While getting talent with any name value to do adult work is always a longshot, it doesn't hurt to ask. What gets a "LMAO GTFO" today might be money desperately needed in 6 months. And as I alluded, you can always credit them as "sexythot8847luvzcockxoxoxo" or some such other name if needed. Getting amateurs that can do a reasonably close facsimile of the original that would do it in exchange for the exposure could be an option if the originals aren't interested.
In this case I believe you are misapplying DMCA. If they were to take voice clips from show, which WB does own, and use that without permission, it would be a DMCA violation. In this case they would be hiring the voice talent directly and would own the recording outright, whether WB liked it or not. My understanding of the first DMCA complaint was the use of the term Injustice, which WB has trademarked in ways which overlap the game and thus violated their IP in a way not covered by the porn parody loophole.
[IANAL]
Just an fyi, it actually could easily fall under DMCA or some other legal mechanisms. It depends purely on whatever contract these voice actors have with WB or whomever. It’s not unusual for video game companies to own those voices for the characters. An example being metal a gear solid 1 iirc. And silent hill 2 for sure. In cases such as these, reproducing the voices would be a bad idea and an easy way to get bogged down by legal action. I wouldn’t even recommend using others attempting to reproduce the original voice, as I believe ownership is on the voice and not the actors representation in those cases. Not sure. In any case it’s an easy way to invite a mess of legal issues for benefits that cannot outweigh the consequences.