I'd deleted the game off my computer since I'd made that post, but I decided to redownload it and check what was up, and yeah, for the download on this page that happens, but then I remembered that I'd upgraded to 1.1.6 after a little bit of playing around, so I tracked down the thread I downloaded that from and downloaded the game from there and now all the saves worked, so yeah, seems to have been version compatibility issuesIt seems like Saves 1 and 2 don't pop up for me, but 1 does?
On that note, I won't leave you high and dry on what thread I got the 1.1.6 version from, here you go: https://f95zone.to/threads/modifications-fvlaenix-modifications.117902/post-9682086