CREATE YOUR AI CUM SLUT ON CANDY.AI TRY FOR FREE
x

Dipasimaan

Active Member
Feb 22, 2019
691
5,920
monster and superhuman can, Mc can, Ella can, and that monster looking like Syla can
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
But of course she could still be 4th chosen, just that 3th is also possible .
No they normally can't. Like I said at the first phrase, if they haven't dual traits like the MC or Deus possibly normally a superhuman can only use his monster parent's powers. Obviously there are some inconsistencies as, if the monster parent has percentage of memory body and dark even if in little parts it's obvious that if someone concentrate hard enough could theoretically utilize both traits and possibly more but it's so nigh-impossible that noone ever tried and even if they did it's not like having dual traits or 50/50 of twins traits. I'm sorry if it's not extremely well-written or explained but right now I can't do it better.

Also Ella can't use both of Memory and Body traits as she was infected by the 3rd and she wasn't compatible with the 4th trait so she could never use it. What you implicated in your post about aglaecwif possibly having both traits couldn't be possible as for monsters it isn't exactly possible as as we know to have both traits divided in 50/50

I admit that I have not a good counterargument for the strenght eater but I guess that it has a good portion of both but not exactly half of both
 

Gtdead

Active Member
Jul 13, 2021
922
5,736
Since the last update, I think we have to rethink our theories about Ella and how dual trait spawn work.

- Ella knows who MC is, who his parents are, and what his compatibility is.
- Ella says that MC is just like her.
- Ella considers herself a failure.
- During the Body dream she says that memory is not "her strong suit" so it leaves a possibility that she is actually capable of using it a bit.

So what I think is happening here is that Ella is supposed to be a half & half and just happened to be turned by Body, either by chance or circumstance. She just never managed to develop her Memory trait because she is a "failure", despite having a compatibility with it, and this is also why Memory is so active in her life.

With the new knowledge, a lot of the ideas we had about Apostlespawns are not correct. MC for example is not 100% compatible to both traits, he is a half & half. We also learned that Apostles in general prefer high purity spawns, while the Evolution Twins prefer strict half & half. So we need to start answering these questions:

1. Why would Ella care about using the memory trait? No other Apostle spawn (except MC) was ever capable of using the twin trait
2. Why would Ella consider herself a failure if she only had compatibility to Body?
3. Why Memory is so interested in Ella if she is supposed to have Body compatibility? Does she actually have high Body compatibility?
4. Why did she fail to manifest Memory powers?

I don't have developed the new theory enough to give answers, but I think the good old "Ella is the spawn of the 3rd and that's that" is not correct.
 
Last edited:

kibaris

Member
Mar 17, 2019
251
563
Since the last update, I think we have to rethink our theories about Ella and how dual trait spawn work.

- Ella knows who MC is, who his parents are, and what his compatibility is.
- Ella says that MC is just like her.
- Ella considers herself a failure.
- During the Body dream she says that memory is not "her strong suit" so it leaves a possibility that she is actually capable of using it a bit.

So what I think is happening here is that Ella is supposed to be a half & half and just happened to be turned by Body, either by chance or circumstance. She just never managed to develop her Memory trait because she is a "failure", despite having a compatibility with it, and this is also why Memory is so active in her life.

With the new knowledge, a lot of the ideas we had about Apostlespawns are not correct. MC for example is not 100% compatible to both traits, he is a half & half. We also learned that Apostles in general prefer high purity spawns, while the Evolution Twins prefer strict half & half. So we need to start answering these questions:

1. Why would Ella care about using the memory trait? No other Apostle spawn (except MC) was ever capable of using the twin trait
2. Why would Ella consider herself a failure if she only had compatibility to Body?
3. Why Memory is so interested in Ella if she is supposed to have Body compatibility? Does she actually have high Body compatibility?
4. Why did she fail to manifest Memory powers?

I don't have developed the new theory enough to give answers, but I think the good old "Ella is the spawn of the 3rd and that's that" is not correct.
Ella said that she can help mc with memory but isnt her strong suit, so maybe she can but not as well a she should?.
All other superhuman and monster linked to 4th or 3th could use both so far and in this last update Ella hint that she possibly can too.
For Aglaegwiff , i learned that her source of inspiration is strongly linked to water " Grendel's mother has always been associated with the water and may well have been based on an ancient Slavic water-goddess or spirit. ", and with Aglaecwiff change being made during the twin arc and their monster being strenght eater, a fish linked to the great ocean + Liz and Amber affinity to water, maybe myst isnt that far with is random theory about Aglaecwiff and 10th ^^
 
Last edited:

JmTrad

Active Member
Jun 2, 2018
912
3,004
Since the last update, I think we have to rethink our theories about Ella and how dual trait spawn work.

- Ella knows who MC is, who his parents are, and what his compatibility is.
- Ella says that MC is just like her.
- Ella considers herself a failure.
- During the Body dream she says that memory is not "her strong suit" so it leaves a possibility that she is actually capable of using it a bit.

So what I think is happening here is that Ella is supposed to be a half & half and just happened to be turned by Body, either by chance or circumstance. She just never managed to develop her Memory trait because she is a "failure", despite having a compatibility with it, and this is also why Memory is so active in her life.

With the new knowledge, a lot of the ideas we had about Apostlespawns are not correct. MC for example is not 100% compatible to both traits, he is a half & half. We also learned that Apostles in general prefer high purity spawns, while the Evolution Twins prefer strict half & half. So we need to start answering these questions:

1. Why would Ella care about using the memory trait? No other Apostle spawn (except MC) was ever capable of using the twin trait
2. Why would Ella consider herself a failure if she only had compatibility to Body?
3. Why Memory is so interested in Ella if she is supposed to have Body compatibility? Does she actually have high Body compatibility?
4. Why did she fail to manifest Memory powers?

I don't have developed the new theory enough to give answers, but I think the good old "Ella is the spawn of the 3rd and that's that" is not correct.
I have a bad feeling about MC past...

1706384123279.png
 

Ddlc

Member
Jun 22, 2017
388
1,498
1. Why would Ella care about using the memory trait? No other Apostle spawn (except MC) was ever capable of using the twin trait
2. Why would Ella consider herself a failure if she only had compatibility to Body?
3. Why Memory is so interested in Ella if she is supposed to have Body compatibility? Does she actually have high Body compatibility?
4. Why did she fail to manifest Memory powers?

I don't have developed the new theory enough to give answers, but I think the good old "Ella is the spawn of the 3rd and that's that" is not correct.
1. We know that most apostles want pure spawn and only Body and Memory want 50/50, but from Syla's words it's possible to imagine that this is a recent development, if that's the case maybe they wanted a 50/50 with both traits but Ella never progressed much on her memory, Mc is the first like that because it's supposed to be even more rare than being pure, and because none of the other apostles and even Body and Memory didn't care before.

2. Do we know her compatibility with both traits ? i really can't remember anyone mentioning it before, i mean she clearly is VERY compatible with body but do we know if she is or isn't with memory?

3. Maybe she also is 50/50 or close to that but instead developing both she just strived to body powers, her thinking that she is a feailure could be from realizing that even at her 5 evolution she didnt grow on the memory trait enough.

4. Now that's interesting, in Mc case he had both traits from the start but grew too much on the body side, his father as a pure body and mother almost pure memory so maybe thats the reason. Could also be because while being constantly in danger his powers were forced to depend on body for survival, mind state is also a thing and his will to fight lead to developing body.
In Ella's case we don't really now but it seems like this was both not the plan and a dissapointment to her, Body and Memory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SquallofNight

TerminusPrime

Member
Nov 23, 2020
178
447
1. Why would Ella care about using the memory trait? No other Apostle spawn (except MC) was ever capable of using the twin trait
2. Why would Ella consider herself a failure if she only had compatibility to Body?
Ella needs a superhuman for a specific role. She's been making multiple superhumans for different roles that she needs for her plans. She considers herself a failure because she never developed the powers to fulfill the role herself.
She turned MC, Jake and a few others as Minyak spawn for a specific purpose that she needs. Much earlier in this thread it was theorized it was some kind of telepathy since that's the one aspect that seems to be in common between the Memory trait, the Authority trait and Minyak powers.
It's also not something good since she spends a good deal of time when she's walking away from the frat party feeling guilty that it's likely going to be the MC she has to use, and that she happens to like him. Though Ella gets a few points in being willing to subject herself to whatever mysterious fate she had planned if she had manifested the Memory trait with her 5th Evolution.
That's not the only specific superhuman that she needs for her plans, Deryl and his compatibility with the Rebis also factored heavily into things, but Deryl turned out just like she needed, and she didn't seem particularly guilty over what happened to him.
 

RAYZ3L

New Member
Jun 25, 2022
14
20
I decided to do a full replay, the first in quite a while and damn this game is getting long, not that I mind as it felt really good to play some of the parts I have basically forgotten.

I noticed something when playing the battle of the diamonds part however. The Michael part I usually speed through but this time i decided to not do that and while I remembered that Michael had some strong resistance to energy I didnt remember that in the fight he tanks several lightning strikes and basically shrugs them off. His fight with Met might not be as loopsided as we thought. Met might be a evo above him but Michael is basically a direct counter it seems.
People always forget that The spawn of apostle like MC.ella . And the others are fairly stronger and have higher power level than the normal monster spawn and im not included the big dogs like levels 4n 5 and the mc who is spawn of 2 apostles and his parent perfect candidate of the same twins apostle, let's not forget he is somewhere the host of a being like that arbiter eye think that give me reference like itadori n skuna
 
  • Like
Reactions: SquallofNight

harem.king

Engaged Member
Aug 16, 2023
3,762
6,527
2. Why would Ella consider herself a failure if she only had compatibility to Body?
She was TOLD she is a failure by the divine ancestor during her 3rd evolution when she was... 13? IIRC she was 13 year old at the time
In latest update you get to read the memories of Ella and her classmates during the massacre.
Finally putting to rest the question of "did ella really murder her entire class for the lulz"

And the answer is no. During her 3rd evolution she got possessed by her monster ancestor who, stating she was a failure, would try to fix her by devouring all those human brains.
Culminating in her chopping herself into pieces to prematurely end her evolution to stop herself from harming Christy.
not a single person who used to claim Ella is evil because "she is a child murderer" ever apologized for slandering her
 
Last edited:

sexoffended

Newbie
Oct 6, 2020
94
93
Ella was stated to have memory power centered on her eyes. She can look at anything and get information on it's structure and function. If she looks at someone with cancer, not only she'll get information on current state of a tumor, but also how to treat it.
 

jak1165

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2018
1,013
1,284
So how are people feeling about where the story picked up from previous cliffhanger?

It's even more obvious to me that without Shen, MC absolutely claps the twins
 

Gtdead

Active Member
Jul 13, 2021
922
5,736
Ella said that she can help mc with memory but isnt her strong suit, so maybe she can but not as well a she should?.
All other superhuman and monster linked to 4th or 3th could use both so far and in this last update Ella hint that she possibly can too.
For Aglaegwiff , i learned that her source of inspiration is strongly linked to water " Grendel's mother has always been associated with the water and may well have been based on an ancient Slavic water-goddess or spirit. ", and with Aglaecwiff change being made during the twin arc and their monster being strenght eater, a fish linked to the great ocean + Liz and Amber affinity to water, maybe myst isnt that far with is random theory about Aglaecwiff and 10th ^^
Going down this path is a bit of a rabit hole. WW is obviously getting heavy inspiration from religion and folklore. But I really don't think it's a good idea to transfer the attributes of these characters from the various works to this game.

Now we can create a list like that:
Aglaecwif - Chosen of 3rd - Name taken from a demon? troll? not sure what she is, from Beowulf.
Syla - Chosen of 4th - Name taken from a demonic spirit in Arabian folklore.
Valravn - Chosen of 7th - Name taken from a raven in danish mythology.
Eisheth Zenumin - Chosen of 9th - Name taken from a demon in Zorah.
Rebis - Chosen of 12th - It's name means the result of a great alchemical work.

There's also Lochan Deus, which translates to God of the Lake and since he somehow sets MC on his path and "protects" him from deviations, perhaps he is inspired by Nimue (Lady of the Lake)? I can't find any other explanation for his name.


I have a bad feeling about MC past...

View attachment 3301522
Frankly, SIN care so little about MC that I doubt Tanos has played any important part in MC's past. Perhaps there was some overlap by accident or by circumstance, but probably not enough for that thread to worth the trouble pulling.

1. We know that most apostles want pure spawn and only Body and Memory want 50/50, but from Syla's words it's possible to imagine that this is a recent development, if that's the case maybe they wanted a 50/50 with both traits but Ella never progressed much on her memory, Mc is the first like that because it's supposed to be even more rare than being pure, and because none of the other apostles and even Body and Memory didn't care before.

2. Do we know her compatibility with both traits ? i really can't remember anyone mentioning it before, i mean she clearly is VERY compatible with body but do we know if she is or isn't with memory?

3. Maybe she also is 50/50 or close to that but instead developing both she just strived to body powers, her thinking that she is a feailure could be from realizing that even at her 5 evolution she didnt grow on the memory trait enough.

4. Now that's interesting, in Mc case he had both traits from the start but grew too much on the body side, his father as a pure body and mother almost pure memory so maybe thats the reason. Could also be because while being constantly in danger his powers were forced to depend on body for survival, mind state is also a thing and his will to fight lead to developing body.
In Ella's case we don't really now but it seems like this was both not the plan and a dissapointment to her, Body and Memory.
1. I get the sense that this 50/50 idea is Memory's project and she designs hers and her brother's spawn based on this. I really don't get the sense that this is a recent development. If Syla is anything like the other Chosen, she may be thousands of years old. The one thing we can say for sure is that finally, the Arbiter has a chance to be reborn after a long time, and Memory is aware that 50/50 spawns have higher "connection", whatever that may be. It feels very.. planned, to me.

2 & 3. I agree that the main assumption is that Ella failed on the Memory trait, but to be capable of failing in the first place, she has to have compatibility with it. So while we don't know Ella's compatibility, I think it's fair to assume that she is supposed to be compatible with it. So like MC, she has to have a significant percentage of compatibility, if not a perfect 50/50, at least something close. After all Syla says that MC isn't a perfect 50/50 but he seems to be the one.

4. This lack of even the smallest example of Ella being capable of using the Memory trait makes this question really hard. The 4th wouldn't accept Ella if her grasp of the Memory trait was weak anyway, at least if Syla is to be believed. MC wasn't good at Memory too, but he was capable of using it to augment his shapeshifting. Ella seemingly had to build her forms from scratch.

She was TOLD she is a failure by the divine ancestor during her 3rd evolution when she was... 13? IIRC she was 13 year old at the time

not a single person who used to claim Ella is evil because "she is a child murderer" ever apologized for slandering her
You assume that Ella considers herself a failure because she doesn't fit in Memory's plans. This isn't necessary true. Ella wants MC to succeed because he will make "her dreams" come true (deadend2), not Memory's dreams. She also reiterates that she is a failure in deadend3, which is a different outcome of the same scene.
 
Last edited:
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: JmTrad

Gtdead

Active Member
Jul 13, 2021
922
5,736
So how are people feeling about where the story picked up from previous cliffhanger?

It's even more obvious to me that without Shen, MC absolutely claps the twins
I was very satisfied with how this fight played out. Not only MC used the techniques that I advocated for quite a while (burrowing tentacles to kill Devana, uprooting half the forest to stomp Evander), but his performance against Shen was beyond my imagination. It felt like MC would easily win this fight if Shen was a level 3.
 

harem.king

Engaged Member
Aug 16, 2023
3,762
6,527
You assume that Ella considers herself a failure because she doesn't fit in Memory's plans.
It isn't an assumption. it is based on evidence which makes it a presumption.
And it is barely a presumption too.
there is a very direct causal link between your divine patron telling you explicitly "you are a failure" when you are a child (especially a little orphan child who seems to be heavily dependent on said divine patron as a parental figure). and then you internalize it.

It is possible that she completely ignored being told "you are a failure" by her god and then decided she is a failure for a completely different and unrelated reason.
But that is quite tenuous.
 

Dominosaur

Newbie
Nov 21, 2021
96
163
7th: The obvious choice would be Valravn but hes not exactly a friend but he does think of us as a respected opponent. Emily would be another choice but her eventual super status is only speculation at this point. Maybe Shadow? Or perhaps Nyx but her power doesnt really seem to fit somehow.

10th. Shen will probably drop in here because he seems to be more or less a pure 10th but I´m thinking he probably wouldnt be a guide as such seeing as hes an enemy. Even Jake was more of a frenemy regardless of path you take. Demi could be an option too.
Emily for 7th would be rough, since she's not a time person, so she doesn't have the same excuse as Claudia. Val is more likely.

Weirdly, Demi for 10th might work, if that's their origin? Even if you kill them, or skip their sidequest, they might still show up, and react. They still manage your fan club (presumably) if you ignore them, so they could be dropped in the tenth with minimal variety.

Friends: Demi alive, route finished: Demi is happy to see you, and help. Maybe a memory sex scene.

Fan: Demi alive, route not finished, before kidnapping: Demi is excited to meet you, but MC is kind of meh about it. Can maybe have a positive or negative treatment of them, before you get the memory thread.

Enemy: Route not finished but after kidnapping, or Demi (and Clover) died: Demi hates you and refuses to help (Either "you abandoned me" or "you killed me (and Clover)"), so you have to take what you need by force.

Possible alternative for the Enemy route, Demi runs away and you meet Shen. He's weirdly amicable, seeing you as "One of Big Sis Ella's allies." Or even maybe he tries to 'kill' you out of pride because you're just kind of hanging out, when his power should be willbreaking you.
 

Ddlc

Member
Jun 22, 2017
388
1,498
I was very satisfied with how this fight played out. Not only MC used the techniques that I advocated for quite a while (burrowing tentacles to kill Devana, uprooting half the forest to stomp Evander), but his performance against Shen was beyond my imagination. It felt like MC would easily win this fight if Shen was a level 3.
He did amazing to say the least, it seems that the autonomous tails once again prove they don't need Mc being conscious to kick ass.
Since SIN's invasion is very clear that Devana is a terrible match against Mc, and even with the impact of the tails softened by digging trough the ground he still gave her a nasty wound, without regeneration she would be overwhelmed very quickly.
Evander is annoying as fuck but a have the impression that he doesn't shrug off the kinetic energy completely when hit, so maybe you only have to keep beating the shit out off him until he rans out of juice.
As for Shen i hope Mc can learn some form of memory attack, probably not the best option against him directly since its lv3 vs lvl4 but if at least he could affect Devana and Evander with something that forced Shen to release them using his powers that would be enough to keep him on the defensive, better than being affected by the Living Fantasy again and again just to escape as soon as possible.

Example:Mc learns a way to make people forget something for a short period of time, imagine if Devana is about to be pierced by a tail, her response is using the bunker, but if she forgets for a single second about it she is fucked or Evander charging at Mc at full speed and forgets for a moment to cover his head with antimatter, he is done.
By using a memory attack against then for something so quick Shen would need to be vigilant to undo the attack immediatly, maybe with Mc being stronger attacking him could give Shen some kind of recoil and not being able to respont in time after this would essentially mean the death of the others, so focusing on defense would be the best strategy.
 

TerminusPrime

Member
Nov 23, 2020
178
447
He did amazing to say the least, it seems that the autonomous tails once again prove they don't need Mc being conscious to kick ass.
Since SIN's invasion is very clear that Devana is a terrible match against Mc, and even with the impact of the tails softened by digging trough the ground he still gave her a nasty wound, without regeneration she would be overwhelmed very quickly.
Evander is annoying as fuck but a have the impression that he doesn't shrug off the kinetic energy completely when hit, so maybe you only have to keep beating the shit out off him until he rans out of juice.
As for Shen i hope Mc can learn some form of memory attack, probably not the best option against him directly since its lv3 vs lvl4 but if at least he could affect Devana and Evander with something that forced Shen to release them using his powers that would be enough to keep him on the defensive, better than being affected by the Living Fantasy again and again just to escape as soon as possible.

Example:Mc learns a way to make people forget something for a short period of time, imagine if Devana is about to be pierced by a tail, her response is using the bunker, but if she forgets for a single second about it she is fucked or Evander charging at Mc at full speed and forgets for a moment to cover his head with antimatter, he is done.
By using a memory attack against then for something so quick Shen would need to be vigilant to undo the attack immediatly, maybe with Mc being stronger attacking him could give Shen some kind of recoil and not being able to respont in time after this would essentially mean the death of the others, so focusing on defense would be the best strategy.
I don't remember the specifics but either MC or Syla notices that the MC isn't as effected by Shen's power if other people's memories are involved, and it's noted that is a possibility the MC can use against Shen when he finishes the connections and breaks out.
Syla also tells him that once he's finished 6 of the 12 connections she might be able to teach him something new. It's also possible she'll have something else to teach him after all 12 connections are done.
It seems that Shen's power is about to become considerably less useful against the MC after he gets out of the dreams.
It'll still be a level 3 superhuman going after a level 4 superhuman, but MC might be able to just shrug off Shen's power soon.
I also doubt this would happen, but if MC has a connection with the memories of each of the 12 Apostles he could flood Shen's mind with their memories, which probably wouldn't go so well for Shen maintaining his concentration.
 
4.80 star(s) 388 Votes