osculim

Active Member
Aug 21, 2019
803
921
On what path are you ? Was this with you on the sage path.? My version is way different. She literally gave josy that look of discust and asked her wth she is doing. It could be that it is part of the Josy path. When you told them you want to be friends only and keep going to jozy side everytime. You even kiss josy at the sorority party. Somewhere I think a unseen split came up. The scene I refer to is where she and josy are standing to each other. There are so many twists and turns in this game. Guess we will have to wait a nd see
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,549
22,422
I think in my opinion this will happen here's the factors:

A unknown detail is that being on Chad good side:
Taking the Blame for the fight makes Chad cool with MC, even after picking that option Chad face pretty tells you he's shocked that you defended him.

During in ep.7 he will take one of his friends that MC is cool, when he friend wants to start shit.

And I think not facing Troy plays a part into as well.

Plus, not telling Sage & still dating her will probably trigger.

I mean it's crazy on how many trigger there is for Sage to break with MC:

I mean you fucked her mom; it's worse if The DIKs & Burke knows about it will use it against him & her in the future.
Him used the restaurant, and not telling Sage about it
Telling Josy about Chad & Troy relationship and not telling Sage. Like I call it now that Josy will slip up & tell her about it.
every BR drama will affect Sage, there is no wrongdoing or betrayal that does not involve her, even in the canon story.

normal that having had anything to do with Jade will be a problem (even just having accepted her advances in class?) and likewise being a customer at the restaurant (even though MC is aware of it anyway and in no way talks to Sage about it...)

on the other hand, the question of telling Sage about Troy and Chad in my opinion is more complicated, actually the only way for Sage to find out is for MC to confess it. it doesn't make sense for Josy to do it, after all the girl's initial advice is just not to get involved, why should she go and tell Sage about it? even if it happened by mistake it would be a really bad gesture on the part of a friend
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
Like the end of episode 8, with the ominous sound effects and that "Fuck, fuck, fuck" from Fuckface in the Burke's, which tried to anticipate big expectations for the next episode. And yet, what we got in episode 9 on that front was quite underwhelming, more like "Meh, meh, meh".
I know exactly what you mean. EP9 feels like an oversized free roam event where there was no obvious main story progress. But you should consider so that the "fuck, fuck, fuck" and another "fuck" could drag on throughout season 3. So why would DPC break up all those "fucks" into a single EP? That would take away the tension.

Furthermore, revealed in EP9 so that DPC can point out the past EPs and the mistakes that were made. Examples.

- Elena said to the MC so he would be her nemesis, the demigod. Why? In EP4 the MC can play the Sage Branch. Elena and JB get another girl every now and then for fun. But we know so JB isn't as hot as the MC and that's why Elena has to approach the girls to see if they are interested in a threesome. This can be read well in the Sage Rooster Cluck in EP4, which has the HOTs Movienight as a theme. Cowgirl Elena MC Titty (I think this is so awesome) said at the end of this conversation in the bathroom so the MC shouldn't come to here town anymore (Hots house). Why Isabella explains in EP2. The MC is the women's issue and Elena has a hard time finding a girl for a threesome because they get their hopes up for the MC.

- In EP4 the MC has the choice to sleep in either Josy's or Maya's bed. If the MC has had sex with both, the player has a third choice, which is to sleep on the floor. This option has it in it because the MC makes it clear here so he doesn't choose between Josy and Maya because he doesn't want to hurt either girl. In EP9, when the MC welcomes Josy and Maya to the party, he has a choice. Either he prefers Josy or Maya, or he compliments both. Now it gets more complicated. When the MC is asked to choose his three favorite costumes, I just check off Josy and Maya, but don't choose either of them. This actually confirms the sleeping on the floor option from EP4. Either a relationship with both or neither.

- Vinny says to MC, in a neutral decision of Major Choice, for the MC to be polite and submissive. This attitude is important in EP7 with Patrick, because Patrick then likes the MC. However, Vinny only says so that the MC should only act that way and not so that the MC is that way. "See, dog? That's how you should behave. Polite and submissive."

There are many such situations in EP9 that confirm or refute previous decisions. It doesn't just involve Josy and Maya, either. The point is what Nick said about Vinny in EP3. Vinny was a guy who did everything twice. That's why I figure for DPC to present us with clues on how to dodge mistakes when replaying BaDIK.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jumbi

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,549
22,422
Like the end of episode 8, with the ominous sound effects and that "Fuck, fuck, fuck" from Fuckface in the Burke's, which tried to anticipate big expectations for the next episode. And yet, what we got in episode 9 on that front was quite underwhelming, more like "Meh, meh, meh".
actually went even worse, to justify that scene we witnessed one of the saddest and most miserable scenes in BADIK, the impotence from Tybalt stress:oops::oops::oops:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jumbi

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
In the future, Chad will probably ask the MC if he's told his secret to anyone other than Sage. I don't see any point in telling Josy about Chad's homosexuality, but I do see consequences if the MC goes around talking to people other than Sage.
The point of telling Josy about Chad and Troy is so that the MC will trust Josy. Josy did prove yes so she can keep secret. She didn't tell Sage anything in regards to her relationship with Maya, she also didn't tell Sage so she could fuck the MC.

For a relationship to work, not only love is important, but also trust.:rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jumbi

osculim

Active Member
Aug 21, 2019
803
921
osculim
any path, just ask Josy to makeout with Sage, and Sage will gladly take the initiative (ep9 after you throw Oscar out)
but on the account that Sage is cold to Josy, there were enough scenes where the opposite is shown.
There are so many twists and turns in this game its hard to keep up. Even little things like liking a text on the cluck can make a difference in this game. Anyway that is what makes it fun. You never know where its heading
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
Clever. Josy will blurt out at some point, I don't know how anyone can trust Josy after that thing with the MC and Maya. Some people just like to play with fire I guess.
I was referring to Josy lying that she had a boyfriend when in fact she had a girlfriend and that she swings both ways. What were you referring to? :unsure:
Right here is the point. Josy did not lie to the MC and did not reveal any secret, which shows so that the MC can trust Josy.:rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Ness

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
every BR drama will affect Sage, there is no wrongdoing or betrayal that does not involve her, even in the canon story.

normal that having had anything to do with Jade will be a problem (even just having accepted her advances in class?) and likewise being a customer at the restaurant (even though MC is aware of it anyway and in no way talks to Sage about it...)

on the other hand, the question of telling Sage about Troy and Chad in my opinion is more complicated, actually the only way for Sage to find out is for MC to confess it. it doesn't make sense for Josy to do it, after all the girl's initial advice is just not to get involved, why should she go and tell Sage about it? even if it happened by mistake it would be a really bad gesture on the part of a friend
That's exactly why I want my MC to be Sage's best friend only, because she doesn't have anything like that in her life and maybe never has.
 

Lovetities

Active Member
Apr 3, 2020
655
1,340
I was referring to Josy lying that she had a boyfriend when in fact she had a girlfriend and that she swings both ways. What were you referring to? :unsure:
When did she lied about that? It was only Maya who lied. Josy said that she is in relationship and whatever she is doing is wrong. Which is understandable since Josy doesn't want to hide her relationship with Maya/fuckface and she doesn't care if other find out she is a lesbian I think.
 

felicemastronzo

Devoted Member
May 17, 2020
11,549
22,422
I feel that depends on the path you take. If you don't choose her path, the MC pretty much becomes her best friend.
I disagree

if you decide not to be her fuckbuddy, which is your first chance to start a romance with her, Sage playfully tries to seduce MC at the Preps party, and then proposes again at the HOTs party.

Josy likewise, in fact never gives up.

Only Bella and Maya seem to give up any romantic involvement serenely
 

dalli_x

Engaged Member
Jul 7, 2017
3,409
7,735
I don't see that Sage is looking for a best friend ... no LIs are looking for that
It is not that Sage is looking for a best friend, but that she has found a best friend without looking for one.

If in the later a relationship between Sage and the MC should come about, this relationship is not only based on sexual attraction, but has a stable basis of friendship.

But I can well imagine so that the Throuple would accept Sage as a fuck buddy. Josy and Maya find Sage hot and so does the MC.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dav3knight

Jumbi

With my good eye closed
Donor
Feb 17, 2020
1,592
4,484
Honestly I never really gave her shit for that. At least she was honest about being taken so it's on us for pursuing her. It's really Maya's fault for pretending she was single.
Maya did not fully pretend being single. She only told the MC that she had no boyfriend. It is not the truth, but it is not a lie either. It is more like half the truth. Still not sincere with the MC, mind you. But considering where she comes from, I can understand her doubts, her fears.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dalli_x

Takkatakka

Engaged Member
Nov 11, 2022
2,915
9,165
I disagree

if you decide not to be her fuckbuddy, which is your first chance to start a romance with her, Sage playfully tries to seduce MC at the Preps party, and then proposes again at the HOTs party.

Josy likewise, in fact never gives up.

Only Bella and Maya seem to give up any romantic involvement serenely
I was going off what we see in Ep. 9 if the MC tells her that he is together with someone else. She still has the hots fpr the MC probably, what what she really needs is someone to talk to.
 

Jumbi

With my good eye closed
Donor
Feb 17, 2020
1,592
4,484
The point of telling Josy about Chad and Troy is so that the MC will trust Josy. Josy did prove yes so she can keep secret. She didn't tell Sage anything in regards to her relationship with Maya, she also didn't tell Sage so she could fuck the MC.

For a relationship to work, not only love is important, but also trust.:rolleyes:
I would go further on this point. Without trust, love is not possible.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: dalli_x

Jumbi

With my good eye closed
Donor
Feb 17, 2020
1,592
4,484
There are so many twists and turns in this game its hard to keep up. Even little things like liking a text on the cluck can make a difference in this game. Anyway that is what makes it fun. You never know where its heading
I don't know the inner mechanics at play in the game very well. But from what I have gathered reading the guides of the game, liking or not clucks or messages on Rooster has no effect whatsoever on your stats or your relationship with the people involved. It is reacting (with a message) in different ways to some of those clucks that can have an effect in the form of +DIK or -DIK points or getting or losing RPs.
 
Last edited:
4.80 star(s) 1,553 Votes