Wouldn't this be okay though?
If patreon is a 'open bag' with no entitlements or expectations, it's simply donating to an artist and supporting them in their endeavors - why would these examples be scams?
--
Switching topics, I love the art style / color palette in the example images, the whole aesthetic looks unique / amazing.
Hoping to see this game grow and expand.
The difference lies in the context.
This game has no set schedule from what I can see, and no excuses or promises have been made.
When a delay happens, it is plainly stated, and the payments are paused.
Geseeki and the LoK team made countless, progressively more abstract excuses and in the case of the latter one even took to this forum to complain about his Filipino girlfriend (whom he went to visit using Patreon money, they had lots of Patreon-funded vacations which is fine but they lied about having them) cucking him and turning into a MRA/MGTOW person because of it. They made promises they failed to execute on, made several excuses after, restarted the game to get a fresh start because it was too hard to work on, figured out making a 3D game with costume damage, combat, exploration, dynamic quests, high detail animation is harder than a simple dialogue-driven one, and then went back to the old engine but now in a non-working state. Along with the smug superiority the original thread had from someone who allegedly "worked at EA" and "knew better" it piles up.
I haven't been following this game as much as I followed either of those but the circumstances seem to be very different.
Those two feel like scams because the pretty obvious lies get irritating, with this game I just see "yep, here's a delay, payments paused." The dev is just doing what they can, when they can, and showing transparency while also replacing stuff (which is far easier than making new assets) as their style improves. If there's info out there I'm not privy to that's a whole other can of worms and I can't rule that out. So far, though, seems like the open bag is fine here. I wouldn't give money to a bag that lied to me and blamed me for their faults.
Those kinds of "updates" shouldn't be allowed. It's even worse since the version with more content gets removed, and then the devs add said content again, unchanged, back into the game slowly to milk their Patreons.
Shouldn't be allowed by whom? I'm genuinely curious who the authority figure is here.
If the game is being reworked from the ground up because the dev learned new techniques taking out existing content to put it back in makes sense. You can still download the previous version with all the content left in it.