- Dec 13, 2018
- 7,748
- 19,526
Unfortunately, given where the game is at right now, even if DPC were compelled to make some adjustments that would make these decisions feel more intuitive to the MC's actions rather than the affinity/status checks, it's a lot of work to do to practically re-write huge portions of the game, so we're stuck with it, I'm afraid.One thing I'm not understanding about some of these comments is the averse reaction to the idea that MC will have to face consequences for certain decisions (sleeping around) with LIs... I'm not sure if the complaint is that there are consequences or if it's hard to know when actions will trigger consequences, however... both of those things seem somewhat realistic. In real life, sleeping around is like rolling the dice. Maybe you'll get away with it, maybe you won't. But if you expect no consequences, that's completely unrealistic. You really think MC can be a hoe on a college campus and word won't travel and reach the ears of the women you've been trying to romance or deduce what's going on?!
Somewhat related: I agree that some of the CHICK/DIK affinity/status checks/choices are kind of counter-intuitive, but I'm not really sure how DPC could fix that, especially this far in. It's definitely not lost on me that being a DIK is really only a successful path for one main LI (Sage) either, so there's a lack of balance there. The walkthroughs definitely help but if you're someone who doesn't like using walkthroughs, I could see how this game could get frustrating because some of the choices that cause you to LOSE RPs aren't necessarily what you'd expect (for example, when you first meet Jill, if you're a DIK, complimenting her causes you to lose a point or two with her).
The thing with this game is that it's not really about making everyone happy by allowing all the sex without consequence because there's plenty more drama in this game that doesn't exist in others to make it engaging and tease the possibility of consequences further down the line. The problem is that everything is happening too quickly and it feels like a lot of potential relationships aren't really being given much of a chance to get off the ground before you have to start cutting them off. There's also the fact that some of these affinity/status checks don't often seem to align with how your MC has generally been throughout the game and how they've interacted with certain characters.If he is a bad writer then what are others like? hahaha man I have played quite a few games here and there is none that has the emotional and humor level of this one as well as the personality of the protagonists. City of broken dreamers for example is up to the task, perhaps A mothers love or A wife and a mother also have a very good argument but the rest are very simple, all they do is make everyone happy by allowing you to have sex with all and hardly anything happens
Plausible is more the issue I have, like, is it plausible to be able to do everything with M&J yet get rejected for some DIK decisions they couldn't possibly know about? No. Is it plausible that a MC who's still with M&J and had a positive Swyper chat with Cathy is not allowed to choose whether to continue or not? No. Is it plausible that a Neutral or CHICK MC who has done everything bar the ep 4 scene in the HOT house with Quinn should be rejected by Quinn when offering to help her? No.What is this obssesion with 'real' in fiction. Plausible? Yes, Believable? Yes, but Real? I don't want a game that makes my back ache like a Real day at work or makes me worry about how I'm going to pay for something expensive and unexpected. And I especially don't want the pain of REAL relationships, or REAL suffering or REAL death's. See, I have a real life with all of those real things in it, I don't need an imaginary REAL life to entertain me, just a little amusement and escapism.
These are just some examples of things that, for me, don't seem plausible and yet the game is blocking us off from them because of stat checks rather than basing it on the MC's actions with those particular characters.