You guys are going in circles. Almost all of the women in the story are attractive. Each person has a preference and that's okay. Someone like me knows, beautiful is beautiful. So you have to look at the bigger picture.
Emma is trouble, but thankfully has a conscience. They broke up for reasons. Usually, that means it just won't work. Sometimes you gotta let go. It's not like the MC is desperate.
Catherine is the boss? She's gorgeous and playful if i remember the first installment. Absolutely worth pursuing. The other girl at work (I'm bad with names) the brunette, she's pretty too.
Lisa is a great romantic option, obviously. It is a bad idea to date someone in your bad though, but it's worth it. I have a feeling Jade might come into the picture (optionally) with that couple. I could be wrong. Just guessing. The hint has been there that she might be on both sides of the fence. As for Penny, she's cute. Don't see that going anywhere in story.
Jane, she's a tough nut to crack, but she's cracking. She's awesome. One of my top choices no doubt. And of course Julia...yes, I guess I'm a scumbag. XD Also a top choice if possible. Once again, I doubt that's a direction that will be pursued.
Selina. She has a nice figure and lets face it, she gets the best cut scenes in story. Something about her face is off. I know that sounds shallow. Her mother is a bombshell though. Not a bad option here. To each their own.
Nicole. I like her a lot. I have a feeling something could happen with her. I hope so. She's special. (Something about a gorgeous woman that can pull off a short haircut and still look amazing). She's obviously a bit wild and that's not a bad thing.
Decisions, decisions...I've noticed with some stories it's a hard thing to make a commitment when you have a long period of time ahead with nothing but opportunities and you're sticking to your choice. I imagine it's hard to keep that fire burning bright. Someone mentioned it would be nice to have fun and at the end make a choice. That might be best. It will be interesting to see what happens.