Agreed. Reconciling with Naomi, was a good idea, just not in the way in went down. As you said 'forced'. From the get go, I just wanted Ada. You know how I am about Asians and it's very rare that one stands out and I like them. So, that was a kick in the nuts. So, restart and go full on Mira. But, then there's also Naomi. She didn't do anything wrong. If the MC REALLY needed her, instead of screaming and yelling at her, he should've went to where she was. Not a simp decision on that. Just facts. So, I'll also do a second save for just her.
Yeah, I am fine with the reconciliation, if players want, but the railroading into reconciliation was too much. And the next day they are hanging out like good friends who don't have a ton of baggage. It was ridiculous.
Ada was my first choice but she is too hung up on Chris, Chris is too hung up on her. I just feel like if someone cuffed them to an interrogation table and told them to talk it out it wouldn't take very long for them to be back together. One good long talk would heal that relationship. Mira is too plain jane and I don't like that she seems to know all of Damon's secrets and, possibly, all of the MC's secrets too. Naomi looks weird but otherwise I agree she didn't do a thing wrong. She had a volleyball tournament, she had commitments, responsibilities. The MC could have gone to her. I don't really think the MC was as committed to their relationship as she was, he never went to her games and he didn't even know her favorite book was Beloved by Toni Morrison. How do you not know that shit about the woman who you think is your soulmate? How do you not go to her events when she is trying to become a professional volleyball player?
At this point I feel like the best possible golden ending would be one where the MC flips literally everyone the middle finger, skips town, and heads off to college in another state and never interacts with any of these people ever again. That way he can get his own self in order and find a new love interest without all the baggage.
But I also feel any player who tries to go that route (assuming the game even allows you to call all these people out on their bullshit and walk away) is just going to get an ending that craps on us for being selfish and not being willing to compromise ourselves to desperately fling ourselves at someone broken. Or rejecting every potential route will wind up with you forced back with your ex because you clearly couldn't get over her (even if you were actively rejecting her along the way as well).
Though I still say that 99% of the problems in this story all stem from the fact that literally no one is willing to talk about anything. Almost every crisis and problem is created by people keeping secrets, or being unwilling to talk about how they really feel or what their motivations are. If everyone had been honest and open the story would have been over in about 20 minutes and everyone would be much, much happier. And it gets kind of frustrating being at the center of this passive-aggressive vortex when the game clearly expects you to be the bigger man and forgive everyone else's bullshit.
Yeah, I would love a "nukes them from orbit" option when all the secrets come out. Even Erica, Naomi's ex-volleyball partner, knew that Damon was trying to reconcile Naomi with the MC. It's ridiculous the number of people who know something about why his mother left and yet don't feel it is right for them to share that information with him. The problem is that there is a definite sense of being "railroaded" in certain relationships. The MC can't stay mad at Damon about anything, he HAS to reconcile with Naomi, he has to hang out with Mira...
If people would actually tell the MC what is
actually happening then I wouldn't be so annoyed by the manufactured drama. But no one is willing to tell him a damn thing. As if the MC is either an infant OR so mentally unstable that they worry telling him anything would result in him going catatonic. When the MC tries to angrily walk away from Damon it lasts only a few seconds. When Damon does it the MC can't do anything to keep him from leaving. Just want the MC to actually get answers so the audience doesn't go mad waiting.