Hard to tell. In a sense, WIAB is the opposite of SG. There are porny bits right off the bat and less relationship building there. Another big difference for me is that in SG you start from scratch, the MC is not familiar with any of the main characters of the game except Nami and Nojiko and meets most of the characters for the first time at the beginning of the game, in WIAB your MC knows most of the characters at the beginning and has a history with them that is revealed from one scene to the another. I personally don't like WIAB's approach in this case. And as far as I remember, in the old WIAB I didn't like the first couple of chapters, but then the story rolled and became quite interesting. In the new WIAB, only these first two chapters are ready. But they are deeply reworked, the plot has been significantly changed and the renders, of course, are outstanding. So it's up to you to decide.