Recommending An annoyed fucking user's Tier List of Games with Actual Gameplay [150+ games rated]

[Supershadow30]

Nice thread! I'm curious about your thoughts on UzuraZanac's games, they're not mentioned in the thread yet it seems.

Setalia the Demon Realm: 2D pixelart metroidvania where you play a futa with a minigun.
-You move with WASD, and aim and shoot with the mouse.
-Almost all enemies will attack to undress you and grapple you to fuck you when naked.

Seal of Lutellaria: 2D pixelart metroidvania again, although this time your MC has a sword-gun.
-You only have keyboard controls this time. One handed play is possible with the right binds, but definitely not easy.
-Melee attacks come out slow, but dodging shortens the attack cooldown (while using ammo).
-Shots come out quick, but use up ammo that need to be reloaded eventually.
-Just like before, enemies will attack to undress you and fuck you when naked.
-However you can also fuck downed enemies to regen health.

I believe they fit the bill as B tier platformers at least, pushing on A tier
(if you're ok playing 2 handed and into futa x women/futa/flesh abomination)

 

[zzyyxx]

Ah, the pain of being someone who hates tentacles, rape, monsters on girls, insects (what the fuck) and all that kind of stuff. Hundreds of games and almost nothing to play. I appreciate the list though, it's annoying to try and sort by combat in the main page and get thousands of ren'py VNs that have a "click to punch" minigame. Hell, trying to see if anyone created an rts with H-content is nearly impossible since the strategy tag is spammed with games that have no real strategy content.

 

[XulOnTuesday]

Ah, the pain of being someone who hates tentacles, rape, monsters on girls, insects (what the fuck) and all that kind of stuff. Hundreds of games and almost nothing to play. I appreciate the list though, it's annoying to try and sort by combat in the main page and get thousands of ren'py VNs that have a "click to punch" minigame. Hell, trying to see if anyone created an rts with H-content is nearly impossible since the strategy tag is spammed with games that have no real strategy content.

A sexy RTS without "tentacles, rape, monsters on girls, insects" seems kind of boring, just due to lack of enemy variety. What do you imagine that would look like? I'm genuinely interested.

 

[crap]

Two sidescrolling beatemups from the same developer that are conspicuously absent from this thread:

Ayura Crisis

Eris Dysnomia

 

[TaniKun]

I have, and I actually did. If I partner up with an artist I definitely have the required skills, but I don't have the persistence.

Plus, there is stuff that suits me. I'm collecting it in this thread.

hey i can do the art if u want to make a game ping me if u want to see my art

 

[zzyyxx]

A sexy RTS without "tentacles, rape, monsters on girls, insects" seems kind of boring, just due to lack of enemy variety. What do you imagine that would look like? I'm genuinely interested.

Same as anything, really. The RTS portion can be like anything else. Overworld 2d like Age of Empires or Stronghold, up close like mount and blade (I think there's a futa themed game with this in mind already), or to stretch the genre definition just copy sengoku rance. You can integrate sex through the gameplay (healer units, succubus units, etc.) or as an end of mission reward for conquering/liberating a settlement, depending on playing an evil or good faction.

If you really wanted to, you could make a city sim where population growth occurs through lewd scenes. Take a game like the Nations Gold - workers could take short rests at home, and hovering over their homes will make it transparent and show an animation occurring on the inside. After a while, you have a new citizen starting in a "baby" phase on a timer that goes through different life stages until adulthood. Have prostitution buildings, etc.

I'm not against dark elements being part of a game but when it's very clearly the focus or what the creator's fetish is based around, I'm not interested. I don't mind say a demon army showing up as an endgame threat and forcing women in places they conquer, because to me that's just motivation to play better and protect my people. I just really dislike opening a preview page and the first 4 images are of some young terrified girl crying while gross creatures abuse her. Fat old men included.

 

[johnmarstonalternative]

lovely thread

 

[zoobdoob]

 

[Gothgirlgames]

Give a try on Family trouble it's has stats, rpg sheets, interactivity, your choice's have consequences, turn based combat, and more.

 

[ViviX12]

Give a try on Family trouble it's has stats, rpg sheets, interactivity, your choice's have consequences, turn based combat, and more.

And yet it's marked as a Ren'py VN? 3dcg one at that

 

[Gothgirlgames]

And yet it's marked as a Ren'py VN? 3dcg ome at that

Yes, turn based combat, with rpg elements aren't hard to do at renpy.

 

[triodon]

There is one truth in this world.
All of your tastes are shit outside of mine, including the OP.

Yes, that would indeed be the case, IF he had any taste and IF "my taste" didn't objectify 80% of the games in principle. You don't think I'm a fool who saw the first 3 Ren'py games in the trends and started fighting with the first ambassador of true opinion I saw. I have experience and experience doesn't end exclusively with my favourite genre alone - all of them, I've played them all, just about everything.
In order not to be unfounded, I'll use an example from this tier list to prove my point:

Platformers category | S
FlipWitch | Generic platforming with a bias towards . . . apparently to line the pockets of its author. Most of the game is about running and shooting, with the rare CGI made from being. There's nothing remarkable, interesting or revolutionary about it compared to a million of them, but for some reason it's nested in the S category, not the C.​
Cosmobreeder | Generic metroidvania in the vein of "the old days", including boring and meditative gameplay. You also run and shoot, but with CGI already under the pixels. Added, again apparently on the roulette principle, should be in C, not S​
Crisis Point Extinction | Generic action-platformer that the author called metroidvania. You also run and shoot, only with CGI already under the pixels. Added on the principle of fortune-telling in the S range, although it should be in the C.​
Alien Quest Eve | FINALLY something good. Yes, it's also the usual metroidvania, but with really good graphics rather than trying to pull it off like FlipWitch, with moderately interesting enemies, good animations and bosses. Still, I'd personally put it in the A category, because the fact that it's generic and saggy still knocks.​
Night of Revenge | It's not a bad game either, but it's not S either, it's A. If you spend a few minutes with this game, you'll realise that apart from the incredible (no joke) CGI, animations and graphics, there's really nothing to it, and nothing at all. Combat is one-button, with no meaningful character development, and monsters and bosses, although there are plenty, can be easily killed with a single mouse click.​
Holy Knight Ricca | Another game, which can already claim to be S-tier, but is also closer to A. It's quite well made and apart from the dullest plot and unchanging but well realised gameplay, everything is fine with it. The only downside here is that, apart from the well realised potential, it doesn't offer anything radically new.​
Succubus Affection | Not a bad game that deserves B rather than S. Its problem is that despite the seeming variety of everything, that variety isn't there. You run around, grind mobs and sometimes fight bosses - that's it. Nothing memorable about mobs and bosses like in FOBS, even though it's the same author.​
My forest home | A completely generic action-platformer with cute graphics and a scale no higher than B, even though it's closer to C in general. It's small, cute and afraid to experiment beyond the trope it's riddled with, and it suffers for it. Like most games like this.​
Ghost Hunter Vena | Real old-school, which I wouldn't put on the list at all considering how old it is. This game, while bona fide, is extremely outdated in gameplay and graphics. It is EXTREMELY boring to play, and really, there's no reason to play it. It's worth leaving it out of what they like to call the chronicles of history, but not radiocarbon analysis.​
Magic Castle Repure Aria 2 | No comment. This was planted here, apparently by someone, because I have no idea why it's here or why it's here. It's not a game or a product, it's a phenomenon called "trash".​
Castle of Temptation | Like Drain Mansion, but worse and more, without looking beyond C. The problem here is that apart from the rather specious graphics and animations, the puzzles and gameplay itself is extremely boring and uninventive. You run from one point to another, sometimes meeting slightly different monsters and that's it.​
Max the Elf | I'm not going to comment on that. The author has apparently gone completely insane.​

And what do we have in the end? Out of 12 applicants, only 3 remain normal, and yes almost all normal should be in A, but not S. And this is the first top and S-tier, and what comes next I can't even talk about. Where are FOBS, Drain mansion, Eroico and a bunch of other great games? Oh yeah, because the author didn't bother to play these games, but only to watch them - they can't pick beyond B and C range.
Alright guys, I guess that's it. Next time you defend the honour of your dearly beloved master, remember to take out little Joe. I hear it helps.

 

[bazbj77]

I'm sick of Visual Novels, Kinetic Novels, click-all-the-options-to-see-the-porn-games, RPG maker shovelware, and the likes. Hundreds of threads here and on reddit show that there is a demand for porn games that are actual, you know, fucking games. But theres no exhaustive list. Last night I got sufficiently pissed that I decided to make my own.

This list is going to be highly subjective. This list is going to be built up over time. This list will not feature generic ass 3d models (unless they are tied to good gameplay), generic ass japanese art that looks like it was photocopied from one of the other 4000 japanese shovelware games (unless its tied to good gameplay). This list will not attempt to be consistent in its distinction between visual novels/click to get the porn games and management games because its fluid as fuck, so I'm going by feel, if you don't like the way I included it fuck you, deal with it.

Update 2022-03-21: I will divide games into three categories, "platformers", "non-platformers" (because a lot of these are platformers), and "3D" (referring to actual 3D games, not 3D renders). I am lumping certain sidescrollers in with platformers. Do give the non-platformers category a go, there is some creative stuff in there. (Unfortunately not enough, though). Within these I will use the following tiers:

• S-Tier: These games have great gameplay and great porn.
• A-Tier: These games have either good gameplay and great porn, or great gameplay and good porn.
• B-Tier: These games are above average and enjoyable in either gameplay or porn.
• C-Tier: These games are average and mostly unremarkable, or they have some flaws that make a higher tier unjustifiable. Play these after you are done with the upper tiers.
• D-Tier: These games are below average in some respects, but you might still be able to draw some enjoyment from them. This usually means the gameplay is bad, since a bad art style can be compensated by good gameplay easier than the other way around.
• F-Tier: These games are garbage. Do not play.
• Other: These do not fit in the above scheme, usually because I have not played them and I do not want to rate games I have not played. They might also not fit the criteria of being either interesting or having good gameplay (i.e. they might be RPGmaker trash), but I still want to give my opinion on them. (Looking at you, Queen Opala.)

I will roughly attempt to order these within category by quality, but that is difficult. This ordering is more accurate in the higher tiers.
I would like to emphasize that this list is ultimately subjective. If you don't like it, go find another list.

Another user pointed out that I seem to prefer Female Protagonist / Male Domination games. This may be accurate. I tend to have long edging sessions when playing these, so I'm generally looking for something that gives me constant eye candy. I favor background characters with slutty clothes over long, drawn out sex scenes.

I also don't like goblins. They are not real monsters and make it unnecessarily difficult to find proper monster fucking.

With that in mind, here you go:

Spoiler: Platformers

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Non-Platformers

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: 3D

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Other Garbage

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Changelog

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Finally, do check out the suggestions by other users in this thread. They might not always match my tastes, but they might match yours.

Finally, a word of advice on how to filter out most of the garbage to find good games easier:

• Go to the latest updates page.
• In "Engine", either choose "Unity" (and maybe "Other"), or filter out RPGM and Renpy. There are sometimes good, fappable games (or even engaging VNs) made in Renpy, and rarely there are good RPGM games. But the vast majority of good porn games are made with Unity. (And some of the good Japnese games use their own weird engines, hence "Other").
• In Prefix "Other", filter out "VN". This is the single most important filter.
• In "Prefix: Status", filter out "Abandoned" and "On hold".
• Obviously, you can also use tags associated with gameplay to find proper games. "Platformer" and "Sidescroller" are obvious choices, but there is still a lot of shovelware. It is generally also worth excluding "3dcg".

Cheers.

Scarlet Maiden Should be S Tier

 

[DuniX]

Yes, that would indeed be the case, IF he had any taste and IF "my taste" didn't objectify 80% of the games in principle. You don't think I'm a fool who saw the first 3 Ren'py games in the trends and started fighting with the first ambassador of true opinion I saw. I have experience and experience doesn't end exclusively with my favourite genre alone - all of them, I've played them all, just about everything.
In order not to be unfounded, I'll use an example from this tier list to prove my point:

Platformers category | S
FlipWitch | Generic platforming with a bias towards . . . apparently to line the pockets of its author. Most of the game is about running and shooting, with the rare CGI made from being. There's nothing remarkable, interesting or revolutionary about it compared to a million of them, but for some reason it's nested in the S category, not the C.​
Cosmobreeder | Generic metroidvania in the vein of "the old days", including boring and meditative gameplay. You also run and shoot, but with CGI already under the pixels. Added, again apparently on the roulette principle, should be in C, not S​
Crisis Point Extinction | Generic action-platformer that the author called metroidvania. You also run and shoot, only with CGI already under the pixels. Added on the principle of fortune-telling in the S range, although it should be in the C.​
Alien Quest Eve | FINALLY something good. Yes, it's also the usual metroidvania, but with really good graphics rather than trying to pull it off like FlipWitch, with moderately interesting enemies, good animations and bosses. Still, I'd personally put it in the A category, because the fact that it's generic and saggy still knocks.​
Night of Revenge | It's not a bad game either, but it's not S either, it's A. If you spend a few minutes with this game, you'll realise that apart from the incredible (no joke) CGI, animations and graphics, there's really nothing to it, and nothing at all. Combat is one-button, with no meaningful character development, and monsters and bosses, although there are plenty, can be easily killed with a single mouse click.​
Holy Knight Ricca | Another game, which can already claim to be S-tier, but is also closer to A. It's quite well made and apart from the dullest plot and unchanging but well realised gameplay, everything is fine with it. The only downside here is that, apart from the well realised potential, it doesn't offer anything radically new.​
Succubus Affection | Not a bad game that deserves B rather than S. Its problem is that despite the seeming variety of everything, that variety isn't there. You run around, grind mobs and sometimes fight bosses - that's it. Nothing memorable about mobs and bosses like in FOBS, even though it's the same author.​
My forest home | A completely generic action-platformer with cute graphics and a scale no higher than B, even though it's closer to C in general. It's small, cute and afraid to experiment beyond the trope it's riddled with, and it suffers for it. Like most games like this.​
Ghost Hunter Vena | Real old-school, which I wouldn't put on the list at all considering how old it is. This game, while bona fide, is extremely outdated in gameplay and graphics. It is EXTREMELY boring to play, and really, there's no reason to play it. It's worth leaving it out of what they like to call the chronicles of history, but not radiocarbon analysis.​
Magic Castle Repure Aria 2 | No comment. This was planted here, apparently by someone, because I have no idea why it's here or why it's here. It's not a game or a product, it's a phenomenon called "trash".​
Castle of Temptation | Like Drain Mansion, but worse and more, without looking beyond C. The problem here is that apart from the rather specious graphics and animations, the puzzles and gameplay itself is extremely boring and uninventive. You run from one point to another, sometimes meeting slightly different monsters and that's it.​
Max the Elf | I'm not going to comment on that. The author has apparently gone completely insane.​

And what do we have in the end? Out of 12 applicants, only 3 remain normal, and yes almost all normal should be in A, but not S. And this is the first top and S-tier, and what comes next I can't even talk about. Where are FOBS, Drain mansion, Eroico and a bunch of other great games? Oh yeah, because the author didn't bother to play these games, but only to watch them - they can't pick beyond B and C range.
Alright guys, I guess that's it. Next time you defend the honour of your dearly beloved master, remember to take out little Joe. I hear it helps.

Your mistake is not sending all Platformers into the trash.
Here is a secret, in this kind of tier lists you can pick and choose what you care about and make your own judgement on what opinions and criteria you listen to.
It's like Steam Reviews, just because it a negative review does not mean I care about the thing that reviewer cares.
And just because it's a positive review or recommendation does not mean it's something that is good to me.

 

[Otaku111]

No comment. This was planted here, apparently by someone, because I have no idea why it's here or why it's here. It's not a game or a product, it's a phenomenon called "trash".

Geez, judging by the way you are wording, you really like to hear your self talking, don't you?

Sad thing is, I generally sort of agree with what your saying, but not the way you're reasoning it.
Your saying it's a bad tier-list; that's what I think to, but the difference is I think it's bad, bcs it doesn't fit my preferences.. that's it, and guess what, thats ok. its subjective.

If someone likes trash games let him do his thing. The premise of this thread was to 'give a list of games the OP likes but exclude VN's and such that are no more then a gallery in enginge'
And said very clearly, if you disagree be does not care about your opinion.

If you think you can contribute a more suitable tier list, no one holds you back doing an other one. All you are doing right now, is like searching for a genre you don't like and complain about it.. sorry to be the one to bring it to you, but thats moronic behavior.

 

[triodon]

You must be registered to see the links

 

[triodon]

Scarlet Maiden Should be S Tier

If there was a Z category, he would be an S there.

 

[fucksmith]

The fact that this list is one person's subjective opinion is the exact reason it's good. I don't have to agree with the placements or OP's tastes for it to be useful information.

Thanks OP

 

[Girm Ork]

Hi. Would you mind checking my game? Cursed Pantsu is very gameplay-focused, it is a souls-like + 3d platformer game with a variety of mobs and traps. It has an 18+ DLC with 3d animations.

 

[Deleted member 5515203]

This thread is a goldmine. Actual gameplay that's fun on its own is rare in this scene.