Totally disagree with you
First
It totally depends on the person. And you don't have to be a 25/30/35 brutal man who comes to a woman and asks about kids and gifts and stuff. We are human beings and we feel things differently. Because we were born in different places/raised by different parents, and I could go on for quite a while. You might ask why I'm even writing this comment if I feel this way, but maybe I'm just a hopeless optimist hoping to change someone's mind
Second - And in this point we will talk about Becca
Yea it started as "basically the choffeur unpaid chaperone" but the story continues and characters grow. And in the end of chapter 1 we find
Third. And this one will be about Amy
Here will be even easier. There is one screen that destroy all of your comments about how Amy search for replacement and "is easy flirty falling for the hired help - bar tenders are the easiest of prey for the customers"
But to tell you the truth, I'm not deluded and I think, at least right now, that we won't get a happy ending for both girls

. Unfortunately, that's how life works, and in some part you are right. But in most of it, directly from the game and how Becca and Amy interact with the MC, you are definitely wrong.
But if everything ends well and we have a happy ending, that would be the best gift for all fans.