You spend an awful lot of time discussing a game and developer you despise with such passion, might I ask what the point of it is? I don't mind that you dislike it so much, it doesn't affect my enjoyment of BaDIK whatsoever but it does baffle me that you can't seem to let go of something you claim to like solely for its renders.
Seriously, I just want to know the name of the dev/VN that has raised the "writing" standards so high over here that this is always treated like shit.
It may not be the best but, is still better than most of the crap that we see in this genre. Imho the writing is impressive considering he is managing so many characters with some level of drama attached to everyone.
With so much going on, the writing will seem a bit off sometimes but as long as it's fun it shouldn't matter.
And looking at the no. of pages in this thread, it's safe to say that it's quite enjoyable for a lot of people. So as the game fulfills its primary objective, "good" writing is only secondary.