- Apr 26, 2020
- 15,399
- 35,951
Don't worry Koga, we still love your work!
- Thread starter 7767
- Start date
- Apr 26, 2020
- 15,399
- 35,951
They will have to make one that covers the entire damn basketball court.....
- Sep 26, 2019
- 7,515
- 14,666
I am glad you took the time and effort to make your mods to give those that want music to have a way.
I apologize If it sounded like I was dismissive of your mods.
- May 9, 2018
- 2,492
- 6,880
^^ Concur and repeat this. While I won't use them I am glad someone takes the time to make them for those who use them.
- Aug 14, 2018
- 3,188
- 34,287
Don't worry! And honestly: before I started with the "music - modding", I also often muted the sound...
I don't know the theatre room MIGHT be large enough
From the perspective of people who don't want the content, or the music, it's valid to wish they didn't bother with it to make the parts you do want better, or come faster. One of the differences between this music discussion, and other times people have complained about optional content is: The Dev asked for people's opinions on it.
The Dev is clearly trying to find out how many people actually care about the music content, so people who don't want him to spend time on it, regardless of their reason, are valid to the discussion. If BrainDrop had just started adding music and people started complaining, it'd be different. If someone had started the discussion with "Hey everybody, just want to say, I think music is a waste of time, and shouldn't be in any of these games" it would be different.
In *my opinion* music isn't necessary in the game. If BD winds up deciding it's good to have, and puts it in, I'm not going to complain, but my opinion is still valid to the question he asked.
- Oct 5, 2017
- 7,547
- 10,056
No he didn't. People literally are starting the discussion with "Hey everybody, just want to say, I think music is a waste of time, and shouldn't be in any of these games". If he chooses to make a poll on Patreon about it you vote for no music, but he literally did not ask anyone.
He must be having a hard time nerfing the MC's cock, that's why it takes so long from this update.
- Sep 26, 2019
- 7,515
- 14,666
That literally isn't the reason. Real life happens and makes certain devs rearrange their schedules.
Thankfully BD always delivers albeit some times it is slower than others (again real life shit happens) but no non-troll can honestly or literally say he ever milked his supporters.
It is normal for developers to start their games with all the energy and then lengthen the update times.
- Sep 26, 2019
- 7,515
- 14,666
That's human nature imo, not only devs.
If being a dev was a normal job it would have things like sick days, fmla, vacation time off etc. They don't though, so when working solo life's crazy situations still have to be dealt with and make for more noticeable delays.
- May 6, 2018
- 96
- 149
I also mute music most of the time because often the free music used is also used a lot by youtubers and it really takes me out of the experience to be like "I've heard this before". So if he hasn't started doing music I don't see much reason to start now.
now that my 2 cents are in there I just wanted to say the part with tia and jamie was hot as fuck and I hope jamie is more involved in the future like that.
now that my 2 cents are in there I just wanted to say the part with tia and jamie was hot as fuck and I hope jamie is more involved in the future like that.
My apologies, I misread, or misremembered the Mind Drop where he brought it up. He wasn't asking for people's opinion, the Dev shared his opinion that it wasn't necessary - which makes everyone who is sharing that it is also their opinion in support of the Dev's opinion. Still feels valid to me in this case.
- Oct 24, 2019
- 11,399
- 11,564
ok .. ok ... i've heard alot about music in this game (or ) others ... to tell the truth .. i've never in my life walked down the street checking out some young babes thinking ... where's that music coming from
- Oct 5, 2017
- 7,547
- 10,056
It doesn't add anything though. It's literally just '+1' posts. If you want to contribute to the discussion about music say something like for example I think music with lyrics is distracting, game music should be instrumental. Something about the merits of each character having a musical piece associated with them vs. music based on the mood and energy of the scene. Just something that actually adds to the conversation!
- May 16, 2020
- 120
- 344
But that should be the developer responsibility. You can always fix something within a game with mods but doesn't that just shows that there is something wrong with the game if you need mods to fix it? The fact that you don't like music in games and you proudly mute them all the time doesn't mean games don't need it. This should be a dev work to give players a choice, you can mute the music if you dont like it and the others are happy having music in.
- Oct 22, 2017
- 425
- 1,176
There are games that are like a blockbuster movie and really benefit from a good soundtrack. Then there are games, like WVM, that wouldn't need more than your random Spotify list - just some carefree background droning (if at all).
And that is much more subjective. If a dev can pull that off - great. If he can't, and BD seems to be that latter kind of dev, they really shouldn't do so but stick to what they like and can do. Everyone can just turn on the radio or play their default music - no need for BD to invest his time into finding the same 4 free tracks everyone is using.
Or to actually code a system for adding your music into the game, so we can avoid those infamous free tracks - you would still need to add your own favorite music - why has it to be inside the VN instead of just from your normal source of music?
If BD has no talent for choosing music the majority likes, the result of adding that to the game would be like that day at work where a colleague of mine played mongolian throat singing tracks almost all day ... "WHY!?"
Just because someone makes a mod for something doesn't necessarily mean that it's something that should have been part of the creative process of the modded product.
I'm using the "Reign of Terror" (Diablo) mod in Grim Dawn sometimes. This just means I like Diablo and would like to have more content in that universe. Neither should Grim Dawn be Diablo, nor should Diablo necessarily play like Grim Dawn. If anything, it means Diablo 4 should be out sooner and better than Diablo 3 was/is.
Like PrimeGuy I had to go back to see what exactly BD wrote.
- If we go on from 'BD just stated what he thinks', and just saying you share his views isn't relevant - how is then telling us that you don't and what type of music you would like or prefer to have relevant? (Based on BD just having told us his personal view on the topic, but not having started a discussion.)
- If we see this as a discussion about music in this VN in general, though, then both are relevant as they show what kind of music people would like to have in it (or not). This might let BD rethink his views if there was a vast majority that wanted music.
- If it had been a discussion about what type of music you like most in VNs or specific story circumstances (this time not related to where it comes from) - then yes, saying 'I mute VN music and listen to my own' doesn't really help anyone. But no one started that kind of discussion.
- And in case we just comment on BDs views of music in WVM - then again both kinds of comments are relevant, because they can give BD an impression of how others views on this topic do match his own - or don't.
And that is much more subjective. If a dev can pull that off - great. If he can't, and BD seems to be that latter kind of dev, they really shouldn't do so but stick to what they like and can do. Everyone can just turn on the radio or play their default music - no need for BD to invest his time into finding the same 4 free tracks everyone is using.
Or to actually code a system for adding your music into the game, so we can avoid those infamous free tracks - you would still need to add your own favorite music - why has it to be inside the VN instead of just from your normal source of music?
If BD has no talent for choosing music the majority likes, the result of adding that to the game would be like that day at work where a colleague of mine played mongolian throat singing tracks almost all day ... "WHY!?"
Just because someone makes a mod for something doesn't necessarily mean that it's something that should have been part of the creative process of the modded product.
I'm using the "Reign of Terror" (Diablo) mod in Grim Dawn sometimes. This just means I like Diablo and would like to have more content in that universe. Neither should Grim Dawn be Diablo, nor should Diablo necessarily play like Grim Dawn. If anything, it means Diablo 4 should be out sooner and better than Diablo 3 was/is.
Like PrimeGuy I had to go back to see what exactly BD wrote.
- If we go on from 'BD just stated what he thinks', and just saying you share his views isn't relevant - how is then telling us that you don't and what type of music you would like or prefer to have relevant? (Based on BD just having told us his personal view on the topic, but not having started a discussion.)
- If we see this as a discussion about music in this VN in general, though, then both are relevant as they show what kind of music people would like to have in it (or not). This might let BD rethink his views if there was a vast majority that wanted music.
- If it had been a discussion about what type of music you like most in VNs or specific story circumstances (this time not related to where it comes from) - then yes, saying 'I mute VN music and listen to my own' doesn't really help anyone. But no one started that kind of discussion.
- And in case we just comment on BDs views of music in WVM - then again both kinds of comments are relevant, because they can give BD an impression of how others views on this topic do match his own - or don't.
Last edited:
- Oct 31, 2018
- 487
- 1,027
Ah, yes. The VNs I play aren‘t kinetic enough so I need Walkthrough Mods to „fix“ them.
I think Ill wait until there's 1GB update but not play until I'm certain there's another update and when.
The story is too good to take a long pause. Not many games this good out there.
The story is too good to take a long pause. Not many games this good out there.