i agree, both have their share of blame in this mess, Josy had a good number of opportunities to tell him she have a GF and not a BF, and also that her GF was in the same college as the MC, unlike Maya her family doesn't seem to be religious freaks so she was being selfish or she have some unknow reasons (maybe maya's father threatened her?), Maya already fucked things up with the initiation thing, she also made him promisse to always be honest to her while she is having trouble to do the same, but at least she have her reasons for that, the way i see it is that after being forgived and given a second chance if she had reveal the whole truth at that time, MC would be mad again and never given her a third chance, i am cutting her some slack because things ecalated too fast, but she is not blameless, i felt bad because i don't want the MC to be the reason for their breakup, these two girls have to solve their situation before dragging someone else into their mess, i dunno how things are gonna happen in their arcs but i think that this time they will have to run after him and this is the perfect excuse to get rid of them and go for the other girls in the other saves we have for the others