Now calling his story "childishly stupid," that's just rude. One thing I've learned in life; those who can't do, criticize. Its like someone on F95 said, 'similar to calling my girlfriend ugly but still checking out her ass while going to fap about her.' Although he put it better than I. Your calling his story, "unconvincing" and saying he needs " little bit more intelligent." Where's your story, or is the only thing you are good for to complain about something free given to you? Buddy, you can insult me all you want as I've been called worse, but insulting the man who's pouring his heart and soul into this game where you just bitch and complain about isn't exactly acting like an adult yourself. Pot meet kettle. Although thats kind of funny: He needs to be more, intelligent. Sure, because he's trying to win an Academy Award for best screenplay.
And I absolutely hate your last sentence on the facepalming comment. Saying you can make comments, but he needs to be more patient than you. What a cowardly way to say that its ok for you to talk shit but he needs to shut up and take it. Just like a bully saying he can throw punches but he can't fight his own battles against people like you.
You should find something else to do other than insult people's hard work.
what a missinterpretation! even rude and insulting from one preaching against rudeness and insults. bigotry i say. to cut your bs and falsely twisting my words
1. i didn't attack dev's work in global as childishly stupid, just blackmail segment -> quote:
"maybe direction was right (main plot for sure, i liked it and put on watchlist),
but storywise everything around blackmail is so unconvincing, childishly stupid. of course that blackmail is necessary in this type of game, but cmmon do it at least little bit more intelligent."
2. movies, music, books... are all subject to critics and to all critics you can apply nonsense comparison you wrote "calling my girlfriend ugly but still checking out her ass"
and i don't have habit calling other people's gfs ugly and then fap on them. are you? mocking someone for what mother nature gave him/her is not nice, but criticize work is welcome. it might even help author to improve
same goes to another ignorant batch of remarks all about "if you didn't do something, you can't criticized it" aside fact you don't know anything about me, it is wrong! e.g. most respected book, movie, music, art critics never wrote book, made album. painting or movie and yet are highly respected by authors.
3. expecting story for academy award? hell no! but just not to insult inteligence yes.
4. the only thing i might agree is maybe i shouldn't be so sharp in objections and sugarcoated it, but you're last one to complain. no matter of words i used, argument stays and i'm not lonely.
5. the last, facepalming issue is most devious, malice twisting of my words and garnish with accusation that i'm coward and bully who wants to criticize but the one who is criticized should shut up. it is blatant lie. i said i was expecting debate from author not finger/facepalm -> quote: "
dev/author shouldn't respond on critics with facepalm but with argument", because work is in progress and can improve - that is why i put my critics in discussion thread, not at reviews.
as said this ends our debate, at least from my side. it is time to return thread to debate about product