EmperorGus

Active Member
Oct 11, 2020
866
1,330
Why was Elena & JohnBoy fighting in Episode 7 again? Before JohnBoy came to HOT party and they made up
Don't think a specific reason was given.
But, tension between DIKs and HOTs would make sense.

Personally,
I'm still waiting for Sage to figure how the she should have the HOTS apologize to the DIKs for screwing up their Hell Week. Publicly, that is. Not just explaining it to MC, but taking responsibility for the fact that the HOTs did not fulfil their promise to be there and didn't even have the courtesy to warn them ahead of time. (Yes, I'm aware it was Quinn specifically, but the whole point of Greek Orders is that they act as a group. So it falls on all of them to apologize.)

Or at least for one of the DIKs to point it out to one of the HOTs next time one of the girls say they're waiting for the guys to 'come around'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LoDoN-

B-52reloaded

Well-Known Member
Aug 25, 2018
1,182
1,129
Story has many flaws. It makes it looks silly. For example, Jill promises not to meet Mc forever because of the threaten of Tybalt. What a stupid story! Maybe the writer has forgeten Jill is more powerful and rich than Tybalt. And Jill even make a date with him. It is ntr plot.
I have the perfect solution for you - stop playing the game and live happily ever after!
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,099
21,714
Don't think a specific reason was given.
But, tension between DIKs and HOTs would make sense.

Personally,
I'm still waiting for Sage to figure how the she should have the HOTS apologize to the DIKs for screwing up their Hell Week. Publicly, that is. Not just explaining it to MC, but taking responsibility for the fact that the HOTs did not fulfil their promise to be there and didn't even have the courtesy to warn them ahead of time. (Yes, I'm aware it was Quinn specifically, but the whole point of Greek Orders is that they act as a group. So it falls on all of them to apologize.)

Or at least for one of the DIKs to point it out to one of the HOTs next time one of the girls say they're waiting for the guys to 'come around'.
I think this is already out of date. Tommy, who is the only one who might object, knows that Quinn is to blame. John boy, Jacob and Mc didn't mind going to the HOTs party.

individually both Sage and, in her own way, Quinn apologized to MC.

it's all stopped just because the DIKs are still working on their mansion
 

EmperorGus

Active Member
Oct 11, 2020
866
1,330
I think this is already out of date. Tommy, who is the only one who might object, knows that Quinn is to blame. John boy, Jacob and Mc didn't mind going to the HOTs party.

individually both Sage and, in her own way, Quinn apologized to MC.

it's all stopped just because the DIKs are still working on their mansion
Just because they still went to the party doesn't mean that they're not owed an apology.
It's just a matter of principal.
The HOTs (as a group) screwed the DIKs (as a group) and haven't said anything about it outside of the private explanation Sage gave MC.

And what brought it to my mind again was (atm I forget which girl) commented at the party if the DIKs were 'finally coming around'. As if they had zero right to be annoyed.
It was the other moment at the party I really wanted a chat option for the MC to retort.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,099
21,714
Just because they still went to the party doesn't mean that they're not owed an apology.
It's just a matter of principal.
The HOTs (as a group) screwed the DIKs (as a group) and haven't said anything about it outside of the private explanation Sage gave MC.

And what brought it to my mind again was (atm I forget which girl) commented at the party if the DIKs were 'finally coming around'. As if they had zero right to be annoyed.
It was the other moment at the party I really wanted a chat option for the MC to retort.
if they were on bad terms they wouldn't have gone, you don't go to the party of someone you think has wronged you.

in my opinion just as a group it's all behind them, the DIKs know it was Quinn who should have warned them and didn't, it's also possible that Sage talked to Rusty about it directly.
even Tommy and Quinn in their own way have cleared the air....

I don't think there will be this official apology moment.
 

Tadpol

Member
Mar 22, 2021
359
535
The loan tickles my suspension of disbelief, just a bit. But it's not even close to breaking it.
I take it for what it is. A story element meant to highlight A) that her father is a monster and B) Maya is in a pretty damn stressful situation.
It's exactly that.

It comes down to the detail, the important thing is the consequence. To accept fiction, you have to be able to accept that certain small details are not consistent with our world.

In addition to the sentence that Maya comes out after, it is typically the means that an author uses to tell us that.

Or even simpler, in the fictional world of the work, it is quite possible.

I hope you can get past that sort of thing, otherwise works of fiction should not be your cup of tea.
 

crabsinthekitchen

Well-Known Member
Apr 28, 2020
1,549
8,734
Just because they still went to the party doesn't mean that they're not owed an apology.
It's just a matter of principal.
The HOTs (as a group) screwed the DIKs (as a group) and haven't said anything about it outside of the private explanation Sage gave MC.

And what brought it to my mind again was (atm I forget which girl) commented at the party if the DIKs were 'finally coming around'. As if they had zero right to be annoyed.
It was the other moment at the party I really wanted a chat option for the MC to retort.
Right now, the only reason HOTs and DIKs don't party together is because Tommy is mad at Quinn and both of them are too stubborn to work it out. Everyone else knows why HOTs did it (at least the official version) and that Quinn was supposed to tell them about the change of plans. So the best way to patch things up would be to throw a party together to show that things are back to normal, but with two VPs not talking to each other and DIKs being busy with repairing the mansion it's kinda hard

Also I don't see why MC, out of all people, would be annoyed, prep party had its fun moments
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,099
21,714
It's exactly that.

It comes down to the detail, the important thing is the consequence. To accept fiction, you have to be able to accept that certain small details are not consistent with our world.

In addition to the sentence that Maya comes out after, it is typically the means that an author uses to tell us that.

Or even simpler, in the fictional world of the work, it is quite possible.

I hope you can get past that sort of thing, otherwise works of fiction should not be your cup of tea.
I fully agree with you.
DPC's mistake though was to overexpose the issue, Maya talked about it in practically every chapter, and instead of clarifying the situation she made it less and less credible.
the loan has a narrative function, perfect, no problem, there's no need to talk about it every chapter.
 

Canto Forte

Post Pro
Jul 10, 2017
21,122
25,847
MC needs to maneuver around them jocks having nothing to talk about but what
worm brothers also talk about ... binge beer drinking, of all things party related .. Ughhhhh!
Right now, the only reason HOTs and DIKs don't party together is because Tommy is mad at Quinn and both of them are too stubborn to work it out. Everyone else knows why HOTs did it (at least the official version) and that Quinn was supposed to tell them about the change of plans. So the best way to patch things up would be to throw a party together to show that things are back to normal, but with two VPs not talking to each other and DIKs being busy with repairing the mansion it's kinda hard

Also I don't see why MC, out of all people, would be annoyed, prep party had its fun moments
MC is annoyed, raging just because he cannot take them alfies one by one out back
and kick their teeth in. Alas, he is not alone and would enlist them hots to outsmart
all those beer heads plastered all over his routes into the babes hots
 

Hermith

Member
Feb 13, 2018
330
703
Right now, the only reason HOTs and DIKs don't party together is because Tommy is mad at Quinn and both of them are too stubborn to work it out. Everyone else knows why HOTs did it (at least the official version) and that Quinn was supposed to tell them about the change of plans. So the best way to patch things up would be to throw a party together to show that things are back to normal, but with two VPs not talking to each other and DIKs being busy with repairing the mansion it's kinda hard

Also I don't see why MC, out of all people, would be annoyed, prep party had its fun moments
We will probably get that with the Halloween party. Even if the mc isn't pursuing Sage she asks him to work together and plan the best party ever. Damn, ep8 can't come soon enough.
 

Niu6609

Member
Apr 28, 2021
201
420
Right now, the only reason HOTs and DIKs don't party together is because Tommy is mad at Quinn and both of them are too stubborn to work it out. Everyone else knows why HOTs did it (at least the official version) and that Quinn was supposed to tell them about the change of plans. So the best way to patch things up would be to throw a party together to show that things are back to normal, but with two VPs not talking to each other and DIKs being busy with repairing the mansion it's kinda hard

Also I don't see why MC, out of all people, would be annoyed, prep party had its fun moments
MC was probably annoyed because he's snuck in to the preps' mansion a number of times, practically making him feel like a criminal at this point :KEK: He might've been able to have more fun moments had the HOTs come to the DIKs' party instead, and all without having to give a shit about wearing a suit, fitting in, and most importantly, Tyballs.

I'm hoping the Halloween party will be a moment of reconciliation for the DIKs and the HOTs, accompanied by closure for Sage so we can finally, fucking, finally, start dating. I'm also hoping that Episode 8 won't leave us at the start of the Halloween party by the end of the episode, because that'd fucking suck.

I fully agree with you.
DPC's mistake though was to overexpose the issue, Maya talked about it in practically every chapter, and instead of clarifying the situation she made it less and less credible.
the loan has a narrative function, perfect, no problem, there's no need to talk about it every chapter.
It's like when you write a descriptive essay in an exam, and it starts out perfectly fine, incredibly thrilling even. But halfway through you realize that your writing is repetitive and starting to go off-topic, but you can't stop writing it because there's like half an hour left before the exam is over and it's too late for you to rewrite everything because you wouldn't be able to finish before the end of the exam, so you just push through it and what comes out is a confusing piece of work that started out strong and became somewhat of a mess halfway through.

I'm really hoping Maya's "daddy issues" can be resolved soon so we can get other forms of character development from her. From how Episode 7 ended, I theorize that Maya may have told Sage about her debt problem, and, since we know Sage is from a wealthy background from a previous episode, she might suck it up and ask her family to help with Maya's problem. After all, at the end of Episode 7, Sage did say something along the lines of "It's hard but it might work.... Just don't expect too much so that I don't feel like shit if I fail." I'm thinking that Sage's relationship with her family isn't the best, so that's the main reason for that. Again, just a theory, so no need to start pointing fingers if you disagree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DavDR

DavDR

Well-Known Member
Oct 14, 2020
1,983
3,248
You’re acting like they’re objective plot holes when they’re not.

Your argument works both ways, people should stop defending it without any thought and you need to stop picking at plot points and acting like they’re objectively bad.

Maybe the “distance” wasn’t necessarily one of actual physical separation but Maya/Josy doing exactly what they’re doing this episode again. They’re metres from one another at the moment and not speaking or seeing each other. They went “long distance” and shit broke down because Maya’s response to stress is to turtle up in the dark and not put any effort into the relationship and Josy just leaves her to it.

It’s established in the plot that’s how they react. Just because it isn’t explicitly stated it doesn’t make it a “pathetic quibble” designed to “quash” any grandiloquent criticism of the game.

Story has flaws. Not even close to perfect (if that even exists in literature). But you’re just the other side of the same coin as the people you’re calling cringey.
Read the reply's above yours.

One person says I'm unreasonable because I insist that there are flaws in the game.

You admit that there are flaws in the game but insist that I "need to stop picking at plot points and acting like they’re objectively bad." ?!? So there are flaws but just not bad flaws and I have to stop pointing them out?

Another admits that the plot stinks but hey it's only a porn game so let's go back to talking about sex.

Suspension of disbelief in fiction is not infinite! Just because an author says that a thing is a thing is not a universal truth that every audience member must accept, there is a standard of plausibility, and this game has long since raced past that standard.

As I have said repeatedly now if you enjoy the game that's fine, enjoy it. But it's not going to stop me from criticizing this game. If you can't handle that someone is criticizing your precious game then just ignore me. If you can't do that then that's your problem, not mine.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: diegao

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,003
2,859
Oh that's rich. This whole argument is about Shazba's unwillingness to admit that there are any plot flaws in the game at all and you jump in crying about this crap? HA
Seems to me it's kinda pointless finding plotholes in a FICTION work based on minor facts like in laws and student loans....
We all know student loans excist, we all know laws exists, we all know schools have policy's....
There really isn't much reason to evaluate each and every one of them to the level of absolute correctness...

There's fiction out there with flying cars, mind control, vampires, goblins, laser weapons, time travel, and literally a ton more impossible things happening....

This does not mean we can not talk about any plotholes... it's completely credible to point out any part of the story that conflicts or just isn't logical but it's useless to go into minor facts to a 100% realism level.

Everybody is entitled to form his or her own opinion and we are all allowed to think the story is credible or not, based on what we are told in the story.... If the large majority of players think the story is credible we can assume the dev did well enough...
If we disagree we still are allowed to have the opinion it lacks realism based on personal view...

In my personal opinion i have not found any plotholes of concern.... there are alot loose ends, but the story isn't finished yet...
 

Hermith

Member
Feb 13, 2018
330
703
Read the reply's above yours.

One person says I'm unreasonable because I insist that there are flaws in the game.

You admit that there are flaws in the game but insist that I "need to stop picking at plot points and acting like they’re objectively bad." ?!? So there are flaws but just not bad flaws and I have to stop pointing them out?

Another admits that the plot stinks but hey it's only a porn game so let's go back to talking about sex.

Suspension of disbelief in fiction is not infinite! Just because an author says that a thing is a thing is not a universal truth that every audience member must accept, there is a standard of plausibility, and this game has long since raced past that standard.

As I have said repeatedly now if you enjoy the game that's fine, enjoy it. But it's not going to stop me from criticizing this game. If you can't handle that someone is criticizing your precious game then just ignore me. If you can't do that then that's your problem, not mine.
It's absolutely fine if you criticize the game, but I think you are going beyond that. The game has flaws and parts I don't like, but none of them are game breaking, for me at least, so I prefer to focus on the parts I actually liked. I mean that's the reason I'm sticking around. You on the other hand seem to enjoy rubbing people's noses in the parts you don't like. It feels like you want them to admit the thing they enjoyed is actually a pile of shit.

I think BaDik is one of the best games I found thanks to this site. Sure it has flaws, technical and logical errors, but all in all it also has fun characters, a fine story and probably the best atmosphere.
 
Last edited:

DavDR

Well-Known Member
Oct 14, 2020
1,983
3,248
It's exactly that.

It comes down to the detail, the important thing is the consequence. To accept fiction, you have to be able to accept that certain small details are not consistent with our world.

In addition to the sentence that Maya comes out after, it is typically the means that an author uses to tell us that.

Or even simpler, in the fictional world of the work, it is quite possible.

I hope you can get past that sort of thing, otherwise works of fiction should not be your cup of tea.
No, you've just outlined the difference between good fiction and bad fiction. Suspension of disbelief isn't a universal cure, the ultimate trump card that cancels all objections. It has limits.
 

LoDoN-

Member
Sep 3, 2017
228
438
Is it when Josy is in your room after finding Maya’s father in their room?

unless it was patched out it isn’t broken it’s DPC putting some bullshit into the game to crash it if you’re using a save file that used cheats/walkthrough mod. There’s a workaround listed somewhere.
Wat. I played the game with the Mod, and never had that. The game was a little weird in the beginning with the arrows disappearing, but a little patience, and the latter chapters ran smoothly.
 

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,003
2,859
Wat. I played the game with the Mod, and never had that. The game was a little weird in the beginning with the arrows disappearing, but a little patience, and the latter chapters ran smoothly.
Yeah, the full version works okay with the mod, think it's the compressed version that crashes on several points ingame...
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: LoDoN-
4.80 star(s) 1,526 Votes