Avaron1974
Resident Lesbian
- Aug 22, 2018
- 28,174
- 97,276
- 1,021
Monica asks him to stay right after he tells her his will conditions. Jenna and Katie do the same.
Zarah is trying to set him up with Monica but hasn't been told about the will yet.
- Thread starter UncleVT
- Start date
Zarah is trying to set him up with Monica but hasn't been told about the will yet.
Boracle
Member
- Jun 3, 2017
- 230
- 470
- 257
The more i replay parts of the game, the more i'm getting convinced that Zarah is Lily's biological mother. They have some physical similarities, especially with the first episodes. Then we have Zarah, who's in the fashion business and Lily who has a natural gift/talent for designing clothes and a well developed fashion sense. Kinda hard to get that trait from 2 doctor parents. Think this is one more surprise that awaits us there in the future. Won't be surprised at all if she turns out to be Mc's half-sister. Not the ending Lily fans want but a pretty plausible one.
Avaron1974
Resident Lesbian
- Aug 22, 2018
- 28,174
- 97,276
- 1,021
No incest in the game at all though so not that plausible.
And how would be Zarah's daughter make her MC half sister?
Boracle
Member
- Jun 3, 2017
- 230
- 470
- 257
In the same way Dog-Boy could be MC's half-brother...
And since someone mentioned grouping of women again earlier... The idea of 2 sisters together is not always a pleasant one ...
Avaron1974
Resident Lesbian
- Aug 22, 2018
- 28,174
- 97,276
- 1,021
MC isn't fucking dog boy.
Lily has fucked the MC and this game has no incest so still not a plausible theory.
I'm just gonna leave you to it.
Every single theory you've come up with has been so far off the reservation and totally against anything resembling logical that the only explanation in game for any of it to work is "a wizard did it".
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
How is it fighting common sense? People have made valid points that you yourself just shoot down because you disagree yet make only the point that makes sense to you.
Maybe because he's young and dumb for one. He can choose to start things with multiple people before he even gets his own home so to begin with he has nowhere else to go. Now once he get's it yes, despite what he says to Elaine, it doesn't make that much sense for him to stay with Monica but he HAS to stay there, you know, for the drama.
What defies logic? Most of this is likely just arguing what we can't do much with, with the choices in game.
Ok, the "Nah, love" made me laugh. But yeah, I replayed this part last night and the way she jumps at it is very suspect.You think I'm dumb, got it. And if you mean the way I'm replying with answering point by point that is because I'm dyslexic and have OCD tendencies so have to take my time to read, re-read and re-read again, reply and check multiple times before I post so that's why it takes me so long to do so. And I don't mind snark, I find it funny.
Makes sense.
Can I just ask you, what is your main game like? Who are you pursuing/ignoring? Do you plan to take the money? I get you'll likely do most if not all once all is said and done and it's complete but which way are you playing on your main playthrough? (If you don't mind me asking)
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
Avaron1974
Resident Lesbian
- Aug 22, 2018
- 28,174
- 97,276
- 1,021
My main playthrough is for Lily.Can I just ask you, what is your main game like? Who are you pursuing/ignoring? Do you plan to take the money? I get you'll likely do most if not all once all is said and done and it's complete but which way are you playing on your main playthrough? (If you don't mind me asking)
I have saves for all of them but Lily is my main one.
He isn't dumb. A lot of things can be said about many of the characters in the game but him being dumb isn't one of them.
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
Cool, thank you.
I didn't mean dumb as in his overall intelligence, I meant in terms of choices he (We) can make. Take the party night for example. If you go to extremes, you can't honestly say that wasn't a dumb thing to do. (Justified maybe) but still dumb.
You yourself point out why should he stay with Monica when he could move out and be in the money, that would be dumb, no?
Avaron1974
Resident Lesbian
- Aug 22, 2018
- 28,174
- 97,276
- 1,021
No, I said starting a relationship with someone else not in that house and staying there would be dumb.
He's picked someone else, he has his own life to lead and won't be there forever so he starts his new life with his new love interests and moves on because that's how life works.
The only time it makes sense to stay living at Monica's is if you are with Monica herself.
The second you tell her you're fucking one of her kids she's going to remove your balls so moving out would make sense there too.
He only went to Monica's in the first place because he had nowhere else to go, that is no longer the case and once a new relationship has started it makes even les sense to be staying there.
He has hiw new relationship and possible future children to think about which that money would set them all for life. So yes, I do whole heartedly believe staying at Monica's after starting a relationship with someone else and giving up that money for no reason would be dumb as all hell.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 14,400
- 35,671
- 997
Lot of assumptions here on Elaine's conditions when in reality...we know absoloutely fuck all what they are. So be careful coming across as making facts when in reality they are opinions.
- Mar 8, 2018
- 2,767
- 3,810
- 463
That's true, but if her conditions don't involve the MC one way or another the whole Elaine story is kinda pointless.
- Jul 12, 2020
- 14,400
- 35,671
- 997
Oh agree, they must at some level...as will our mystery third wheel too. Dad all over isn't it (from what we have been told about him) to have the three of us all trying to screw people over...namely us as the huge disappointment we obviously were to him.
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
Ok, my bad.
What do you mean, he's picked someone else? Again, that would be YOUR choice, in YOUR game. Most peoples games can play out quite differently depending on choice so you can't really say the MC DID this and DID that, if it is a choice with different out comes.
Yeah I can agree with that.
Now this is what I'm dying to see the outcome of!
I like the way you look at that.
- Mar 8, 2018
- 2,767
- 3,810
- 463
I think her point is you pick Monica you stay, you pick someone else you move out.
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
Ah, ok. I guess I read it wrong and misunderstood.
- Mar 8, 2018
- 2,767
- 3,810
- 463
We'll see.Ah, ok. I guess I read it wrong and misunderstood.
Sooo, Natasha and Roger coming back at some point. I guess Natasha could be Zarah's?
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
Oh no, you won't bait me, sir!We'll see.
- Mar 8, 2018
- 2,767
- 3,810
- 463
Yeah, sorry.
I have wondered why they're coming back, no characters are random really.
Cigar-Ferras
Well-Known Member
- Jan 22, 2019
- 1,089
- 2,779
- 457
Maybe Natasha is hungry for round 2? Maybe Roger wants revenge (If you went full extreme) at the party. Or maybe he's just following Natasha around.Yeah, sorry.