You had me thinking you were intelligent and capable of critical thinking until you started breaking down Ella's actions. [...]
Ignoring that pathetic try of flailing one's incelligence around and calling other's stupid. I can do that too, far better than you, choosing not to because it's a wrong thing to do in a conversation about a topic.
1. If she knows you aren't able to handle it, she won't infect you (or rather, let you get infected). When Dave reacts poorly to the pill she gives him, she kills the monster that comes for him.
She doesn't infect Emily because she has a greater understanding of Emily's mental state than she does the jocks. At most, you can argue that she's too careless.
2. Why is killing Jock #2 evil? He attacked her, and given what we see with Kenny, he was definitely going to go on a rampage.
3. She doesn't have the orphanage for tools. She might, but there's literally no evidence that's what she intends. All the superhuman kids (e.g. Cole, Shen, Briar, etc) with her were randomly attacked by monsters and picked up by HERO, then escaped HERO with her help.
4. Not sure why not hesitating to kill someone counts towards her being evil, but she doesn't actually kill the MC. In the first dead end, she kidnaps him and takes him to Memory for something. In the second, she attacks and it cuts to black. I'm pretty sure this is just because WW didn't want to show anything more (most likely because it's just a retread of that first dead end), and he confirmed on a livestream that the MC doesn't die in this dead end.
5. How do you know what she did to become certain her plan is necessary?
6. Citation needed.
Besides me calling her a cunt, the rest of that was to point to her overall not valuing human life, at all, which is my point of her being evil, not likely not bad, just evil. Also, what kind of debunking is this?
1 - Yes, she never turns people that can't make it, that's why those two did make it, clearly capable of pulling through, none of them monsterified, after all. Like, what even is your take here? That if she is certain that you won't pull through that she doesn't do it? Okay, then she just gambles lives of people away.
2 - Yes, he attacked her, the bystander, who had nothing to do with it, certainly not arranging his infection firsthand, so she was innocent. Even more abhorrent is her reaction to that. Remorse at killing someone? Feeling bad? No, "man, I'm losing my touch", not even acknowledging a human life she wasted away for fucking nothing.
3 - Yes, no evidence. This was an overstretch on my part, I just assumed since she case after case manipulates people and uses them, that this is the case here, but it might be different. So yeah, the orphanage is unusable argument.
4 - Oh, not killing MC? Just doing whatever the hell she did, maybe worse? Ok, better examples then: What about that time she murdered her class for a power boost? All right, maybe greater good, grand plan, I'm good and shit and all that, still failed to get what she truly needed so this kinda was just a murderous killing spree, which might be evil, but I can't put my finger on it. All right, another one then: hobo she gutted and turned into a meatball. For what, being a dick, that was already put in place by MC? Or for showing that you can transform others with your power? If there was another way of showing that to a shapeshifter... like using mouth to fucking say that. It's not like she showed MC some direct way to do that, just threw the idea at the wind, one life less on the world. But, I dunno, you loathe hobos and this human life has no meaning for you, okay then. The worst example, that is just quite about literally undefendable. Valravn. She did not even consider for a minute the lives lost if she sets him free. She knew this will be disastrous, she knows what it is and how it works. She needed distraction, so why fucking bother with lives? It's not like Valravn will go specifically after innocent and children, the more innocent and younger the better.
5 - Again, I do not, this is also an overstretch on my part. I assumed again, since she never did consider lives lost, pain and suffering ever before (Valravn, hobo, class, everyone everywhere) that she did not here. But it's not a counterargument too - since no one knows what her plan is. Might not even be about surviving as remnants of humanity, now superhumanity, might just be one giant blood sacrifice. As it currently stands, we just do not know.
6 - ?
So yeah, for now Ella shows quite only a disregard for human life, manipulation, narcissism, power hungry and bitchy behavior. She might work for greater "good", whatever that entails, no one can prove that now, probably never, for now only show of Ella is that of evil shitling that have some morals somewhere. Like the another guy in the thread said some pages ago, if Ella was a dude, no one would be sperming over her and defending her, but some smell pussy even through the electricity and pixels.