Dude , after reading your long post , I miss period and comma so much.
I straight up just barely skimmed through it after I noticed the lack of punctuation. However, I understood his meaning, the less we are given and the longer it takes, the greater people will lose interest. I deeply enjoyed the game in its first incarnation and frankly saw no real issue with the mc or story. My expectations are not high for porn games but it was actually pretty good ngl. I never played the second incarnation because I made the wise decision to read people's feedback. I didn't want my experience ruined. The new version came out and I was initially happy with it until it became clear that there was not much there. So, I waited. I knew that the longer I waited, the more content I would have. Yet, I made sure to check up on progress and read what people said.
Now, I only keep the book mark and look over it while going through my bookmarks list. This the one time I decide to see. Unfortunately, I think that (just a theory) Waifston succumbed to feature creep. According to a Wikipedia definition: "Feature creep is
the excessive ongoing expansion or addition of new features in a product, especially in computer software, video games and consumer and business electronics." - Wikipedia
I don't know but this seems to fit with what everyone else has been saying for a while now. At first, he worked on the main girls and the main features. However, he then felt like he needed to add more. Characters, locations, storylines, features, etc. This made sense since there were already hints of other characters. If the main characters were either completed or mostly completed, with future updates optimized and improving their paths, then these character could be reasonably be implemented. Unfortunately, it seems as though everything was done all at once, but in a less beneficial way. Main girls content would be cut until reimplemented and new girls would become the focus. He wanted to have his cake and eat it too. But there would always be more. On top of that, the story would be completely changed, which throws people off.
To be frank, all of the new girls and locations could have been added much later while also keeping the other girls' content. If improvements needed to be made, then they would be made while (possibly) including newer content. Or, whole game done and then improvement patches later on.
I will say that I know these updates take time, especially if only one person is working on it. Not all content creators work as efficiently and this must be considered, especially in this situation. I still believe that the end product will be good, whenever it comes out. A rushed game is just as bad, if not worse. But time is fleeting, people move on. I will wait patiently, but how many will also wait? Who knows.
Waifston, your game was good, and no doubt this version will be just as good, if not hopefully better. I wish you the best of luck, along with good health, both physical and mental. In no way am I trying to tell you how to make your game, I am in no position to do so nor have the power. I simply aired out an observation I made more than a year ago. If there is anything anyone disagrees with or has a comment on, do please reply.
TL;DR: Unlimited Pleasure seems to be suffering from feature creep, and the game could have had all the new content and characters after the main girls were done. But you all already knew that second half.