I appreciate the list, but you should really put NTR in that first game. I was really looking forward to it, based off your rating.....but I couldn't get past that first scene. Total turn off for me as I would never allow that to happen to myself. Pretty disappointing tbh.
That's fair - Just keep in mind that the 5/5 BDSM-Rating just means that the game is exclusively about bdsm - which it is - it's just almost exclusively fdom/msub. It says nothing about the quality or the kind of content.
Which is why I redid all my reviews a while back to include a star-rating, which is my personal opinion of the game - here it is two stars for a game I disliked and would not recommend. That sadly led to unfair ratings due to my personal preferences (only into mdom or lezdom, not into abusive shit, really sick of incest), so I included the (***)-stars.
I add those if I think an alternative rating could be justified for people who like this specific game's content. For example - I fiucking hated Raptus - but people who are into dark shit would love it, so I give it a () rating that I think would apply for people interested in that content.
Here it was **(***) - five stars for people who are into fdom/msub content. Is that generous? - probably yes - I considered giving it only four stars, but decided not to because there is a lot of femdom content (which I mostly avoided and therefore can't rate fairly). So I was generous because the alternative was slogging my way through all the fdom content too, so I can justify a fair lower rating.
I'm doing this because I got the impression that we have at least some switches/fdom enjoyers among us - So I consider it polite to at least mention that the game might be good for people with those tastes.
I did consider splitting my BDSM-rating into a Quality (maybe steal blueberry's intensity rating system?) and a Quantity rating, but that would be so much work and make my rating system even more complicated. It mostly exists as a quick orientation if you skim my masterpost - if a game sounds interesting you are supposed to read the review itself where I mention details.
I assumed that most people who read my posts were familiar with my rating system - if confusion persists I might have to rework the system.
-----
Aside from that - I liked your quotes in the KG thread - it did confirm quite a few of my suspicions.
Edit: Aargh - this is why I mostly lurk - my posts keep balooning.
The sister looks kinda cute, I was hoping for lezdom with her since she has submission points, but it's not happening. It’s just a game about sadism, I’m not sure what to call it, but it can hardly be called BDSM, sick feminist fantasies.
Ah sorry - thought you referred to Villain's Legacy.
The Patriarch is in my "Games I have yet to play" list - I played parts of the first episode but not enough to write a review.
The Patriarch BDSM rating: 5/5
Star rating: ???
Just played the first episode and it seems pretty cool so far. Lots of domination, bondage, spanking, devices
So it has been some time again - I was (and will be) mostly busy replaying older games to update my lacking reviews, but I do have one new recommendation - as always I've updated my masterpost.
Games that I replayed and where I updated my reviews:
Camp Klondike BDSM-Rating: 5/5
Star-Rating: *****
Played Night six part two - Has both the spanking and the bdsm tag. It's also rated rather highly, but the unusual artstyle kept me from trying it. Finally had some time to try it and have to say - the ratings are completely deserved.
It's mostly a kinetic novel - the options only give an illusion of choice and only change how a sex-scene plays out or whether you want to see certain content (or how extreme you like your content). You can't influence the plotline at all.
The art style is unusual and while it looks weird at first glance, you get used to it rather quickly and in the end I found it quite charming - it also fits the stories style and themes pretty well.
The game is about a group of teenagers spending a week together in a summer-camp in the woods while exploring their sexuality and relationships. It deals with accepting yourself and others, dealing in a mature way with fetishes, consent and growing up. The story and the characters are rather well written and pretty memorable.
It also stays rather realistic and grounded - sweet, wholesome and the drama feels like something that could actually happen with a bunch of teenagers rather than drama for drama's sake. The sex-scenes are well written and have a beautiful build up with a lot of teasing and fantasizing. You feel like you're really in the characters' head.
Bdsm-wise several of the characters have an interest that they explore during the story - nothing too extreme, but it's nice watching young, enthusiastic people exploring their fetishes in a realistic manner with all the stumbling that implies.
Has bondage, spanking, domination, clamps, gags and some role-play.
Also has some sharing/swinging/voyeurism, there are also two other boys who have relationships of their own (one of which can have a sexual encounter with the MC's girlfriend) - the creator generally warns the player when it's about to happen and you can abort it, but if you're easily upset by such story-beats, you might be offended. I personally thought that it fit the story pretty well, because it's part of the theme of living true to yourself without being bound by others expectations or demands.
Definitely worth trying. It's also pretty close to its climax - night number six is almost finished with most plotlines resolved, and it's implied that the game will have seven days.
Played but not recommended:
Making Movies BDSM-Rating: 0/5
Star-Rating: ***
The (first?) game of Droid-productions, the creators who gave us Love of Magic. I played it out of curiosity because I loved some of their other games. Is a short, complete sandbox game with honey-select assets about a porno-producer. You seduce the main heroine into a life of vice and porn.
The sandbox elements mostly consist of you grinding up your skills to unlock scenes (it's pretty obvious the creators built on the sandbox-elements for Love of Magic - here they are lacking in comparison)
The game is pretty short - maybe 3-4 scenes with the main heroine and a handful one-offs with side girls. Game is extremely linear, your choices don't really matter.
Mostly a corruption game with some exhibitionism. There is one domina who has some bondage, whipping and humiliation content with a msub (not the MC). If your strenght is high enough you can counter dominate her - but the scene has only rough sex.
Doesn’t really have any real bdsm content – the “submissive assfuck” just has some dirty talk, and another scene has the MC give one of the girls some swats on her ass – not even any real spanking. (though to be fair the game has neither the bdsm nor the maledom tag)
It's a decent first game that actually got completed rather than abandoned but the creator’s later games are a lot better. If you are bored or curious you might give it a try but take it as it is and don't expect too much.
Decent enough (if you're into lezdom or real-porn-art):
Confidence Man BDSM-Rating: 4/5
Star-Rating: ****
Played v3.2 – html, mostly linear visual novel with a male mc. Uses real Porn art and gifs which takes some getting used to. The writing is pretty good, the characters are a bit one-note but interesting and memorable enough. The writing is aslo good enough that you get attached to the characters pretty quickly and want to see more of them.
You play a conn-man who pretends to be a sexual studies-teacher on an all-girls school. You either play as an asshole or an empathic nice guy, or a mix of both. Kind route has you seducing the girls, cruel uses blackmail, manipulation or force.
Story-Scenes split depending on your choices. The nice part is that you can switch between cruel and gentle routes and the characters react to it – you also sometimes get different scenes than if you just make cruel or just kind choices.
I personally would have preferred fewer characters with more focus on them. As it is each girls has two-three scenes at the most. Scenes were hot, even if they were mostly retellings of the gifs. Has mostly domination, some humiliation, some spanking, bondage (one scene only).
It’s pretty cool that you get to see different sides of the characters depending on your choices.
The main plotline seems to involve some mafia drama. The game’s pretty short – maybe an afternoon, or a day if you try to see all different scenes.
Sadly this is probably dead for good since it has not been updated in two years and the creator’s patreon page was deleted.
Say it again
BDSM-Rating: 4/5
Star-Rating: ****
Played v 1.0.0 - Short kinetic novel about two lesbians falling in love and experimenting. First off - the art is rather unusual, but you get used to it pretty quickly. (At first glance the characters look like bug-eyed aliens)
Second - there was music at the main menu, but during the story no music played - not sure whether that's a bug or intended.
BDSM-content consists of bondage, blindfold, rough sex, fisting, knife play, choking and domination.
There's some drama between the two characters but nothing annoying (the sub likes her sex a lot rougher than the dom, who doesn't like how much she enjoys her own cruelty). The game is pretty short, I finished it in two hours. Short, sweet and wholesome. The writing and the dialogue was pretty good, the scenes were hot. I personally hoped for more content, but I guess a game that actually gets finished is good too.
Not recommended (as a bdsm game):
Strange Nights
BDSM-Rating: 1/5
Star-Rating: ***
Played v. 0.7.1 - Abandoned for almost four years. Is a parody/porn-continuation of the Life is strange universe. You play the villain of the game who developed strange mental suggestion powers that might allow him to change the past. Excellent dialogue, great characters (that are mostly in-character for their original selves) and the scenes and animations are pretty good too. A shame this was abandoned.
Has the Bdsm and female domination tag - only has a single scene where the male mc is blackmailed and lightly dominated by a woman. You can turn the tables and fuck her senseless.
Nothing else. Pretty short too - I finished in an hour or two.
Games not on Andrash's list or recommended by the thread:
Recommended:
Consent
BDSM rating: 5/5
Star rating: *****
Played v0.3.3 – html, trainer game with a male mc and real-life porn. The mc decides that the only way to get the perfect wife is to abduct a woman and turn her into said wife through bdsm-training and CIA-brainwashing.
I personally am not a fan of trainer games since I had bad experiences with repetitive, grindy trainer games that lacked unique sex scenes and were pretty boring. I also was not a fan of real life porn games. Despite that I absolutely loved this game (it might even encourage me to look at other real-life-porn-games).
Don’t let the abandoned tag fool you – there are three complete routes created (brunette, redhead, blonde) – the reason this is abandoned is because the creator took a creative break and did not finish the other three planned routes (I am rather sad, that we did not get the promised asian route yet).
The creator chose varied and inventive bdsm-clips for each route and added pretty good narration and dialogue to it (you really feel like you are in the mc’s head) – there is bondage, whipping, humiliation, all kinds of pet training, breathplay, piercing, wooden horses, cages, maid play, and many rather extreme scenes,... – I have never seen such a diverse array of bdsm content in one game – depending on your choices you can be gentler or cruel and abusive – there are even different endings that take your methods into account, not all of them happy.
The writing is pretty good, the chosen girls pretty (and while the game uses different actors for one girl, it’s not annoying), the training inventive and plot might be simple but I still liked it. Also, there are a lot of different training scenes, so the game doesn’t fall into the trap of repeating the same training over and over to fill a bar.
My only complaint is, that some of the clips of the brunette route are of a lower resolution than those of the other routes.
I hope that the creator finds their creative spark and returns eventually, I’d love to see an asian route.
Meh Games:
Make Love not Waagh!
BDSM rating: 1/5
Star rating: ***(*)
Short complete kinetic novel – maybe 20-30 minutes long. I tried it for the bdsm tag and the high rating. It was okay – the art is pretty good (especially the non sex type), the writing is competent and the characters are sweet.
The dweeby mc gets mixed up with an orc-woman with a raceplay fetish and a submissive streak. Has three scenes (raceplay, handcuffs, spanking, choking, light domination).
What I disliked a lot was how fucking cliché the plot was – you feel like you’re in yet another hollywood interracial romance movie – boy meets girl, parents are surprisingly nice and welcoming, but what a surprise – a racist grandma shows up and mentioned her ex (who has a “proper” skin colour), big confrontation where the girl says that he makes her happy and that she doesn’t give a fuck about his skin colour, followed by a dramatic incident where boy proves himself to racist grandma, happy ending – seriously it’s the plot of every single one of those stories. I’d have preferred more originality.
Recommended if:
a.) you can stomach hollywood cliches
b.) you really love raceplay
c.) you want a short, sweet lovestory about a submissive orc-woman with a raceplay fetish
Bindr: Kink Dating
BDSM rating: 5/5
Star rating: ***
I played v0.9.1.0 – sandbox game with a male mc and about a dozen heroines. I played it because of the bdsm, male domination, spanking and humiliation tags. The game is about a man hooking up with various women over bdsm-tinder. Most women have both sub and dom scenes depending on the mc’s preferences. The framing device is fresh – you have sex first and then develop a relationship/start a woman’s storyline (so far the only girl who has hints of a storyline is Farah with her escaped serial killer).
I wanted to like this game so bad… Sadly despite the interesting premise and kinks, the decent writing style and the pretty women the game feels rather lifeless. Sex scenes feel rather similar to the point that it feels like you played 90% of all sex scenes after your first. Most of them have some light bondage, light domination, oral, vaginal and anal – Most of them are built after the same pattern, that repeats over and over. And while I generally don’t care about the quality of animations the constant identical hip thrusts in every single scene kinda annoyed me.
Maybe less would have been more – fewer scenes, that are more interesting and unique and fewer women with stronger storylines.
There’s also some spanking/whipping and it seems like the creator has a heels-fetish.
The game’s big gimmick (ai-voiced characters) kinda missed its mark with me because I’m not a fan of it, so I can’t comment on it, since I disabled that option.
If you’re into bdsm you might want to give it a shot and play one or two scenes – if they bore you, drop it – it’s just more of the same. If you love it you’ll probably like the rest of the game.
I personally found it just forgettable, despite it matching my fetishes and taste in women. (which is plain sad )
Games on Andrash's list:
Recommended (with reservation):
Rainy Day BDSM rating: 2/5
Star rating: ***(*)
Played v0.6.2 – abandoned, rather linear visual novel about a male mc getting shot and being recruited by demons to buy people’s souls. You can either play a nice guy or an asshole – asshole path has a lot of rough sex, domination, some spanking and some rape/blackmail. Sadly it has been abandoned for years. The creator started a second game in the same world after this game didn’t get the financial success they hoped for. They also abandoned that second game before it got far.
Writing is decent, plot interesting enough (sadly it got abandoned just as it started getting really interesting), girls are hot and scenes were written well. One of my complaints is that there are ten-ish sex-scenes (some have variations) and another five joke sex scenes featuring the creator avatar – seriously? A third of the game’s sex scenes are jokes? I would have preferred the creator invested that effort into the game itself.
If you don’t mind that it’ll never get continued it’s worth checking out.
Not recommended:
Due Process
BDSM rating: 2/5
Star rating: **
Played v 3.6.0 – abandoned trainer game where you’re part of a brainwashing study. Girls are hot, writing decent and the plot interesting enough. Considering its high rating and the bdsm and slave tags I had high expectations going in.
Sadly it seems like the “porn” part of the porn-game has been a halfhearted afterthought for the creator. You have a lovingly made trainer system where you fill different bars to lower the women’s modesty, resistance, etc and set up a schedule of different tasks to brainwash them, but there isn’t really any payoff – your first brainwashing victim has a really short sex scene, your second one has one scene with device bondage and toys or several men depending on your choices, but the handful of other scenes are just a single still image with the narration telling you, that you had sex.
Even the trainer system turns stale since there are only a handful of actions the women can take and there are no proper storyevents after you pass certain corruption benchmarks.
Slut Trainer BDSM rating: 2/5
Star rating: **(*)
I played v9.02 - highly linear visual novel with a female mc. Was made by the same creator as Red Sakura Mansion. Has been abandoned since 2020.
It’s mostly a corruption focused “wizard of oz”-parody. Dorothy lands in the magical lands of porn-oz and slowly gets corrupted into a slut.
The characters look okay, the english is flawed and full of errors (which I personally hate), the dialogue is stilted and sounds wrong and the mc is extremely naive and stupid. The game starts as an episodic journey meeting tin-man, scarecrow and the lion who are porn versions of themselves – here the game is rather whimsical and tries to be funny, there also are several clicking minigames that unlock sex-scenes flashbacks. The humor wasn’t to my tastes but someone else might like it.
After you get to the emerald city the games becomes a grindfest of training, sleeping, buying items and earning money. Each new training and job has one big erotic scene when you unlock it but the grind gets tedious pretty quickly.
Mostly corruption and prostitution, some male and female domination, some watersports, gangbangs, some device bondage, public use, some spanking and whipping. Also has one scene where the mc can grow a dick and have a m/f/f threesome. The best scenes are probably tin-man’s flashbacks where he gets cucked by a woman dominating his wife and turning her into her slave.
As far as bdsm is concerned I’d not play the game for it because scenes are not anything fantastic or memorable – at best they are okay. If you are really bored you might give it a try. If you liked Red Sakura Mansion you might also enjoy this – I personally dislike the bad english too much.
Witch Master BDSM rating: 1/5
Star rating: *
Played v0.1.9 – has been abandoned for years – mostly kinetic novel with no real choices that matter, also pretty short – maybe 20 minutes? There are also only two scenes – one masturbation scene with Fleur and one dream scene with Ginny as a maid sucking a fat master’s dick while Hermione watches.
It’s kinda crap, there are spelling and grammar mistakes and the dialogue is stilted. The plot is Draco Malfoy using a mind control artifact to manipulate the women around Potter to get his hands on the black inheritance. The story ends after using the artifact to give Hermione an erotic dream.
The mind control concept is interesting and the art isn't bad either but don’t bother with that one – what we have isn’t great and it likely won’t be continued either.
It's Complicated BDSM rating: 2/5
Star rating: **
Played the complete v1.0 – visual novel with a male MC and two heroines. Pretty short, maybe half an hour. If you are really bored you could play it, I guess?
The writing is readable but not great, the renders are okayish (old honey select) and it’s complete. The MC can either chase the blonde who has a crush on him or a redhead who’s being abused by her boyfriend
The blonde is vanilla only – the redhead has 2-3 bdsm scenes with her abusive boyfriend (domination, humiliation, pain, petplay, nipple torture, bondage, exhibitionism). After her boyfriend throws her away the mc can save her (one scene, submissive girlfriend with no selfworth) or turn her into his pet (one scene, light domination, humiliation). After that the game ends.
Project Domani BDSM rating: 1/5
Star rating: **
Played v1.0 – complete game, maybe 10-15 minutes long. Rather linear, you get choices, but they are cosmetic only or don’t change anything because you need to do all of them anyway.
The MC gets propositioned by his (virgin)childhood friend and they start experimenting together. The heroine has a submissive streak and is interested in a D/s relationship. The scenes go kiss-strip-grope-blowjob-sex and get longer as you repeat them (and the heroine gets less shy). There are essentially only those four scenes and you just unlock more of a scene as you play. There is only light domination (she calls the mc master) and that’s it.
This would probably be a great game if there actually was some content – as it is it kinda leaves you unsatisfied because it’s over before you know it. Still - I'd give a new game by the dev at least a look.
Dark breed BDSM rating: 1/5
Star rating: *
Played v0.1 – kinetic novel with futa vampires – complete garbage. The writing is error riddled, the grammar is shit, the renders are okayish, the writing is cliché and the scenes are pretty basic and boring. Has some domination of a woman by a futa-vampiress, some spanking and that’s it. Abandoned for good reason.
I also have a request for anyone willing to contribute:
As you saw, most games from Andrash's list that I reviewed this time were kinda meh - probably because I already picked all the low hanging fruits. So here is the list of games I haven't played yet - If you've played some of these games I'd appreciate it if you could post a short comment which ones are worth playing and which are not - I'd help me decide how to order my list and decide which to play first.
- this is why I mostly lurk - my posts keep balooning.
