- Nov 4, 2022
- 135
- 1,449
Correct. They originally shared their music on Soundcloud under a CC BY-SA 3.0 license, meaning it was free to use, even commercially, provided credit was given to the band. DPC still wrote to them at the time, asking if they were okay with him using their music in a game with adult content but they didn't reply so he went ahead with it.No it wasn't related to any website, just one band asked to remove their songs from the game
It wasn't until a few years later that they got back to him and asked to remove their content from his game. Apparently, they misunderstood the license types and Creative Commons by Attribution wasn't what they had in mind for their music...
As for Ocean, dealing with the artists directly is definitely the safest option. Having to contact and negotiate with each artist individually is quite a hassle, but if you're upfront with them about the type of content their music will be used in and they give you the green light, there won't be any unpleasant surprises in the future. And it's beneficial to the artist as well, as normally the intermediary would take a chunk of the license fee.
Many of them actually don't mind their music being used in adult games; when Leap of Faith was hit with a DMCA claim after making it to Steam, Drifty pulled the game's entire soundtrack and went on to talk to the artists directly and in the end was able to secure licenses from most of them. It's the various music libraries' restrictive ToS that are the problem.
They can still be useful, just not for getting the licenses. Those that offer membership for a monthly fee can be used to find tracks that interest you. Then just reach out to the artist directly and see how it goes.
It pains me to see some of the brilliant tracks SG had removed from the game, especially those that had entire cutscenes built around them... I can only imagine how frustrating and disheartening that must be for Ocean. But hey, I would likely never have heard any of those songs otherwise so there's that, at least. My playlist is bigger now.