Boehser Onkel

Forum Fanatic
Modder
Feb 20, 2021
4,088
6,045
Oh my! Why does Tommy 'need' the MC's guitar? And if he isn't going to give it to Sage, then how the hell did she get it? Did she mug him?

Troy is not under any real protection from Chad. Chad just tries to distract the other Alphas from giving Troy abuse while he's there. But, for Chad to really put Troy under his protection would raise too much suspicion. One doesn't have to venture too far into the realm of wild theories, to suggest that Dawe got a few other jocks together (behind Chad's back) to pound on Troy. The guitar found its way back to the Alphas' house where Chad found it and gave it to Sage.

Simple and uncomplicated.

EDIT: Dawe's motive is that Troy beat him up. He's out for revenge.
sound more plausible than dalli´s story ;)
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,091
21,705
Troy isn't under Chads protection, Chad even tries to keep their relation a secret from the other Jocks. The only time he can protect Troy from the Jocks is when he's there.

Troy literally said some Jocks took the guitar, if Tommy took it why hasn't Chad jumped him in the dark while he does jump MC in the dark? The guitar was stolen before the blackmail was delivered.

Dawe was hit by Troy and Troy got kicked from the Jocks, but Dawe didn't get to hit him, Chad was there...
So Dawe visited Troy and brought a few more Jocks, it's that easy. Dawe had a motive...

Why should Tommy have a motive to beat up Troy when he was hit by Dawe? That's not common sense...
Sure IF Tommy knew he could have blackmailed Troy, but for a guitar he was gonna give away? Why? To reassure Sage's relation with Chad with the hope they breakup? That's like giving people money hoping they go broke...
but if you exclude all these well-founded objections, at the end it is a theory that holds up :unsure: :unsure:
 

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,003
2,858
but if you exclude all these well-founded objections, at the end it is a theory that holds up
Correct me if i'm wrong :

MC's first contact with any Jocks was when he said goodbye to his father before the school, Dawe and Anthony saw him and his guitar and Dawe called him "gay"...
MC's next Jock was Chad arguing with Sage...
After that MC got bullied by 4 Jocks, he made fun of them and got a wedgie...
Now why would Dawe come up with the idea to take the guitar when he beat up Troy? Any guesses?

Now what is the reason Tommy took the guitar IF that theory is what you're going with? It's totally random Tommy would take the guitar to reassure Sage. He wants them to break up, that's just contradictive goals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Walter Victor

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,003
2,858
Quinn and Tommy want Sage and Chad to break up.
Yeah, they want to party at the Dik's so they can blow, that's much is logical. But if you want them to break up the last thing you want to do is reassure Sage in her relation with Chad. So come with another theory how the guitar came to Chad.
This part of the theory just doesn't hold, sorry.
 

varage

Active Member
Jun 26, 2019
800
614
Oh my! Why does Tommy 'need' the MC's guitar? And if he isn't going to give it to Sage, then how the hell did she get it? Did she mug him?

Troy is not under any real protection from Chad. Chad just tries to distract the other Alphas from giving Troy abuse while he's there. But, for Chad to really put Troy under his protection would raise too much suspicion. One doesn't have to venture too far into the realm of wild theories, to suggest that Dawe got a few other jocks together (behind Chad's back) to pound on Troy. The guitar found its way back to the Alphas' house where Chad found it and gave it to Sage.

Simple and uncomplicated.

EDIT: Dawe's motive is that Troy beat him up. He's out for revenge.
Or dawes motive is her a shrimp dicked bully out to beat on someone weaker then him?(just throwing it out there bullies don't need a motive they just are who they are."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Walter Victor

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,003
2,858
Sage shows interest in the MC. Everything is arranged so that the MC has to pick up his clothes and cell phone. Who tells the MC that he needs to talk to Sage? Oops, Quinn. Who made the MC take off his clothes and leave his clothes and cell phone at HOT's? Oops, Quinn. Who told the Quinn via cell phone that the MC was on his way to steal the underpants? Oops, Tommy. Who didn't leave the MC at the DIK mansion? Oops, Tommy. Who told the MC that Troy was a former jock? Oops, from the DIKs.

Just because Sage has shown interest in the MC, everything is being done to bring Sage and the MC closer together so Sage will turn her back on Chad. That would get Quinn and Tommy the party at the DIK mansion.

It was never about reassuring Sage. It was about Sage and the MC getting closer.
Everything except Sage being interested goes for Derek too. Except ofcourse the theory Tommy and Quinn had a masterplan to let Sage fall in love with MC, but that's only working because Chad happens to be gay and involved in a secret relation with Troy.

You can't plan a thing like that, there's just too many unknown factors to even be hopeful on a succesfull execution of the plan.
There's nothing in the plan to push Chad away, it happens but it's totally unrelated. There's nothing in the plan that would push the MC towards Sage at all, it's just his own decisions that decides to go there or not. And there's nothing in the plan that would make Sage drop Chad and pursue MC.... Surely Tommy and Quinn realise it's better to make plans when not stoned...

It's a plan that's nothing but speculation as a theory. You can't make people fall in love with each other if you don't involve Cupid in your plans, it's really that simple.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,091
21,705
Correct me if i'm wrong :

MC's first contact with any Jocks was when he said goodbye to his father before the school, Dawe and Anthony saw him and his guitar and Dawe called him "gay"...
MC's next Jock was Chad arguing with Sage...
After that MC got bullied by 4 Jocks, he made fun of them and got a wedgie...
Now why would Dawe come up with the idea to take the guitar when he beat up Troy? Any guesses?

Now what is the reason Tommy took the guitar IF that theory is what you're going with? It's totally random Tommy would take the guitar to reassure Sage. He wants them to break up, that's just contradictive goals.
But Tommy is young, still under the influence of Josy's nail polish fumes....

all the facts say otherwise, and what if all the facts are nothing more than red herrings to keep us from suspecting something that normally wouldn't make sense?

in the end if you exclude the impossible... how boring!!!

and anyway Tommy is a Burg

non ascoltate.gif
 
  • Haha
Reactions: vogelbeest

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,389
7,648
Everything except Sage being interested goes for Derek too. Except ofcourse the theory Tommy and Quinn had a masterplan to let Sage fall in love with MC, but that's only working because Chad happens to be gay and involved in a secret relation with Troy.

You can't plan a thing like that, there's just too many unknown factors to even be hopeful on a succesfull execution of the plan.
There's nothing in the plan to push Chad away, it happens but it's totally unrelated. There's nothing in the plan that would push the MC towards Sage at all, it's just his own decisions that decides to go there or not. And there's nothing in the plan that would make Sage drop Chad and pursue MC.... Surely Tommy and Quinn realise it's better to make plans when not stoned...

It's a plan that's nothing but speculation as a theory. You can't make people fall in love with each other if you don't involve Cupid in your plans, it's really that simple.
Do you have to have everything chewed out for you?

The panties in Chad's gym bag were at the college before the MC arrived. Ergo, the MC is an extension of the plan. But there's no point in debating it with you because you don't want to understand it anyway. This is a review!

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: affque

vogelbeest

Engaged Member
Jan 9, 2021
2,003
2,858
Do you have to have everything chewed out for you?

The panties in Chad's gym bag were at the college before the MC arrived. Ergo, the MC is an extension of the plan. But there's no point in debating it with you because you don't want to understand it anyway. This is a review!
Dalli, you're a great guy, but why ask me if i have everything chewed out for me? you're chewing everything out for the MC.
What is the relation between Chad panties and MC? It's not MC's panties, maybe they're Troy's, maybe they're from a girl.
We don't know.... Only thing we know is they're not MC's.... We don't know where they've been and for how long, we only know MC was already in college when he saw Chad with the panties.... We know Sage made him spy on Chad.... So if the panties were part of a plan how did they get there? Who put random panties in Chad's stuff and why did Chad even pick up weird panties? He knows who they belong to.... He's calling her/him/it.... So whoever he calls must be in on the plan so by your theory that leaves either Tommy or Quinn.... Sorry, not buying it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ename144

jak1165

Active Member
Mar 10, 2018
925
1,164
Everything except Sage being interested goes for Derek too. Except ofcourse the theory Tommy and Quinn had a masterplan to let Sage fall in love with MC, but that's only working because Chad happens to be gay and involved in a secret relation with Troy.

You can't plan a thing like that, there's just too many unknown factors to even be hopeful on a succesfull execution of the plan.
There's nothing in the plan to push Chad away, it happens but it's totally unrelated. There's nothing in the plan that would push the MC towards Sage at all, it's just his own decisions that decides to go there or not. And there's nothing in the plan that would make Sage drop Chad and pursue MC.... Surely Tommy and Quinn realise it's better to make plans when not stoned...

It's a plan that's nothing but speculation as a theory. You can't make people fall in love with each other if you don't involve Cupid in your plans, it's really that simple.
Doesn't explain why Quinn would go behind Tommy's back, either

It happens for plot reasons, nothing more
 
  • Like
Reactions: vogelbeest

Skeltom

Engaged Member
Oct 9, 2017
2,351
2,778
I don't think I follow. The panties that Sage found were in the bag on campus yes, but it was because Chad bought them willingly. We know now that they were for Troy who he was likely on the phone with when the MC got the proof for Sage. They are there because of Chad so unless he is a part of the plan to break up with Sage that doesn't fit at all.

Tommy and Quinn are only saying that the only real connection is their relationship, not that the only way to start parting together is to somehow break them up. It's not like their relationship is the end all be all for that to happen. Even after they break up Sage still wants the tri-alphas to be at least involved with them because of traditions. She talks about it at the party planning. Them breaking up doesn't mean they are done with the tri-alphas and can only party with the DIKs.
 
Last edited:

sorco2003

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2020
1,660
12,344
Exactly sorco2003 give my facepalm and ignore the evidence written in the game.:rolleyes:
I never ignore anything given by the game, in this "theory" of yours, it is you who ignores everything that happens, in pursuit of your so desired theory, and not content with that, you affirm as a truth illuminated only by the maximum creator, that what you say is the revealed truth, the only truth and how everything happened in history. Sorry for not following your evangelized truth dalli_x
 
4.80 star(s) 1,526 Votes