Hallo
Vhaerun
I tested the game again and this time be more selective with my choices.
zger recommanded it. Thank you for that.
I want to give you my honest opinion. And I hope it comes not around as sinister or so.
Just My thoughts I dont demand or expect anything from you. Just my opinion when I play your game.
Could contain minor spoilers.
First love the art style. The ladies looking good. The assets too. The game runs smooth without loading times. We have here one of the best UIs for a sandbox game I ever have seen, If I would be able to skip a day in the kitchen. A dedicated skip button is missing. The rest works wonderful. All this is a good working ground for a game.
But it has problems and I have a few suggestions If you don't mind
Vhaerun.
As I understand you on discord you choose a sandbox game, so we can choose which one we want to hunt down. This Time I go full throttle for Sophie because BDSM is my kink and Alex's really annoys me.
Let's say my experience was a lot better than my first play through. And I mean
a lot. But at this point it gets convoluted.
Our choices matter but somehow don't. We have the illusion of choice until the game says "no". Most apparent in the Panty scene. No decision power for the player = not good feeling for the player.
As I said I tried to ignore Alex, but somehow I got a point for her (should not have breakfast with the family) and that triggered her scene with her searching my room. So I was railroaded again. Something I really tried not to do.
My conclusion is the sandbox in itself is not a good tool to give player power over their decisions. I suggest we could call her out and say just "No" to her.
Something like:
"Look Alex I am not here to be your new Daddy. I am only here to fight the loneliness of your Mother. You don't want her to be lonely, do you?"
Don't take that line Vhaerun it was a Joke. That would trigger her Histrionic personalty disorder and things get worse. (Did the writer work in the field of psychology?)
The BDSM exploration with Soph was excellent and really romantic. Loved it.
Jules was ok : stereotypical innocent, but deep down dirty girl. Like the rest of her family.
The hole Martin thing in the prologue in all honesty dose nott work. Martin in comparison to the women in this household is the most innocent person on this planet.
What I want to say things don't fit together, the introduction and the 180 in act one. It missis something.
Now to the Gameplay. I take two steps back and looked at it from a new perspectiv and have to say it isn't too much, but I remain by my opinion it is still boring to do.
The dead time is worse if you don't go full harem. Which is another argument against this sandbox style. It is frustrating to get the hint to meet Sophia on Wednesday evening, and it is Friday noon.
So yeah need an always anywhere skip button. I don't expect you to go VN, but a skip x amount of days button could help that.
The Money mechanics are ok. But there is a trap if you go shopping and don't have jobs to do. That's not good!!!
There was a tip here in the Forum that I should update my computer to generate more money while working.
I tested this for you and have to say maybe I miss something. But I highly recommend not to do this.
Because: Both updates together cost you 243$, and you generate round about 15$ per week more. That's 16 weeks before you got this Money back and generate a surplus. That's right of now not worth it.
The money grind is good, but the prices need some adjustment.
The Money grind is the only gameplay we have.
So I think that game has a good basis to start from. The gameplay could work. But it all needs to go more hand in hand. So
Vhaerun I hope you don't see my feedback as evil minded.
Today with this stand of the game I would give 3 out of 5. Four without the Panty thing.
One question do the decisions even matter or are they a no matter thing because I can grind the stats anyway?
That would be somehow awesome and somehow stupid.