- Oct 10, 2022
- 4,193
- 7,403
I also thought it was Elly. I still think there is a chance but I am leaning whatever happened it was MC who did it. Also, I think MC having memory lapses so he may have done something to one of the twins and not even remember it. Elly being the culprit maybe red herring and it was MC all along.My theory is that Elly has been in love with MC since they were kids. The repressed memories from the cabin were about Elly killing another girl that MC liked, out of jealousy. Elly kidnapped whichever twin MC showed more favor to, but only hurt them if MC made a move on them. Dad and Ashley covered up the original incident, and decided to keep the kids separated to avoid future problems. Ashley likely decided enough time had passed, and Elly had changed enough, to stop the separation. Unfortunately, Elly has clearly not changed at all, other than physically.
I don't think Ashley is involved at all, though I did find it odd that she seemed to go out of her way to avoid telling MC that Elly is Danielle. She had to have seen the PhotoGram shots of them together, and there is absolutely no reason she wouldn't have mentioned Danielle's name change to MC. So it is possible she was involved in Elly's efforts to deceive MC about her identity. There's a lot more evidence that Elly is the kidnapper, but I've typed up plenty already.
For Ashley part, I always though that it was weird Ashley did not talked about her with MC. She mentions here and there but they even have same classes so, at least she should have asked did you see Elly to MC? Btw, is not Elly short of Danielle? Did she change her name?