- May 8, 2017
- 576
- 3,447
this is all i really have to say about this topic: all of the stuff you posted doesnt really matter to me much.If anything, I want to say to the Quinn fans. I don't hate your favorite waifu. Damn it, I like her character - complex and controversial.
But to whitewash her behavior, to turn a blind eye to the fact that she has committed many bad deeds is somehow strange. It is also strange to protect her by humiliating other girls in an attempt to make Quinn look better. This looks childish.
What would a good line of defense for Quinn look like:
"Quinn grew up in a highly hostile and toxic environment among drug thugs. She didn't have a normal childhood. Her father gave her terrible life lessons:
"Trust no one but your dad. Keep everyone else at arm's length".
What normal parent would give such advice? Quinn grew up socially aloof, with obvious signs of a sociopath. Growing up in a street gang, she does not recognize the normal foundations of society.
It is also possible that Quinn was physically and mentally abused. As a result, she considers any manifestations of love, friendship and normal social relations as a weakness. She mocks people to look cooler so that no one can see her broken and wounded soul.
Maybe it can be cured if you put her in a normal environment where she gets good treatment. So I see Quinn's redemption path as possible."
Written in an extremely simplistic way, because it takes more than a page of text to describe Quinn's psychology. But the direction is like this.
I wrote reviews like this shortly after I got here and what's interesting is people liked to discuss them, put forward counter-arguments and no one caught cringe.
Quinn is one of the most interesting characters in the game and her path feels like it respects the time required to put into it. This game is filled with stalling plotlines and boring junk like Maya's never ending tuition and cringey junk like Tybalt's blackmail with JIll.
While Quinn being a drug dealer and running a brothel is ludicrous, its more interesting on its face than those other lame plotlines AND it leads to actual gameplay moments as you can build relationships with the other HOTS through the restaurant. I have no interest in personally defending Quinn as a person, but as a character in this game and story she seems like she is integrated the best into a forward moving narrative that connects with worthwhile gameplay choices