Let's see.
Jill: 48 votes despite being pretty lacking in terms of both characterization and content compared to all other LIs, is quite a surprise. Then again, as I said before, she's beautiful, smart, stupid rich, has a warm personality, and is very patient and forgiving towards MC (doesn't get mad at him for grabbing her boobs). The perfect girlfriend on paper. Plus, the date in episode 4 was wholesome and ended in the best kiss scene of the season (imo).
Oh, and I found the music of the date:
You must be registered to see the links
Maya: 45 votes. Goes to show that those who hated her after all the shit she put MC through since episode 1 were ultimately a vocal minority. Gotta admire the loyalty of the Mayans. It helps that out of all LIs, she's the one who got the most focus in terms of character moments and screentime.
Bella: 37 votes. There is no question that she deserves those votes and more.
Sage: 20 votes. Fourth, but a distant fourth. How unfortunate that she's that far behind despite her solid characterization and her awesome content (she's the only LI so far who had uninterupted sex with MC).
Josy/Quinn: 10 votes, a tie. Despite the vocal love she gets, Quinn seems no match for all other LIs. Then again, she did steal MC's clothes and publicly humiliated him, tased him after having Maya grind him for no reason at all, attempt to have sex with MC, while he was tied up (and without his consent depending on your choices), hit him in the balls if he decides to leave Quinn's room, and in general being unpleasant towards Maya (and we've seen there is a lot of Mayans). I admit being surprised at Josy being that low, though I guess her low screentime in episode 2 and 3 since she couldn't join the school yet (and she was grounded), as well as the episode 4 drama must have contributed to it.
The rest are side-girls who have no hope of matching the rest in terms of characterization.