and then I would not find it enjoyable anymore, but so far so good.
My opinion on your review, is maybe review the game for what it is so far, instead of where you think it's going.
Just my 2 cents.