Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,435
11,678
Josy/Maya cheat.
Sage cheats.
Bella thinks she is cheating.

The only LI's that are free from issues with infidelity are Jill and Quinn, our paragons of virtue.
Josy and Maya really only cheated on each other not MC they did lie, Sage says she cheated even if MC doesn't fuck her, can Bella really cheat?
 

Jimayo

Well-Known Member
Jan 1, 2018
1,544
1,809
Does she date Tybalt? Yes, even if she doesn't want to she explicitly agrees to go on three dates with him. Within the timeframe of the dates she makes out with Fuckface. Making out with someone while dating someone else is commonly considered to be cheating. Especially as she promised Tybalt that she wouldn't see Fuckface while she was dating him.

If Sage is to be condemned for cheating on Chad then there's no reason not to condemn the goblin.
Are you people fucking insane? Being blackmailed into 3 dates does not a committed relationship make.
 
Last edited:

Jimayo

Well-Known Member
Jan 1, 2018
1,544
1,809
Josy and Maya really only cheated on each other not MC they did lie, Sage says she cheated even if MC doesn't fuck her, can Bella really cheat?
Assuming he's be gone for more than a year legally they are separated(and that's assuming he's not dead) so it wouldn't be cheating either.
 

allanl9020142

Well-Known Member
Aug 23, 2018
1,256
1,984
Ehh, fuck this noise. Blackmailing someone into revealing their secret (which is what "i know what you are and you should tell it to someone you were deliberately using for years to hide it" effectively boils down to) isn't really any different from revealing it to person you want to know it yourself. It's just a flimsy excuse to pretend one is being morally better than they actually are. Ohh i didn't reveal his secret, he did. As if he's done it without the interference.

And to be perfectly honest, it's not like MC owns Chad anything, keeping his secrets included. Especially after getting robbed and assaulted without as much as "i'm sorry" afterwards.
That reminds me, what was that whole thing about Troy and the dorm room getting all fucked up? Was it ever explained or are just left to make assumptions?
My money's on Troy and Chad had a fight and he took the guitar. Otherwise, I don't really know how Chad had it in the first place. It's not like he was going to join the other jocks to randomly fuck up the guy's dorm room because they hate him so it can't be that. At first I thought Troy was involved in some sketchy shit and the other party took the guitar as collateral (that was before finding out about Chad).
 

mindern

Active Member
Jul 7, 2017
542
2,224
Josy and Maya really only cheated on each other not MC they did lie, Sage says she cheated even if MC doesn't fuck her, can Bella really cheat?
I can’t recall perfectly but doesn’t Sage say something to the effect of she didn’t cheat but she definitely thought about it, or wanted to cheat if you turn her down?

If you have slept with her she is blunt and says she cheated, if you don’t she says she functionally cheated.
 

BeingADikDik

Engaged Member
Apr 17, 2021
2,201
6,329
In which fucked up society is it cheating if a man or woman dates another human while being forced to meet someone dued to blackmailing? Tybalt might be thinking he has three dates but all he gets are meetings. Nothing more.
#TybaltDidNothingWrong
 

Jimayo

Well-Known Member
Jan 1, 2018
1,544
1,809
Personally I don't think either Jill or Sage did anything wrong.

But it's clear that some who are criticizing Sage for cheating on Chad put Jill on a pedestal, I'm just pointing out that she is not a paragon of virtue either.
Except all you are pointing out is that you need to listen to classical music more. Bump up that iq a few points.

She is not in a relationship with Tybalt. She does not want to be in a relationship with him. He is coercing her into dating him. You cannot cheat on someone you are not in a relationship with. This line of "logic" is more ridiculous than any of dalli's. Jill is far from perfect but she ain't no cheater.
 

ffive

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 19, 2022
6,089
14,085
That reminds me, what was that whole thing about Troy and the dorm room getting all fucked up? Was it ever explained or are just left to make assumptions?
My money's on Troy and Chad had a fight and he took the guitar. Otherwise, I don't really know how Chad had it in the first place. It's not like he was going to join the other jocks to randomly fuck up the guy's dorm room because they hate him so it can't be that. At first I thought Troy was involved in some sketchy shit and the other party took the guitar as collateral (that was before finding out about Chad).
I don't it was explained yet, or maybe i just missed/can't remember it. My guess would be that Chad with other jocks went to that room "to teach Fuckface a lesson" (which is also why they took the guitar), and while at it maybe some of these other jocks started shit with Troy due to him no longer being part of the fraternity etc, and Chad would allow that to happen to avoid blowing up his cover..? IDK.
 

Darkwen

Forum Fanatic
Nov 10, 2020
5,435
11,678
I can’t recall perfectly but doesn’t Sage say something to the effect of she didn’t cheat but she definitely thought about it, or wanted to cheat if you turn her down?

If you have slept with her she is blunt and says she cheated, if you don’t she says she functionally cheated.
Sage clearly tells chad she had cheated on him any if you didn't do anything with her I check my one of my josy saves
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Doowacko

allanl9020142

Well-Known Member
Aug 23, 2018
1,256
1,984
I don't it was explained yet, or maybe i just missed/can't remember it. My guess would be that Chad with other jocks went to that room "to teach Fuckface a lesson" (which is also why they took the guitar), and while at it maybe some of these other jocks started shit with Troy due to him no longer being part of the fraternity etc, and Chad would allow that to happen to avoid blowing up his cover..? IDK.
Yea actually, that makes a fuck ton more sense. I take my guess back. Unless, it's the one that turns out to be more on target then I'll say "I was right all along, idiots!" :geek:
But nah for real, my guess doesn't make any sense in retrospect lol
 

J_A_S_I_U

Newbie
Nov 3, 2018
30
76
With less than a week to go until the next release I wonder if there's anyone willing to share transfer saves with mini games disabled... I've seen ones from
SteveyP but personally I just want the novel part :)
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: SteveyP

RNasc4444

Active Member
Aug 16, 2022
947
3,906
Except all you are pointing out is that you need to listen to classical music more. Bump up that iq a few points.

She is not in a relationship with Tybalt. She does not want to be in a relationship with him. He is coercing her into dating him. You cannot cheat on someone you are not in a relationship with. This line of "logic" is more ridiculous than any of dalli's. Jill is far from perfect but she ain't no cheater.
Fucking good. Even Tybalt as bad as he is deserves better than that god-awful goblin. She is vile. I regret once stating in tis thread that they deserved each other and only one house would get ruined if they got together but I changed my mind. Tybbi is not on the same level of disgusting as her.
 

Tremonia

Justice for Finnabair!
Donor
Jun 14, 2020
2,702
8,417
Are you sure, because I remember her saying she cheated at first and then telling him that she didn't but she wanted to, or something along those lines?
If you are with Sage she says to Chad that she cheated on him. Right after telling him she knows for sure he is cheating. If you're not fucking her she said she wanted but didn't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Webleten
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes