It's almost like a real life decision where you don't necessarily get the universe saying "what options would you prefer" and offering them to you.
They
gave us the option, and some of us played it. Nicole apologised for making the stupid proposal and had a whole change of heart. So it's
not like some of us wanted something we couldn't have.
The way I see it: if your intent was to play the faithful route and only be with Nicole, then perhaps you'd have reason to be upset that you don't get this choice. If your intent was to do anything with any other female character, then you have no leg to stand on.
Correct. Since they gave us the option before, some of us (probably a major minority), actually chose to play the faithful route. Doesn't mean I have no interest in the other girls, but for that I would choose to break up with Nicole and have a separate playthrough with them.
The only choice on this route that would be fair to her and in line with "salvage the relationship" is "we both get to do what we want with who we want.
Not sure I follow you here. How do you align "salvage the relationship" with "we both get to do what we want with who we want"? As far as I'm concerned, there is nothing to salvage once you start sleeping around with other people. In the case of Nicole and the MC, they were in a long term monogamous relationship. You can't salvage that when one party (in this case Nicole) all of a sudden decides to have sex with other people, and your only choice is to agree with it. Again, we
did have the choice before to say no and stay with Nicole, and also to break up if we wanted to be with the other girls. So really, everyone already could have had what they wanted (from playing like a monk to playing the field).
I admit for those planning to be faithful it would have been nice for them to have that choice.
They did, and you're right, we were happy. In fact, no one had a reason
not to be happy before (unless you can come up with one). Exactly what benefit
does this open relationship now bring that we didn't have before? Cuckqueen? So some form of cucking planned down the road? Only instead of her cucking you, you cucking her?
Interesting how
Hyperserver has been very quiet about this lately (we all know he's been pushing for it).
I understand that the MC doesn't know this but you do. If you really need to reconcile this with the MC's knowledge, just pretend he knows her so well that he is certain she won't actually do anything with anyone else.
Probably the only thing to do now. But I really do hope she does have a change of heart soon and actually will
want to salvage their relationship (other than her wanting to watch him fuck other girls).
And if it's still something you can't handle, go play another game.
Not gonna happen (yet). Stop sharing my thoughts and opinion? Not gonna happen either, but thanks for the suggestion.