ImariKurumi
Member
- Nov 21, 2022
- 364
- 622
- 217
She's my favourite too.
Her bubbly & flirty personality is a nice contrast to the depression in the story and other LIs lol.
Wonder if she will be an LI too?
Her bubbly & flirty personality is a nice contrast to the depression in the story and other LIs lol.
Wonder if she will be an LI too?
Michkooo
Member
- Jun 25, 2024
- 191
- 464
- 107
slick97
Active Member
- Dec 2, 2021
- 826
- 2,204
- 377
JPK could be pulling a Chasing Sunsets on us quite honestly. Not enough story threads line-up for her to realistically be the MC's half-sister.
But... that wouldn't stop JPK from crushing my soul and laughing maniacally while ripping a romance path with Tracy/Madelyn away from me...
- Sep 18, 2023
- 245
- 1,208
- 244
If jpk was referencing my game I'd feel incredibly honored, but its probably just an expressionAlso, wasn't the whole "Winters is a pale blonde" a reference to Once Again?
There are lots of verrrrrry valid reasons why a relationship with madelyn would be a very very bad idea.
Than you see her ingame and think fuck it, shes perfect!
she made the mc smile quite a bit too (more than anyone else?) and despite the fact that both of their meetings were utterly sad.
Than you see her ingame and think fuck it, shes perfect!
she made the mc smile quite a bit too (more than anyone else?) and despite the fact that both of their meetings were utterly sad.
QueenOliviaDunne
Newbie
- Jan 29, 2025
- 22
- 50
- 22
Nah man, there could be 1000 alternate versions of her and they would all be kind, adorable and cute.
If theres anything nefarious about here, than shes unaware of it, im 1000% convinced of that.
she has a good conman setupd/spot but her being a conman would entirely eradicate my confidence about being able to read people lmao and in case of the mc i would just give up any remaing hope in humanity and go upwards to ella and maddy
Danford Ambrosia
Member
- Jul 16, 2018
- 425
- 409
- 209
Are my eyes deceiving me? The preview pictures look like this VN has normal/realistic looking men in it. Can it be true? Could this be one of those extremely rare instances where men (apart from the MC) look like... normal men?
Effort was made for sure. I even noticed a flaccid dick that wasn't the size of a fucking boner.
Skep-tiker
Well-Known Member
- Oct 11, 2023
- 1,986
- 2,551
- 338
Well i could live with her being MCs half roommate....
As if that has stopped me in the past...
elkon98
New Member
- Jun 20, 2025
- 8
- 7
- 13
Bombmaster
Well-Known Member
- May 8, 2022
- 1,478
- 2,487
- 387
Is not perfect, is crazy.
But this story is showing spiritism, now predestination. If i was a betting man she is going to be in your life one way or another.
Be as family or more.
QueenOliviaDunne
No. But feel free to give us reasons, the bit in the past showing Ella writing her novel have enough context to the lost sibling plot.
Last edited:
Do I understand this correctly? John's father wants John to date and marry Lily to form an alliance, but a fateful meeting with Ella ruins everything. John's father kicks him out and gives him nothing, but John knows his father's dirty secret and gets a large sum of money to open a company. Since Lily still cares about John, she'll jump in at some point
I doubt the conflict between john and his father was about Lily, maybe about ella but i doubt that too. I feel like the conflict was related to the secret
shenlao
Member
- Aug 31, 2022
- 276
- 384
- 82
I think unlikely happen thou hahahaha
its crystal clear that Ella IS Madelyn Half-Sister. Ella's Father Cheating with Madelyn's Mom. Now i wonder how/why people thinking that Madelyn is MC's Half-sister? IF Madelyn is MC's Half-sister, than Ella is MC's Half-sister too.
Since its clear, that Madelyn's, Ella's and MC's Mom are different, so the silver lining will be from the Father. When MC married with Ella, MC's Mom will be likely trace Ella's background first, and its impossible MC's Mom will stay shut about it.
Skep-tiker
Well-Known Member
- Oct 11, 2023
- 1,986
- 2,551
- 338
Because Madelyn describes her biological father as a guy with money, and it seema clear that MCs father had deserved the end of his marriage. Following standard AVN protocol, this is plenty of hints
shenlao
Member
- Aug 31, 2022
- 276
- 384
- 82
I'm still not convinced with that theory thou, since MC's mother can digging information, and i'm very sure MC and his mom isn't naive if we read the dialog between them when they're digging Madelyn's background
slick97
Active Member
- Dec 2, 2021
- 826
- 2,204
- 377
Normally I'd agree, but if I'm understanding the dialogue from Madelyn correctly then her and Ella only share the dad, not the same mom. If Madelyn's dad is the MC's dad as well, then Ella would also be his half sister (which would make the story quite awkward since incest isn't planned).
I think Ella knew her time was limited and tried setting pieces in motion to help the MC move on from her while also giving her half-sister a family she's probably always wanted as well. I initially thought Ella titling her story "the missing piece" was alluding to Madelyn, but it most likely is a self reference as she is quite literally the missing piece (due to.. you know... dying...).
Skep-tiker
Well-Known Member
- Oct 11, 2023
- 1,986
- 2,551
- 338
i understood it have been different fathers. Why else should Tracy-Madeleines dying mother know about Ella? Anyhow, even if your right, there have been weirder things in AVNs. Then again, my first avn was sisterly lust.. so maybe i just dont care.