- Sep 26, 2021
- 100
- 106
Oh, we are running off topic and before a mod goes angry we better "slow down", sorry to put a lid on our fun.
Well, i admit i have less knowledge about the music world, my info is based on talks with a lot of musician during our own sound recording in the studios. As far as i understood lately their work is more and more commission work, the label decides what the musician has to prepare. Just remember how much (good) songs get refused by a Label. Of course there are famous musician who could do their stuff but the mainstream musician is somehow caged. The end-consumer gets the songs like processed food. OK, this impression could be total wrong but that's how i was told.
So let go back to the original posts, to compare music dev with games i would say music is more equal to triple a or a complete release of a game where the dev is done in background. With the games here we have different approaches, some like WAL are more like comic or TV series, some others are more like seeing the development ( like the pre-stage "written, storyboard, filmed, edited" ). Lol, and of course there are games like "wtf is the dev doing". But never forget, the devs here are normally not professionals (e.g. WAL is the first game of the "nuts").
Only with short comics you could afford a full release, for longer comics (and TV series) you create something like a framework and fill this over time (hehe similar to WAL). So no complete release, normally you send only few chapters/shows to the publisher and during the "airing" you work on the next chapters. This type of work works like a safety feature e.g. what happens if the artist can't deliver or the consumers don't like how the art is going. There is even another buffer called "filler chapter", you get a filler when something went wrong. Lets see the worst case, the show/comic doesn't work and needed to be axed, there is still enough time to do a closure chapter.
On a side-note: I have an active manga (comic) in work, it started in 2012 and has now more than 120 chapters and hopeful will not end soon. It has changed over time, heck even during times i had to change the story slightly to be "political correct" (or whatever they will call this fad). To release it as whole at start would be impossible
Interesting perspective on how comics work. Makes sense, especially if it's an untested story/market.
I think the musicians you have dealt with are more hired guns, or hired studio musician. Studio Musicians more or less show up, get the music, play a few takes, and then F!@#$ with money in hand. HAHA. However, composers and song writers also fit what you have described. Composers and song writers tend to be employed by a label/production company to write a specific style, or piece to fit the manufactured group/band/movie/game/etc. On the other hand, artist/bands are independent and either have their music licensed, or released by a label, but function outside the constraints of the label... Well, within and outside depending on how successful their project is, or has become. Most bands now start on an indie label, which tends to give artist full range, but major labels do tend to have a stronger influence over a bands process. However, if a band has proven their worth (Foo Fighters, Red Hot Chili Peppers), then they can do Whatever the F!@#4 they wish.