2.30 star(s) 4 Votes

Ferghus

Engaged Member
Aug 25, 2017
3,145
4,936
468
I know this is probably a dead thread, but according to VirusTotal this game has a trojan? Just want to have people confirm if this is a false positive or not.

...And yes, I know VT is not 100% accurate. I'm just paranoid AF.
Question, do you understand how VirusTotal works?
 

Faponymous1

Newbie
Nov 22, 2020
28
10
93
Question, do you understand how VirusTotal works?
I admit, I don't know everything, mostly just that it checks the file using a group of antiviruses, but I like to use it as a way to satisfy my own paranoia at times. So, no. I don't know all of it.
That means you can feel free to enlighten me. Because I am quite frankly a fucking idiot at times.
No, this is not meant as a sarcastic response or anything, I mean it genuinely.
 

Ferghus

Engaged Member
Aug 25, 2017
3,145
4,936
468
I admit, I don't know everything, mostly just that it checks the file using a group of antiviruses, but I like to use it as a way to satisfy my own paranoia at times. So, no. I don't know all of it.
That means you can feel free to enlighten me. Because I am quite frankly a fucking idiot at times.
No, this is not meant as a sarcastic response or anything, I mean it genuinely.
So here's there thing, not all antiviruses are equal. Some are more accurate and reliable than others. This is important because not all antivirus programs on VirusTotal are reliable indicators of whether something is a virus. The other thing to be aware of is that some of these antiviruses aren't meant for personal computers. Industrial-grade antiviruses are more strict because a company's use of computers is generally more focused and limited and anything that's known to conflict with their chosen antivirus program are going to be whitelisted anyways.

Because of these two things, you shouldn't immediately freak out if you see one or even a few antiviruses flag a file. Ususally a low number of hits means it's a false positive. Find out if those antivirus programs are even reliable for what you're scanning. However, if a lot of them are flagging the file and even the well-known antivirses don't like the file, it's best to be cautious.

If you spend enough time on this site, you might pick up on some types of games being common candidates for false positives, like games that run on Godot, RPG Maker, and anything that makes use of text hooking to translate. That doesn't mean that these types of games are always safe, and the people downloading the files may not necessarily do their due diligence to ensure the file is safe. It's up to you to do your diligence to cross reference the VirusTotal results and make your best judgement. Try to look up whether the file it's flagging is commonly flagged as a false positive. Don't be lazy and assume that the first rando that answers your question actually knows whether something is a virus. If anything happens to your machine, you can only blame yourself.
 

Faponymous1

Newbie
Nov 22, 2020
28
10
93
So here's there thing, not all antiviruses are equal. Some are more accurate and reliable than others. This is important because not all antivirus programs on VirusTotal are reliable indicators of whether something is a virus. The other thing to be aware of is that some of these antiviruses aren't meant for personal computers. Industrial-grade antiviruses are more strict because a company's use of computers is generally more focused and limited and anything that's known to conflict with their chosen antivirus program are going to be whitelisted anyways.

Because of these two things, you shouldn't immediately freak out if you see one or even a few antiviruses flag a file. Ususally a low number of hits means it's a false positive. Find out if those antivirus programs are even reliable for what you're scanning. However, if a lot of them are flagging the file and even the well-known antivirses don't like the file, it's best to be cautious.

If you spend enough time on this site, you might pick up on some types of games being common candidates for false positives, like games that run on Godot, RPG Maker, and anything that makes use of text hooking to translate. That doesn't mean that these types of games are always safe, and the people downloading the files may not necessarily do their due diligence to ensure the file is safe. It's up to you to do your diligence to cross reference the VirusTotal results and make your best judgement. Try to look up whether the file it's flagging is commonly flagged as a false positive. Don't be lazy and assume that the first rando that answers your question actually knows whether something is a virus. If anything happens to your machine, you can only blame yourself.
So it does work kinda like how I imagined it. Glad to know my assumption wasn't too far off.
But yeah, I am very careful when it comes to my stuff. I often like to search threads in each game for the common words (Defender, Trojan, Virus, etc...) to check what they say and how many say it.

Thanks for the clarification and great explanation, Mate. Appreciate it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ferghus
2.30 star(s) 4 Votes