I'm not super familiar with the dev process so take these with a grain of salt and I realize the work isn't finished.
As a whole I liked the game so far but....
MC:
So he's a bit of a beta shrouded behind a mask of an alpha tbh. I guess i'm just too old to fall for the being a nice guy all the times will get you laid. It doesn't honestly and it depends on the girl/guy. And while i won't mention other games in this thread the option for having control over the mc's personality type goes a long way with replay ability.
Girls: Probably my biggest gripe is that they are just thrown at you constantly with no work involved. Decisions don't have much impact other than meet this girl or don't. The upshot is most of the girls are very well done and beautiful so no complaints there.
I guess maybe it's other peoples thing but the constant give me a kiss and hug gets really overplayed. It's super clingy and gets to almost cringe level by the end. The fact that either the MC or the Girls constantly need this reinforcement is just well...annoying.
Story: Pretty damn good so far man. This has the most potential and i'm seeing placeholder events that i'm sure will bear fruit.
The girlfriends "why dosen't he love me" over and over on the notepad was one of the first things i noticed and was pleasantly surprised because the game is really on rails right now. Looking forward to see how things play out. I've noticed others have commented on the writing style and while I do think it could be polished, overall its not all that terrible.
Artistic Choices: While i'm not a fan of cartoonishly large breasts which there are several in this game to my eyes it looks very unnatural, yes i realize others may like this. MC's dick is lol, what can i say... for me it would be way better without the overcompensation lol.
Animations: Pretty good so far my only criticism is there is very little choice or control yet. Many of the scenes have the exact same position ect so hoping for some more variety.
Overall i've enjoyed OP's game and am curious about others thoughts.
MC: totally agree on the MC's personality but as we're coming to find out a lot of his personality is or was shaped from what seems a a rough childhood that led him to losing his mother and a possible sister due to his father possibly abusing them
Girls: I would normally agree with you on this but the MC is supposed to be the most desired college basketball star and possible NBA star as well so there going to be lots of woman throwing them self at him just like they do to celebrities, in my opinion as long as he develops their story after we find out they're there to stay I'm okay with it
Story: the plot on this game might not be the best but the dev tries hard to give us a well thought out story with multiple things happening that have good potential
Artistic Choices: yeah I can see how people might dislike the size of certain things at the end at the day some are going to like or dislike it I personally don't mind it since it's better then some games I have tried playing where the boob size are bigger and less realistic seeming more like balls rather then boobs