- Sep 20, 2018
- 3,454
- 14,245
It's pure speculation on my part; none of the other theories we've tried to really fit the facts of the Cathy-cluck caper, so why not assume it was a previously unknown third party? It's true we don't know if the three of them really are a group (all three are at Becky's dorm party, but they're not together), but the episode title and teaser image at least imply it. So definitely take this with a grain of salt.Hmm, why do you think that they're the group behind the Cathy-cluck? Is it because it just kind of fits with DPC's style of narrative/melodrama or was there some clue or foreshadowing that may have hinted at it?
From my perspective, I don't really see any sense of cohesion(?) among the group. Other than I think they were all at the dorm party. I could be wrong. The middle and right faces just look the same to me so I can't even remember whether we've already seen them. At the very least, I don't think we've been shown any interactions with "Carolyn" and the other two.
I think I can kind of see how they'd be a group based off the last image but I guess I just didn't interpret it that way. Instead of a singular group of women that want to stir up trouble and will run counter to the MC's best interests, I just saw them as three (maybe loosely) connected women that serve as potential temptations for the MC, both symbolically and literally as options in the game. I thought of it like that because of the reintroduction of Zoey into the story fits better with a general theme of temptation. Otherwise with Zoey, it'd feel like two main conflicts running at the same time with some redundancy.
Though honestly, your theory sounds more interesting. I mean, if we're going to have deal with that and basically start from step 1 again with the relationships then might as well make the ride down more fun.
I just wanted to more or less get your two cents on the thought process behind that conclusion.
That said, I do think it would give the vixens a much needed role in the story. It's all well and good for them to tempt the MC with their feminine wiles, but the game is already awash in side-girls. If DPC is going to introduce three new characters and at least partially name an episode after them, they need some sort of plotline to keep them relevant. Making them discount-nihilists who want to bring down the school's fraternities/sorority is hardly an epic backstory, but it would fit the game well enough. And it would make them distinct from the HOTs (who obviously like the greek system), the Pink Rose girls (who don't care about campus politics), or Zoey (who is likely to be focused solely on the MC).
Just something to ponder as we count down the last few days. If I turn out to be right I'll totally brag about it, otherwise I'll palm it off as me going crazy from the long wait.
There's no question Chad was in the wrong, but I think it's worth remembering that we don't know exactly how long Che has been formally dating Sage. We know they weren't yet dating in the Episode 5 flashback (about 2 years before the start of the game). If you tell Sage the truth, her dialog suggests it took a while before Chad agreed to be her boyfriend:Honestly, fuck Chad! Gay or not, you have to be one heck of a despicable person to do what he did. He spent years lying, deceiving, and manipulating another human because he's too big of a pussy. Not only that, he bullies and assaults MC. You can't just do what he did and not face any consequences. I hope he gets what he deserves and more!!!!
My guess is that they were only dating for a short time, maybe half a year or so - including the summer vacation when they conveniently didn't see each other very often. My further guess is that this is tied in with Troy; he got kicked out of the Alphas when they learned he was gay, and Chad figured he needed a beard to bolster his totes-no-homo bona fides. So he reversed course and said yes the next time Sage asked him, but said they needed to take things slow.
Again, still a very hurtful thing to do to poor Sage, but not quite the coldly manipulative situation it first appears to be. If we're *very* lucky, maybe we'll find out next week.
My take is that Sage wasn't trying to cheat for revenge, she was trying to make Chad jealous (and maybe burn off a little pent-up horniness as well). Her end goal was clearly to remain with Chad, otherwise his dumping her wouldn't have stung nearly as much.Meh, cheating is still fucked up regardless, if she was so certain Chad was cheating and that their relationship was done for, she should've ended it. Then she could fuck all the dudes she wanted, but instead, by trying to play games and cheat on him for revenge, she stoop down to his level and became what she hated so much in the first place.
It's yet another unexplored mystery, but IMHO there's a relatively simple explanation: Dawe and some of the other alphas went to beat up Troy, then stole the guitar (which they thought was Troy's) for Chad since they knew Sage wanted one.That reminds me, what was that whole thing about Troy and the dorm room getting all fucked up? Was it ever explained or are just left to make assumptions?
My money's on Troy and Chad had a fight and he took the guitar. Otherwise, I don't really know how Chad had it in the first place. It's not like he was going to join the other jocks to randomly fuck up the guy's dorm room because they hate him so it can't be that. At first I thought Troy was involved in some sketchy shit and the other party took the guitar as collateral (that was before finding out about Chad).
If my previous theory is correct, Troy would have been kicked out of the alpha's near the end of the previous school year. Dawe, being Dawe, probably wanted to make it clear that Troy wasn't welcome on campus just because he was still a student in good stead. So he rounded up a posse and went to beat up Troy - either without tell Chad or ignoring Chad's 'suggestion' that they leave it alone.
You are correct. If the MC rejects Sage she'll say she wanted to cheat even if she didn't pull it off:I can’t recall perfectly but doesn’t Sage say something to the effect of she didn’t cheat but she definitely thought about it, or wanted to cheat if you turn her down?
If you have slept with her she is blunt and says she cheated, if you don’t she says she functionally cheated.
Interestingly, she'll definitively say she cheated if the MC only sleeps with her in Episode 7, which shouldn't really be cheating. Either DPC wanted to simplify the branching to avoid a very minor edge case, or Sage was still holding out hope for Chad until the MC finally let Chad's secret out of the bad.
Yeah, it's been done; it technically counts as an "Others" run. There's not much remarkable about it at this time. It will be interesting to see if it changes anything with Zoey when she finally reencounters him.Has anybody completed a celibate playthrough? I'm tempted to try one before Season 3 to kind of see what would happen with Zoey.